What Logan’s Birthday Watch Reveals About Tom Wambsgans
Did Tom Wambsgans Get What He Wanted ?
Before Tom Wambsgans gets anywhere near the chief executive’s office, he tags a little boy out at a family baseball game. Roman Roy has promised the boy a million dollars if he hits a home run. The child makes a decent fist of it. Tom could let him past. Imagine how little it would cost Tom to fumble the ball, or how much pleasure it might give him to make Roman honour the bet. Instead, he makes the play. Roman gets his laugh. Tom has done what a team member is supposed to do. The boy goes home.
There, in miniature, is the man who ends up running the American operations of Waystar Royco. Tom rarely invents the cruellest thing happening in a room. He notices which side he is on and plays his position with enthusiasm. Look at the game from where the boy is standing and the distinction between Roman and Tom gets rather small.
Then, three seasons later, this same man holds a phone to a dying father’s ear so his children can speak to him. He finds words for a situation in which an ill-chosen phrase might stay with somebody for the rest of their life. For those few minutes you would take Tom over almost anybody else on the plane. Matthew Macfadyen makes both men entirely believable. The pleasure, and occasional discomfort, of watching him is having to remember one when you are most inclined to love the other.
The Man Who Has to Ask What Things Cost
Tom’s first real ordeal is buying Logan Roy a birthday present. Shiv gives her boyfriend a rough price range, which leaves him with the problem of discovering what ten or fifteen thousand dollars’ worth of affection looks like to a billionaire. He settles on a Patek Philippe watch. On presenting it, he attempts a little sales patter about what it signals to other people. It is a ghastly thing to have to explain to Logan Roy that an expensive watch will let strangers know he is rich.
The watch ends up with the family of the boy from the baseball game. Tom has spent serious money trying to make an impression on one man. That man can give the object away without it making the slightest difference to his afternoon. You could spend a lifetime acquiring the budget for Logan’s birthday parties and still miss the defining luxury of his life, which is how little attention he has to pay to any of this.
Tom comes from St Paul, Minnesota. His mother is a lawyer. His parents can contribute the wine at an English castle wedding. The Roys make him seem provincial because their scale of wealth renders virtually everybody provincial. There is something rather lovely about his parents being proud of the wine. You can picture the conversation at home about wanting to do their bit. Tom knows what that contribution means. At his wedding, when he makes Nate pour his glass back into the bottle, the family wine becomes the means by which a humiliated bridegroom finally gets to humiliate somebody else.
That particular revenge is vintage Tom. He has every reason to resent the man who slept with Shiv. He also has a much more difficult conversation waiting for him with the person he has married. Sending Nate away gives him one clean, satisfying victory on an evening when almost everything that matters feels beyond his control. Making him put the wine back is the extra flourish. Tom wants the man to feel silly doing it.
What Does Tom Actually Love About Shiv?
It is tempting to settle the question by picking a motive. He married for love. He married for money. Shiv would have good reason to distrust either answer delivered on its own. Tom likes being rich and enjoys saying so. He also lights up at the prospect of being genuinely wanted by his wife. Much of the misery of their marriage comes from how often those desires point him in different directions while obliging him to go home to the same person.
Consider the proposal. Logan is in hospital, Shiv is frightened, and Tom chooses this extraordinary moment to ask her to marry him. You can see what might seem beautiful about the gesture from inside his head. Everything is uncertain. Here is something he can make certain. From Shiv’s side, accepting means making a permanent decision when she scarcely knows whether her father will live. Even at his most apparently sincere, Tom has managed to pick a moment that improves his chances. He may never have put it to himself in such unattractive terms. People seldom do.
Shiv pulls a more devastating version of the same trick on their wedding night. Now that the vows have been exchanged, she raises the possibility of an open marriage. The timing changes the meaning of the question. Tom can theoretically object. To do so, he would have to risk the marriage on its first night and admit how badly he misread the woman he has just promised to spend his life with. Macfadyen gives him the awful courtesy of a host reassuring a guest after a breakage. He starts looking after the person who has hurt him.
