What Does the Pear Tree Mean in Their Eyes Were Watching God?
Janie Walks Past the People Telling Her Story
Janie Crawford comes home to Eatonville at sundown, wearing overalls. The people on the porch remember the dress she left in, the younger man who went with her and the money she had at her disposal. From a change of clothes and the absence of a companion, they can construct a whole history of her humiliation before she has eaten her supper. Janie gives them a greeting and keeps walking. Zora Neale Hurston’s Their Eyes Were Watching God begins with that small exercise of judgement. Janie has a story she wants to tell. The question is who has earned the right to hear it.
What Pheoby Brings to the Back Steps
Pheoby Watson leaves the talkers and takes Janie a dish of rice. She knows her friend has made a long journey and might be hungry. Once they are together, she can admit that she would like to know what happened as much as anyone else. Janie welcomes her curiosity. Bringing supper has already established that Pheoby can think of something Janie might need before thinking about what she wants from Janie.
The two women settle down to talk. Janie is content for Pheoby to pass the story on if she chooses. That permission makes the design of the novel more interesting than a simple opposition between private truth and public gossip. Janie knows perfectly well that people live by telling stories about one another. She likes a good story herself. What she claims is a say in how hers reaches the world. Somewhere between the experience and the next telling, she wants a listener who loves her enough to hear her out.
To explain the woman who has come back, Janie begins with a girl who once failed to recognise herself in a photograph. She grew up among the white children of the family for whom her grandmother worked. When a group photograph is taken, she identifies the other children and asks where she is. The Black child she has overlooked is herself. Everyone else laughs because the answer seems obvious. For Janie, an image that apparently settles who she is has recorded something she could never have seen from inside her own eyes. Eatonville’s porch has just made much the same mistake in reverse. The neighbours recognise her on sight and assume that this tells them how it felt to be her.
Beneath the Pear Tree
At sixteen, Janie lies beneath a blossoming pear tree and watches a bee enter a bloom. What seizes her imagination is the answering movement of the whole tree. The encounter seems to complete something that both bee and blossom have been prepared for. Before she has the experience to put her desire into ordinary words, Janie acquires an image against which she can measure what other people call love. Somebody choosing her will be only half the matter. She wants to feel herself answer.
When Johnny Taylor comes along the road, she lets him kiss her across the gate. Her grandmother, Nanny, sees them. To Janie, the kiss belongs to the afternoon under the tree. To Nanny, it raises the terrifying possibility that a girl she has spent her old age protecting might soon be pregnant and alone. The two women are looking at the same ordinary boy. The distance between what they see is the distance between Janie’s spring afternoon and the history Nanny has survived.
Nanny was enslaved. Her enslaver fathered her daughter Leafy, and his wife threatened mother and baby. Years later, Leafy was raped by her schoolteacher and gave birth to Janie. Raising her granddaughter, Nanny has tried to interrupt a history in which Black women’s labour and bodies were available to people with power over them. For her, a farm, a house and a husband with the means to defend both represent extraordinary gains. Before she dies, she wants to know whose door Janie can close against the world.
Her choice is Logan Killicks, an older farmer with substantial land. Janie tries to believe that marriage will bring the feeling she saw expressed in the pear tree. She has no wish to hurt Nanny and no evidence from her own experience that marriage cannot perform this transformation. After the wedding she waits for love to arrive as if it were one of the ordinary changes that follow a season. When she goes back to tell her grandmother that nothing has happened, Nanny hears a complaint about a good house from a girl too young to know its price.
Both women understand something the other cannot afford to lose. Janie scarcely knows what it cost Nanny to make her childhood possible. Nanny has had so little opportunity to ask what she herself might have wanted from love that she cannot build that question into her plans for Janie. Soon after their conversation, Nanny dies. Janie is left with a husband, a viable farm and the peculiar loneliness of having nobody left to disappoint by admitting what she thinks of either.
What Joe Starks Offers at the Gate
Logan’s early attentiveness wears away. He begins measuring Janie against the work a wife might do, including helping with the ploughing. His plan to obtain another mule carries a disturbing implication for her. A second animal would let a second person work the land, and Logan has already identified the person. Nanny imagined the farm as protection against a life of compulsory labour. Logan looks across the same acreage and sees an extra pair of hands going to waste.
While Logan is away, Janie meets Joe Starks, whom she comes to call Jody. He is travelling to Eatonville, a town being built and governed by Black people. Joe has money saved, fine clothes and something Logan has never offered her: an account of a future large enough to interest him in talking about it. He imagines shops, land and public office. Janie is attracted to what he can see beyond the present arrangement. For a girl who has been asked to wait patiently for her feelings to catch up with somebody else’s decision, a man walking purposefully down the road has considerable appeal.
