COP31 Drops the Words ‘Fossil Fuels’. What Changed Between Monday’s Draft and Today’s?

Two Paragraphs On The Future Of Fossil Fuels Have Disappeared From The COP31 Draft.

On Monday, countries at the UN climate summit in Antalya had two proposals in front of them. One urged governments to move faster on the promise they made in Dubai to transition away from fossil fuels. The next went further and called for a phase-out. By Thursday, 19 November 2026, both paragraphs had gone. The revised draft runs to nine pages without using the words “fossil fuels” once.

One detail is easy to miss. Paragraph 39 of Thursday’s text still points governments back to the Dubai decision that contains the original pledge. What disappeared in Antalya was the proposal to single out that pledge and press countries to act on it faster. Meanwhile, a numerical target for electricity survived the cut. Read together, those edits show where negotiators could still put a number on the energy transition and where they could no longer name the fuels it would displace.

What Did Monday’s Draft Say About Coal, Oil And Gas?

The clearest way to see what changed is to open Monday’s draft at paragraphs 65 and 66. They sit next to each other on page eight, and they ask governments to do different things.

Paragraph 65 starts with an agreement already on the books. At COP28 in Dubai in 2023, countries agreed to contribute to a global transition away from fossil fuels in energy systems. The wording allowed for different national circumstances and called for faster action during this decade. Monday’s draft identified the precise paragraph of that decision, reaffirmed it and urged countries to accelerate implementation.

It also picked up a practical piece of the Dubai deal. Governments were urged to phase out inefficient fossil-fuel subsidies, with qualifications for measures that address energy poverty or help people through the transition. That qualification matters to a government trying to withdraw support for a fuel while keeping heating or cooking affordable.

Paragraph 66 was shorter and more ambitious. It proposed accelerating action to phase out fossil fuels and called for the transition away from them in energy systems to begin immediately. Even this stronger wording gave no date for the last coal plant to close or the last gas boiler to be replaced. What it offered was an explicit destination and a demand to start moving towards it now.

Neither paragraph had won agreement. The presidency said when it circulated the first draft that it had included proposals some countries had already indicated they opposed. Monday’s 18 pages recorded the range of positions negotiators wanted considered. Thursday’s nine pages give a better indication of what the presidency thought might command agreement before the scheduled close on Friday.

The Dubai Pledge Survives Through Paragraph 39

Thursday’s draft contains 80 numbered paragraphs, down from 144. In paragraph 39, governments are asked to carry out their national climate and adaptation plans promptly, drawing on the outcome of the first global stocktake. That is the UN process for assessing collective progress under the Paris Agreement. Its first outcome was the decision adopted in Dubai.

Follow that reference back to Dubai and the fossil-fuel commitment is there in paragraph 28(d). Monday’s draft took readers straight to it. Thursday’s points them to the much larger decision, which also covers renewable power, energy efficiency, methane and a host of other priorities. A government could endorse paragraph 39 without having to say again, in Antalya, that it supports a faster move away from coal, oil and gas.

The difference matters when a minister returns home. Monday’s wording would have given a parliamentarian a straightforward question to ask about the next energy budget. If the government has just backed faster implementation of the fossil-fuel pledge, which investments or subsidies will it change? Thursday’s wording gives that minister greater latitude to explain which parts of the Dubai outcome the national plan advances.

The Electricity Target Kept Its Number

Paragraph 36(d) shows how specific the revised draft can be when it sets out what countries might build. It retains the proposal for electricity to supply 35 per cent of the world’s final energy consumption by 2035. Final energy is the energy households, businesses, industry and transport actually use. Petrol in a car and gas burned in a factory count alongside electricity drawn from the grid.

Replacing a petrol car with an electric one changes that share. So does replacing a gas boiler with a heat pump. The emissions saving then depends in part on how the additional electricity is generated. A country can electrify more journeys and buildings while its gas-fired power stations continue to operate. To understand what happened to gas use, one would also need to know how much demand grew and which generators supplied it.

Thursday’s draft recognises that connection. It places electrification alongside efforts to triple global renewable energy capacity and double the worldwide rate of energy-efficiency improvement by 2030. It also mentions storage and stronger grids. The 35 per cent figure gives countries a measure of progress on electrification. It leaves open a separate question that Monday’s paragraphs addressed directly. How quickly should the world reduce its reliance on the fuels already in use?

What Stayed In On Warming And Carbon Removal?

The revised text expresses concern that global warming is projected to peak above 1.5 degrees Celsius relative to pre-industrial levels. It calls for countries to limit both how far temperatures overshoot that level and how long the overshoot lasts. Those are separate concerns. The same peak temperature could expose people and ecosystems to very different risks depending on how many years warming stays there.

Paragraph 33 gives carbon dioxide removal a role in meeting the long-term temperature goal. Removal means taking carbon dioxide already in the atmosphere back out. Capturing carbon dioxide at an industrial plant before it reaches the air does a different job, although the draft discusses both technologies.

There is a condition attached to the removal proposal. Governments say it should complement deep emissions cuts and should never become grounds for postponing them. Elsewhere, competing figures for industrial carbon capture remain in square brackets, the visible sign of a choice negotiators have yet to settle. That makes the treatment of fossil fuels particularly striking. The capture proposals remain on the page for countries to bargain over. Both of Monday’s explicit fossil-fuel proposals have been taken out.

A $120 Billion Question Also Changed Shape

For countries already paying to protect water supplies, homes and coastlines, another deletion carries immediate weight. Monday’s paragraph 73 proposed that tripling finance for climate adaptation should bring the total to at least $120 billion. It asked developed countries to explain how they would increase their contributions to get there.

Thursday keeps the call for efforts to at least triple adaptation finance by 2035. But paragraph 43 now asks a finance committee to identify possible starting points for that calculation. Tripling a sum sounds precise until the parties have to agree which year, which flows of money and which starting figure count.

There is a trap for anyone searching the revised document for the dollar figure. The words “$120 billion” still appear. In paragraph 54, however, they refer to annual climate finance that multilateral development banks aim to deliver by 2030. That is a different sum, from different institutions, covering a broader purpose. Finding it on the page does not restore Monday’s proposed minimum for adaptation.

What Would Count As A Change In The Final Deal?

The next version could restore the Dubai wording, bring back the stronger phase-out proposal or retain Thursday’s broad reference to the stocktake. The test is whether governments are again asked explicitly to move away from fossil fuels and, if so, what action or timetable accompanies those words.

As of 19 November, Antalya has produced a draft that can tell readers what share of global energy electricity should supply in 2035. It can tell them that countries should limit the height and duration of a temperature overshoot. The question it leaves unanswered is the one Monday’s two paragraphs put directly to governments. How quickly are they prepared to move away from coal, oil and gas?

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

Denmark Has Approved the Greenland Deal. What Can the US Now Do on the Island?

Next
Next

What Did Trump, Xi and Putin Agree in Shenzhen, and What Did They Leave Open on Ukraine?