The account comes due on a beach, during the family’s deliberations over who should take responsibility for the cruises scandal. Tom finally tells Shiv that he has tried to imagine the sadness of leaving her and suspects staying might hurt more. What gives the scene its force is its modesty. He has no new lover waiting, no suitcase packed, no impressive threat to make. He has spent enough evenings unhappy to make a comparison. For once, Shiv has to entertain the possibility that somebody who wanted so much from her might eventually prefer a life without her.
Shiv subsequently asks Logan to spare him. It matters that she does. So does the fact that asking her father is one of the ways she knows how to express love. She can influence a decision capable of ruining Tom’s life. The ordinary work of sitting with him while he is afraid proves much harder for her. Tom will remember both things about his wife.
Greg Gets the Unabridged Tom Wambsgans
If you want to understand what Tom likes about power, book a table for him and Greg Hirsch. When Tom introduces Greg to eating ortolan, a tiny songbird served whole, the meal comes with a ritual and a story about shame. Much of the fun for Tom lies in supplying the commentary. Here, at last, is a man who knows less than he does about how rich people eat. Tom can watch Greg discover the rules in real time and, for the length of a dinner, experience himself as the person who has always known them.
Greg offers something Shiv cannot give him. He remembers Tom as the important man who showed him around on arrival. A Roy can always remember the watch. Greg’s attention gives Tom room to be grand, obscene, oddly literary and very funny. His sentences develop extra clauses. His voice acquires ceremony. Watch Macfadyen at work in those exchanges and you can see how much of Tom’s pleasure comes from waiting for Greg to catch up with the sentence he has just uttered.
There is affection here, and there is workplace abuse. A subordinate who depends on his boss’s favour has limited means of signalling when an entertaining double act has ceased to be entertaining. In “Safe Room”, Greg ventures that he might like to work elsewhere. Tom starts pelting him with water bottles. Greg has attempted a career conversation. Tom experiences it as a breakup and makes Greg physically endure the difference between their interpretations. Once Greg introduces the possibility of blackmail, Tom can take a certain pride in his protégé. A bid for ordinary independence offended him more.
Yet he keeps Greg’s confidence through Logan’s grotesque “Boar on the Floor” game. Offered a chance to divert attention towards the man who admitted speaking to Logan’s prospective biographer, Tom keeps quiet. Later, when prison seems a real possibility, he is willing to take responsibility for Greg’s involvement in the cruises affair. Nobody watching those scenes is obliged to write off the kindness because of the water bottles. Greg has discovered something both gratifying and dangerous about this relationship. Tom can be a considerable source of protection, including against conditions Tom himself helped create.
Their ending honours the whole peculiar arrangement. Greg passes information that could cost Tom the top job. They slap each other in a bathroom. After the deal goes through, Tom presses one of the family’s stickers for claiming possessions onto Greg’s forehead. The boy gets to stay. The price of admission has been neatly itemised on his face. It is probably the nearest these two will come to a renewal of vows.
The Cruises Papers and the Limits of His Conscience
Tom’s introduction to the misconduct buried in Waystar’s cruises division poses a question of a different order from what to wear to dinner. There are people outside the company whose lives have been grievously damaged. There are records. For a short time, as Tom absorbs what his predecessor has handed him, the possibility of bringing the whole thing into the open seems to exist. What he actually does is get Greg to dispose of documents. Greg quietly keeps some for himself.
Look at the distance between those two responses. Tom has enough moral imagination to recognise a horror when he hears about it. He has enough professional imagination to picture what might happen to the executive who announced it. The professional imagination wins. A younger employee gets the physical task of destroying records, with all the exposure that entails. An executive who felt sick about the cover-up has found a way to enlarge it.
The congressional hearing that follows gives the audience the considerable comic reward of watching an accomplished bully struggle to explain himself in public. Among the exhibits is an absurd email about Greg’s future at the company. Inside Waystar, Tom could take for granted that everyone would understand his peculiar mixture of threats, jokes and managerial instruction, or at least pretend to. Read back to him by somebody who owes him nothing, the words sound deranged. Anyone who has ever sent a joke on work email can feel a small pulse of sympathy. The gulf between the silliness of the email and the gravity of the hearing is harder to sit with.