Janie leaves Logan and marries Joe. His ambitions prove remarkably well founded. He buys land to expand Eatonville, establishes a store and becomes mayor. Residents acquire a place to buy supplies, collect mail and meet after work. Joe’s leadership has tangible benefits, and Hurston gives him the intelligence and energy his rise requires. His problem as a husband emerges from the way he imagines success. There is a place for Janie in his picture of a prosperous town. He considers the matter settled once he has put her in it.
At the celebration of his election, someone asks the new mayor’s wife to speak. Joe answers for her. He announces that speechmaking is outside her line and assigns her to the domestic sphere before she has opened her mouth. Janie herself has barely had time to discover whether she wants to give a speech. That detail makes the moment sting. Joe has done more than prevent a particular performance. He has taken away the interval in which she might have decided for herself.
The Mayor’s Wife Behind the Counter
Joe’s store becomes the great listening post of Eatonville. Men on the porch invent stories, argue over impossible questions and turn one another’s misfortunes into extended comic performances. Janie hears how they do it. A speaker can offer an extravagant proposition, wait for a challenge and improve the story by answering it. The outrageousness is part of the pleasure. Having sat through those afternoons, we can recognise why Janie would want a different kind of audience when the material under discussion is her own life.
Joe expects her to work in the store while holding herself apart from the people who make it worth visiting. Her hair becomes a particular concern. After he sees another man secretly enjoying its touch, Joe makes her cover it at work. He gives her an instruction where he might have admitted a feeling. She experiences the discomfort of the head-rag every day without ever being invited into the conversation about jealousy that produced it. The mayor can settle a problem his wife does not know they have by changing what she wears.
The town’s treatment of Matt Bonner’s overworked mule gives Janie a rare opening. The animal has become the subject of elaborate jokes. When the men torment it in front of her, she voices her disgust. Joe buys the mule and allows it to live out its days free of work. Janie praises him, and he deserves some of the praise. He has heard a complaint and used his money to remedy an actual cruelty. But when the mule dies and the town turns its funeral into a comic public occasion, Joe leaves Janie behind. She helped make the story possible. The husband who gets to preside over its finale will also decide whether she may attend.
Years of such arrangements change the marriage. Janie learns to keep an interior life beyond Joe’s reach. It is an effective defence, but it carries a cost. He can live beside her for years without having to discover the extent of her withdrawal. As he ages, he draws attention to supposed faults in her ageing body. Then, after he humiliates her in the store over the way she cuts tobacco, she answers loudly enough for the men to hear. Her reply turns his attack on her appearance back on his sexual pretensions. The witnesses who ordinarily confirm his authority now hear it come apart in his own shop.
Joe strikes her. Their estrangement deepens, and his health deteriorates. By his deathbed, Janie is determined that he will hear what living as his wife has cost her. He would prefer to keep her out of the room. She insists on speaking, telling him how little space his ambitions left for the person he married. The timing makes this a painful victory. She can finally finish a sentence he would rather interrupt, but their marriage has reached the point where there will be no ordinary morning afterwards on which either person might try again.
When Joe dies, Janie takes down her hair and looks at herself. Then she arranges her appearance and goes to announce his death. Public mourning and private feeling run on different clocks. She recognises the solemn part the town expects her to play and can perform it convincingly. She also discovers that a widow with money has options unavailable to a girl whose grandmother needs to settle her future. She can afford to wait and see what she actually likes.
Why a Game of Checkers Matters
The answer starts with a board game. A younger man comes into the store and asks Janie to play checkers. His name is Vergible Woods, although everybody calls him Tea Cake. For years she has watched men play. Nobody has treated the mayor’s wife as a likely opponent who might enjoy learning the moves. Tea Cake pulls her into the game easily enough that she can enjoy herself before wondering what his attention means.
It is a more persuasive beginning than a declaration of love would have been. Janie already knows what it is to have a man describe the wonderful life he intends to give her. Here she can test the offer in the time it takes to play. Does he like her company when she is inexperienced? Will he teach her something he enjoys? Is there room for her to surprise him? An evening fishing, an outing and the small jobs he does around her garden give her other occasions to find out. She gets a series of ordinary days on which affection can prove pleasurable in practice.
Eatonville sees an affluent widow and a younger working man spending her period of mourning in conspicuous enjoyment. The neighbours have legitimate grounds to wonder about money. Pheoby raises the risk with her friend because there are women who have lost both their savings and the men who promised to share them. Janie takes the warning seriously enough to protect some money. She refuses to treat another woman’s bad experience as a complete prediction of her own. Nanny made a decision for her under the pressure of everything that might go wrong. This time Janie will make the decision and carry its risks herself.
She and Tea Cake marry in Jacksonville. An early incident makes the financial danger real. Janie has brought two hundred dollars. Tea Cake finds it, takes it without permission and spends much of it throwing a party to which he does not invite her. She wakes to his absence and has ample time to remember what happened to other trusting women. When he comes back, the injury she most wants him to understand is surprisingly particular. He assumed she would look down on the working people at his party. She would have liked to go.
