The Future of TV Safeguards
Crew Raised Concerns. What Happened Next?
A runner on a television show can be asked to fetch almost anything. What happens when a presenter asks for an audience member’s phone number? On programmes Russell Brand made for Endemol, concerns about requests like that reached senior staff. Years later, an investigation commissioned by Banijay UK, which had acquired Endemol, found that nobody had made a formal complaint. It also found that people had spoken up. The failure came after somebody listened.
That distinction matters as Culture Secretary Lisa Nandy presses entertainment executives to improve protections for workers and young people. On 16 November, Nandy was due to meet industry leaders, including BBC director general Matt Brittin. Ministers are considering whether companies should have to participate in an independent industry standards body. Broadcasters already have a more immediate choice. They can change who takes responsibility when a junior colleague brings them a concern, even if the colleague never uses the word “complaint”.
Why Brand and Walliams Are in the Same Political Debate
On 9 November, Southwark Crown Court sentenced Brand to ten years and six months in prison for raping one woman and sexually assaulting three others between 2004 and 2009. In his sentencing remarks, Mr Justice Bennathan said that Brand’s status had protected him until journalists brought allegations to public attention in 2023.
David Walliams faces allegations which he denies. On 13 November, the Metropolitan Police confirmed it had opened an investigation after receiving several reports of alleged historical sexual offences. Police said those reports were separate from the accounts published by ITV News and the Guardian following their investigation into allegations involving teenage girls and young women. Officers were also reviewing the published accounts. The allegations against Walliams remain unproven.
The distinction matters to the women who gave evidence at Brand’s trial and to everyone involved in the ongoing Walliams investigation. What brings the stories together in Parliament is a question about power. When a well-known entertainer has access to staff, audiences and fans through work, who has the authority to set a boundary and make it stick?
What a Broadcaster Can Miss Even When Someone Speaks Up
Two reviews of Brand’s work found different points at which a concern could go astray. At Endemol, senior staff heard informally about runners being asked to obtain audience members’ phone numbers and about women on the crew feeling uncomfortable around Brand. The review found no clear procedure at the time for passing those concerns upwards. Consider what that meant for a runner. They could tell someone with more authority, finish their shift and reasonably believe they had done everything expected of them. The manager could leave the same conversation without understanding that a decision now rested with them.
Channel 4’s own review identified a different failure. In 2009, a staff member made a serious allegation about Brand’s conduct. Procedures already existed, but the allegation failed to reach senior management and the channel acknowledged it had failed to investigate it properly. Channel 4 apologised. Its review also found no evidence that employees had known about the specific alleged behaviour later described in the Dispatches documentary.
There is a practical lesson in reading the two findings together. A production can write a perfectly clear policy for the person raising a concern and still leave the person receiving it with too much discretion. A producer who hears a troubling account could be required to ask what the person needs now, explain who may have to be told, and record who has agreed to follow up. The worker would then have a name to contact if another week went by in silence.
Who Answers Once a Freelancer’s Contract Ends?
A television series has a peculiar deadline for anyone deciding whether to speak up. The studio empties, the production office closes and colleagues scatter to other jobs. Someone who felt able to talk only after the final recording can find that the work email address they were given has disappeared. A freelancer hoping for another booking has an additional calculation to make if the person hearing the complaint also picks the next crew.
One option under discussion is compulsory participation in the Creative Industries Independent Standards Authority, known as CIISA. Its reporting portal already accepts concerns from people whose organisations have never registered with it. What compulsory participation could change is the company’s position. An individual can already knock on the door. The unresolved question for ministers is what the organisation on the other side should be required to do when a concern reaches it.
A broadcaster could make part of that answer a condition of buying a programme. Before filming, the production company would identify someone outside the immediate team who could receive a complaint. When the series ended, the broadcaster would retain a working contact for former crew. A runner hired for two days would know where to go six months later, even if they could no longer remember the surname of their production manager.
Where Should a Presenter’s Access to the Audience End?
The phone-number example suggests a relatively simple change. A production can tell everyone, including the presenter, exactly what audience contact details are for. A researcher may legitimately need to ring someone about a recording time. Passing the same number to a performer for personal use is a separate decision, one a junior crew member should never have to negotiate in front of the person asking.
For programmes involving teenagers, the equivalent questions begin at booking and continue after filming. Who can invite a young guest backstage? Who knows where that guest is expected to be? If a message arrives later from somebody the teenager met at the studio, can the teenager or their parent reach a safeguarding contact without going back through the sender?
Those are choices a production can make before it knows who the star will be. Put the contact on the booking confirmation. Give staff a named person authorised to decline an unscheduled visit. Tell the presenter the rules at the same briefing. Each step takes a decision that might otherwise fall to the youngest or least powerful person in the room and gives it to someone paid to make it.
What Ministers Could Do About Confidentiality
Nandy told MPs that she had discussed non-disclosure agreements with the Ministry of Justice and would raise them with industry leaders. For television workers, the uncertainty can begin well before lawyers become involved. Imagine signing a confidentiality clause to work on an unannounced series. Months later, would you know, from the wording you signed, whom you could tell about an incident backstage?
Commissioners could require suppliers to spell that out in ordinary language and give crew a copy they can keep when a job ends. There is also a good reason to handle a report discreetly. A person raising an allegation may want their identity shared with as few people as possible, and a person facing an allegation deserves a fair opportunity to respond. A useful policy would explain who needs access to an account, how it will be used and when the person who gave it can expect an update.
As of 16 November, compulsory participation in CIISA remained an option for ministers. The talks themselves had introduced no new obligation. Broadcasters do, however, have a way to test their own promises the next time they decide whether to order another series.
An executive considering a renewal could ask to see what happened to concerns raised during the last run. How long did someone wait for a reply? Did a former freelancer manage to reach anybody after filming ended? Where a concern involved the star, who made the decision about what happened next? Those questions leave room to protect identities and to distinguish an allegation from a finding. They also make it harder to treat an empty complaints file as proof that everyone was safe. In the case of the runners asked for phone numbers, the record now shows exactly why someone needed to ask a second question. What did the people they told actually do?
Sources
Southwark Crown Court — Russell Brand sentencing remarks, 9 November 2026
ITV News — Metropolitan Police statement on the Walliams investigation, 13 November 2026
Banijay UK — findings of the independent review into Brand’s work for Endemol
Reuters — safeguarding proposals and the ministerial meeting, 16 November 2026