It is worth dwelling on what Tom subsequently fears. He can imagine prison food, prison routines and the look of a place he might have to sleep. He takes Greg to a diner to practise eating bland meals. The detail is funny because his research is so earnest and the experiment so useless. He can leave the diner whenever he likes. His solicitude for his future incarcerated self occupies more space in his daily life than the people harmed by the company. Watching him fret, we can find ourselves extending much the same uneven distribution of sympathy. We know what Tom wants for dinner. The people in the files barely get names.
The One Thing Tom Knows About Logan
Kendall tries to recruit Tom when the possibility of prosecution is hanging over him. He has a plausible case, at least on paper. Logan might allow Tom to go to prison. Kendall offers him a way to fight back. Tom’s response is almost embarrassingly empirical. He has seen Kendall lose repeatedly. In his experience, Logan comes out on top. Kendall has spent much of his life imagining what he could become. Tom has been keeping track of results.
Being able to think that way is one advantage of arriving in the family as an adult. Logan’s children carry incompatible memories of their father into every negotiation. He promised them something. He once looked pleased. He withdrew his affection and might give it back. Tom can want desperately to please Logan without needing to reinterpret his childhood every time the man changes his mind. When Logan offers better odds, Tom can take them. It costs him dearly, but it costs him something different.
In Italy, Shiv lets Tom know the siblings are moving against their father over the GoJo sale. Tom tips Logan off. The siblings arrive believing they have the power to stop him and discover their parents have already changed the terms. Then Logan passes his son-in-law and allows him a brief gesture of acknowledgement. Shiv sees enough. By the time Tom approaches to comfort her, she has to stand there and accept consolation from the man who helped do this to her.
Imagine the scene with Tom gloating. It would diminish both the betrayal and the marriage. His instinct is still to go to his wife when she looks stricken. He would probably like to be the one she turns to. He has also arranged a future for himself that no longer depends entirely on her generosity. For three seasons he has asked some version of where he fits in her plans. Under pressure, he finally gives her an answer of his own. The violence of it comes partly from how familiar his consoling voice sounds.
The Phone Call at Connor’s Wedding
Logan’s death gives Tom one of the most demanding jobs anybody performs in Succession. He is on the plane. The children are elsewhere. Somebody has to describe what is happening to their father, and the children are going to remember whatever that person says. Tom has little reliable information, dreadful news and several people at the other end of the phone who need different things from him at once.
Listen to the care he takes with uncertainty. Roman wants room to believe his dad might still be all right. Kendall wants to know what medical help is being given. Shiv needs a chance to say goodbye after the others have already had theirs. Tom lets them speak. He puts the phone by Logan’s ear. He cannot promise anybody that Logan hears, but he can make sure they get to say the words. A man who usually talks until he has established his place in an exchange manages, under terrible circumstances, to make himself almost transparent.
This is one reason it feels inadequate to dismiss Tom as a fraud. There is a real ability beneath his talent for pleasing people. He can remain with another person’s distress, adjust his manner and perform a practical service while frightened himself. In another life it might have made him a good nurse, or simply the relative you want beside you at a hospital. Here it also makes him the employee who can stay on the line while dreadful things happen. What an employer does with that gift turns out to be an important question.
Meanwhile, as soon as he gets a chance, he has his own position to think about and instructions for Greg concerning a file. The professional reflex comes back with almost indecent speed. That feels true to the stranger rhythms of a death at work, especially when the dead man was also the owner. Somebody is crying. Somebody else needs access to a computer. Sometimes they are the same person.
Election Night and the Price of Being Agreeable
At ATN on election night, the virtues of the man on the plane become rather less attractive. There is uncertainty about the vote in Wisconsin after a fire has destroyed ballots. The network’s decision desk has grounds for caution. Roman wants a call that favours Jeryd Mencken. Kendall’s position is bound up with the future of the GoJo deal. Tom formally runs the network, which ought to make the integrity of its election coverage his particular responsibility.