Tea Cake wins the money back by gambling, getting hurt in the process. The recovery matters, although returning the money cannot undo the night of fear. Their more consequential agreement concerns what they will share. Janie has no interest in being placed on another polished pedestal, even by a man anxious to spare her an uncomfortable evening. If the pleasure of his life lies among people he thinks too rough for her, she wants the opportunity to meet them and form her own opinion.
What Janie Finds on the Muck
They move to the fertile farming country around Lake Okeechobee in the Florida Everglades. On the muck, seasonal workers harvest beans, earn money and gather after work to play music, gamble and talk. Tea Cake teaches Janie to shoot. She becomes a good shot through practice, a detail that belongs first to their enjoyment of each other. Hurston is careful to let Janie have an accomplishment before the plot has any urgent need for it.
Janie eventually goes out to pick beans beside Tea Cake. The movement from Logan’s farm to these fields can look contradictory. She left a husband partly because he expected hard labour and now undertakes hard labour with another. What has changed is visible at the end of the day. She shares the jokes that came out of the work. People gather at their house, and she can contribute to their talk. The mayor’s wife stood behind a counter listening to other people turn their days into stories. The woman in overalls has spent the day among the storytellers.
Life on the muck also brings Janie into contact with Mrs Turner, a light-skinned Black woman who admires Janie’s features and disparages darker-skinned Black people, including Tea Cake. Mrs Turner imagines that Janie ought to share her preferences and would make a more suitable partner for her lighter-skinned brother. Her attention makes for an uncomfortable variation on the admiration Janie has received throughout the book. A woman can profess the most flattering opinion of your appearance while regarding the life you have chosen as an embarrassing error she is entitled to correct.
Tea Cake responds to the perceived challenge by beating Janie. Hurston gives the reason with disturbing clarity. Janie has given him no cause to think she plans to leave. He wants reassurance of possession, and he wants other people to see who holds authority in his marriage. Some of the men around him respond with envy. Their approval makes the episode worse because it shows what Tea Cake stands to gain socially from hurting someone he loves.
Janie’s happiness with him is real, and so is the violence. The uncomfortable feature of her account is that she keeps both. Tea Cake invited her into games from which other men excluded her. On this occasion he treats her body as a way to settle a question between men. A reader who dismisses the assault because the courtship was loving repeats the indulgence of his admirers. A reader who treats the assault as proof that Janie never knew happiness on the muck takes another decision out of her hands. She has come back to tell Pheoby what living there contained.
What the Hurricane Changes
Signs of a coming storm reach the settlement. Seminole travellers are moving towards higher ground. Animals are leaving. Some workers take the warnings seriously and depart. Others look to the conduct of people with property, resources and supposedly better information. Tea Cake stays. An established crop is ready to bring in money, and influential people appear willing to remain where they are. Waiting makes economic sense until events move beyond the point where money can buy back the lost time.
The hurricane arrives, and Lake Okeechobee rises against the people who relied upon the land around it. Indoors, with the wind making ordinary conversation increasingly inadequate, Janie, Tea Cake and their companion Motor Boat wait through the darkness. This is the setting for the novel’s title. They can no longer take their bearings from an employer, a neighbour or a confident speaker on a porch. Looking into the dark, they confront the question of what power, if any, is looking back. The scene offers no assurance that the people watching most faithfully will get out alive.
When Janie and Tea Cake flee the flood, survival depends on temporary footholds and things that float. A cow swimming in the water offers Janie a means of keeping herself above it. A terrified dog is riding on the animal’s back. As Janie takes hold, the dog turns on her. Tea Cake comes to her aid, kills the dog and suffers a bite to his cheek. In the immediate accounting of the rescue, both people have survived. The wound seems small beside what has nearly happened to them.
The aftermath exposes a difference that the flood itself had little reason to observe. In Palm Beach, armed white men compel Tea Cake to help bury the dead. The workers are instructed to distinguish white bodies, for whom coffins are reserved, from Black bodies destined for a common grave. Even identifying individuals has become desperately difficult. The authorities nevertheless insist on recovering a racial hierarchy from the wreckage. The scene gives a bitter precision to Tea Cake’s earlier confidence in following the lead of white property holders. Sharing their estimate of the weather never meant sharing their protection.
Why Janie Has to Defend Herself
After Janie and Tea Cake return to the muck, Tea Cake becomes ill. He has trouble swallowing water, and his behaviour grows fearful and suspicious. Dr Simmons connects the symptoms to the dog bite. In the novel, his judgement is devastating. The dog had rabies, the illness has taken hold and Tea Cake is in grave danger. Janie pursues medical help because she loves him and because the alternative is unbearable. Her devotion can keep him company. It cannot make him understand what is happening inside him.
Tea Cake’s old jealousy now acquires a terrifying new force. He suspects Janie of an interest in Mrs Turner’s brother and has a pistol within reach. Janie understands that there may come a moment when the man she knows will look at her and see someone who means him harm. She takes precautions that give her a brief chance to survive such a confrontation. Even then, she stays close enough to care for him. The difficulty is cruelly practical. The distance at which she can be of use to her husband is also the distance at which he can kill her.
When Tea Cake turns the pistol on her, Janie has only moments in which to distinguish intention from capacity. She knows the illness has transformed him. She also knows the weapon is real. As he continues trying to fire, she shoots him with the rifle. He dies in her arms. The ability he taught her during their happier days has enabled her to survive him. Hurston gives that fact its full weight without turning the earlier shooting lessons into ominous rehearsals. They were occasions of pleasure when they happened. Grief is partly the work of keeping hold of that earlier meaning once the later one exists.
Janie is tried for killing him. Some of Tea Cake’s Black friends are openly hostile to her. They knew and loved him, and his death has left them with a need to locate responsibility somewhere. White women in the courtroom sympathise with Janie. A white male jury acquits her after hearing the circumstances, including the medical evidence. None of those alignments makes the courtroom an uncomplicated place of justice. People can arrive at a humane verdict while still knowing very little about the two people whose marriage has been examined.
Hurston gives Janie’s testimony largely through narration instead of reproducing a grand courtroom speech. We learn what she tries to make the jury see. She wants them to understand what Tea Cake meant to her and what the illness had done by the time he raised the pistol. The verdict answers the legal question. It cannot give Janie what she most wants from the telling, which is for another person to know the man who lived before he became the subject of a trial. For that she needs the much longer conversation the novel has been giving us all along.
What Janie Brings Home to Eatonville
Janie gives Tea Cake a funeral in Palm Beach and wears overalls, having been too occupied by grief to dress for an audience. When Joe died, she knew exactly how his widow ought to appear and arranged herself accordingly. Her clothes at Tea Cake’s funeral express a different relation to being watched. She has attended to the burial of the person she loves. Whether a stranger can recognise the depth of that love from the cut of her clothes no longer seems an especially pressing problem.
She cannot stay on the muck once Tea Cake is gone. Of the things from their home, she keeps a packet of garden seeds he bought to plant. A grand memento would be a poor substitute. Tea Cake was always planting things. The seeds bring back the man who once worked in her garden in Eatonville, when the neighbours saw the town’s wealthiest widow spending far too much time with a younger man. Janie remembers that he noticed what was growing outside her window and took pleasure in tending it.
Now the story has caught up with the woman who walked past the porch. Pheoby says that hearing Janie has changed the size of her own life. Her immediate ambition is wonderfully unsolemn. She means to get her husband, Sam, to take her fishing. This is the first consequence of Janie’s testimony that Janie can actually witness. Her friend has heard about desire, violence, bereavement and a trial, and has identified one small pleasure she would like to stop missing out on. The telling has given somebody else a reason to act.
Alone upstairs, Janie can remember Tea Cake as he was across the span of their life together. The scene of his death has no exclusive right to represent him. Hurston ends with Janie drawing the horizon towards herself like a net. As a girl she had looked out from beneath the pear tree, waiting to find a life equal to what she imagined there. She comes home carrying what the journey yielded, with authority to decide what to do with it.
Down the road, the porch sitters still have the overalls to talk about. Pheoby has an invitation to go fishing to negotiate. Janie has a packet of seeds. Of those three inheritances from the same evening, the seeds are the quietest and the most characteristic. Tea Cake bought them for something he expected to live to do. Janie remembers him clearly enough to know what that was, and she has brought them home to plant.
Sources
Their Eyes Were Watching God — Faded Page. The novel’s text, including the opening conversation, the hurricane, Janie’s trial and the garden seeds. fadedpage.com
Their Eyes Were Watching God — National Endowment for the Arts. Publication details and literary background for Hurston’s 1937 novel. National Endowment for the Arts
Their Eyes Were Watching God: Full Book Summary — SparkNotes. Supporting chronology for the marriages, the illness and the return to Eatonville. SparkNotes
Next Reads
Beloved Explained: Sethe, the Haunting and Toni Morrison’s Ending — For another account of the distance between knowing what a woman did and understanding the history she brings to that moment.
The Grapes of Wrath Summary and Ending Explained: The Joad Family, the Peach Strike and the Barn — Steinbeck also follows agricultural workers whose knowledge of the land offers little protection when the water rises.
Jane Eyre Explained: Love, Independence and the Secrets of Thornfield — Compare two heroines who have to decide what material security is worth if a prospective husband has already defined the life they are to lead.