He spends the night attending to who wants what from him, how much authority they can bring to bear and who will own the decision afterwards. It is an absorbing management problem if you leave out the electorate. The episode’s most savage joke is that the electorate can be left out so easily. A handful of exhausted people with private interests can get an enormous distance towards announcing a president while also arguing about the contents of a drink and trying to wash wasabi out of an analyst’s eye.
ATN calling the election cannot settle the legal count. It can shape what millions of viewers believe has already happened and what they will regard as an attempt to take it away. Tom knows the value of getting a particular person to say a particular thing at the right moment. He has built a career on it. He can hardly plead ignorance about the power of doing the same thing on television. The familiar comic sight of Tom glancing towards the most powerful person in the room now has people he will never meet on the receiving end.
Why Matsson Picks Tom
By the time Lukas Matsson considers who should run Waystar in America, the job has changed. Kendall grew up imagining that to succeed Logan was to occupy the position from which Logan bought companies, bent politicians’ ears and kept his children waiting. A sale to GoJo puts an owner above the American chief executive. Anyone interviewing for the role has to grasp that the chair might look just as impressive in photographs while conferring substantially less freedom on the person sitting in it.
Shiv has ideas. She has advised Matsson and helped him navigate her family. She expects to continue exercising judgement once he gives her the title. Tom offers something more congenial to a man who enjoys having ideas of his own and would like an American executive to carry them out. When Matsson makes a sexual remark about Shiv to her husband, the obscenity doubles as an interview question. What would it take for Tom to get up from this table? Matsson receives a disturbing degree of reassurance on that point.
There is genuine stamina in what Tom offers. He has run ATN, stayed at work through Logan’s funeral and learnt how to absorb a succession of unpleasant surprises without demanding a lengthy discussion of his feelings. A chief executive who can execute an owner’s decision, face employees afterwards and take the public blame is valuable. The awkward part is that Tom has spent years complaining, often quite reasonably, about people treating him this way. At dinner with Matsson he can finally name a price for the arrangement.
It would give Tom too much credit to treat this as a plan conceived over Logan’s birthday watch. For long stretches his ambition extends about as far as keeping his current job. Circumstances deliver an extraordinary vacancy. His great advantage is how little he has to change to fill it. Had Matsson wanted an independent American power base, many of the same qualities might have ruled Tom out. There is no general lesson here about the meek inheriting the earth. There is a particular buyer with a particular use for this particular man.
What Shiv’s Hand Tells Us About Tom’s Victory
Shiv’s deciding vote lets the sale go through. That outcome benefits her husband, although it would be a disservice to Shiv to treat her decision as a gift to him. She has just watched Kendall rehearse his entitlement to their father’s office. When she hesitates, his need for the job becomes frightening to witness at close quarters. Shiv has reasons to recoil from Kendall that predate her marriage, and reasons to resent Matsson that will survive his victory. A board vote gives her two boxes to tick. It tells us very little about how many feelings she has while ticking one.
Afterwards, Tom has things to do. There are people to greet, a photograph to pose for, a place for Greg to be determined. These are manageable expressions of success. Then he is alone in the back of a car with his pregnant wife. Tom puts out his hand. Shiv rests hers on it. Neither closes their fingers around the other’s.
Early in their marriage, Tom would have been capable of filling that silence with a quite exhausting number of words. He might have congratulated them both, proposed a celebratory dinner or attempted a joke that would oblige her to reassure him. The man in the car can wait for Shiv to make the next move. Perhaps that is the first small pleasure of the job. It also leaves him free to notice exactly how much affection comes back when he stops doing the work for two.
Think again of the boy running for home. Tom understood perfectly what counted as winning that afternoon. In the car, he has the title, the marriage, the money and even a prospective place for his oldest ally at work. All the things for which he once needed Shiv to put in a good word are his. What he wanted from her on the beach was some reason to believe that staying together might make him happy. Four seasons of exquisite social calculation have brought him to a question he could ask her right now. For once, Tom Wambsgans keeps his mouth shut.
Sources
Jesse Armstrong, Kieran Culkin and Matthew Macfadyen discuss Succession — Fresh Air
Jesse Armstrong discusses the ending of Succession — The Watch