Why Bruno Fernandes Still Has Pochettino’s Backing After the Carrick Fallout
Bruno Fernandes Will Lead United At Anfield, But Who Will Lead Them Next Season?
“Bruno is our captain.” Mauricio Pochettino needed four words on Friday to settle who would wear the armband when Manchester United face Liverpool. Whether Bruno Fernandes will still be at Old Trafford next season is a question with a rather longer answer.
Speaking at Carrington on 20 November, United’s new head coach called Fernandes an important player, then used the rest of his answer to talk about his team-mates. He had spent around three hours the previous day speaking individually with members of the squad. Some injured players were still waiting for their turn. Pochettino wanted to hear what each of them thought needed attention, on the pitch and away from it.
It was a revealing way to answer a question about one man. Fernandes retains the authority to speak for the team. His new coach is also giving the other players a direct line to him. For a side sitting 18th in the Premier League, with one win in ten and a trip to Anfield on Sunday, both decisions make sense.
Why Has Pochettino Kept Fernandes as Captain?
Pochettino’s stated reason was his assessment of Fernandes’s importance to United. The strongest footballing evidence comes from what the midfielder did last season. He supplied 21 Premier League assists, setting a competition record, and won the players’ and football writers’ awards. Few incoming managers inherit a captain with such recent evidence of how much better he can make the forwards around him.
Pochettino also has some history with the player. He wanted to sign Fernandes for Tottenham in 2019, before the midfielder moved from Sporting to Manchester the following January. The Portuguese international subsequently took over the United captaincy from Harry Maguire in July 2023. Pochettino knew what interested him about Fernandes long before he had to decide what to do with the armband.
There is a practical case for continuity, too. Pochettino finished his final assignment with the United States on Tuesday, flew overnight from Cincinnati and went straight to Carrington on Wednesday. Choosing a replacement captain in that first week would have required him to judge relationships he had barely had time to observe. He can now use those first training sessions to answer a question that matters more on Sunday. Where does he want his most inventive passer receiving the ball?
What Is Behind the Backlash?
The criticism has a specific starting point. After United lost 4–1 at Como in the Champions League in October, Fernandes publicly questioned Michael Carrick’s tactical approach. Carrick then left him on the bench throughout the following league game. Bournemouth won 3–0 at Old Trafford. For anyone uneasy about the captaincy, Como raises a fair question. How much of a disagreement over tactics should a captain take into public while his manager is still trying to put things right?
The contract dispute has sharpened that argument. On Thursday, before Pochettino’s press conference, European football analyst Andy Brassell argued that a United rebuild should involve moving on from Fernandes. At 32, a player can still be the best creator at the club while presenting a difficult decision over the length and price of his next deal.
The timing matters. That criticism preceded Friday’s announcement. Supporters had also been directing questions at the owners and football executives over how United reached this position under yet another manager. There is evidence of disagreement about Fernandes’s future. There is little basis yet for calling the response to Pochettino’s captaincy decision a widespread fan revolt.
There is a reasonable test for both sides of the argument. The next time United fall behind, Fernandes may see something on the pitch that the bench has missed. A captain who can get that information to his coach while there is still time to change the game is worth having. How the pair handle that first disagreement will tell supporters more than either man could at an introductory press conference.
Could Fernandes or Lisandro Martínez Leave?
Fernandes has turned down two contract proposals. His present deal runs to summer 2027, and United hold an option for a further year. If the terms remain as they stand, he could speak to overseas clubs in January about a summer move. Exercising the option would give United more time and change that position.
That leaves several plausible outcomes. Fernandes could agree fresh terms, United could take up the extra year, or the current deal could run down. Friday’s announcement settled who captains the side now. It supplied no new agreement on how long United are prepared to employ him. Equally, turning down an offer says only that Fernandes was unwilling to sign those terms. He has previously declined an opportunity to leave, including an approach from Al Hilal in 2025.
Lisandro Martínez is another senior player whose future bears watching. United have a one-year extension option in his case, too. His public comments about director of football Jason Wilcox have added to questions about the relationship, but no departure or destination was confirmed at Friday’s briefing. In the immediate term, Martínez is back from suspension and available to be considered at Liverpool. Pochettino may have a use for him this weekend regardless of what the club decides about next summer.
Is Anyone Coming In?
Fulham centre-back Calvin Bassey is one name to watch. The link prompted a question for Fulham head coach Álvaro Arbeloa on Friday. His answer explained why signing Bassey would take some doing. Arbeloa described him as one of Fulham’s captains and placed him among the best centre-backs in the world. That was a public endorsement from the manager who already picks him. Neither club announced a bid, an agreed fee or a transfer.
Pochettino said he wants a voice in the major decisions affecting his squad. His most immediate defensive options are already at Carrington. Harry Maguire completed training on Thursday after a back spasm forced him off against Aston Villa. Patrick Dorgu also took part. Add Martínez’s return from suspension and Pochettino has choices to make before January recruitment enters the picture.
For supporters weighing up transfer stories, Bassey offers a useful distinction. Fulham have acknowledged why other teams might want their defender. The next significant development would be evidence of what United are prepared to offer and whether Fulham are willing to listen.
What Would Progress Look Like Against Liverpool?
United’s last league match ended 4–4 against Aston Villa. Dorgu set up Joshua Zirkzee and then headed the stoppage-time equaliser himself. Those contributions earned a point, but they also illustrate the predicament Pochettino inherits. On an afternoon when United scored four at home, they still needed a defender to rescue them at the end. It helps explain why Carrick lost his job and why an attack-minded successor has to spend time on what happens behind the ball.
Watch where Fernandes takes his first few passes at Anfield. If he repeatedly has to come back towards his own centre-backs to collect possession, Liverpool will have moved United’s most dangerous passer a long way from goal. If a team-mate can find him beyond Liverpool’s midfield, he can turn and look for a runner. That was the sort of pass behind last season’s assist record. Getting him into position to play it is a job for several players.
Then watch what happens when one of those passes goes astray. A midfielder close enough to slow the counterattack can buy United’s defenders time to recover. Leave that space empty and a pass intended to put a United forward through can send Liverpool running the other way. Pochettino’s team selection will show how much protection he thinks Fernandes needs to take those risks.
Sporting away in the Champions League follows Liverpool. That gives Fernandes an early return to his former club and Pochettino two demanding away games in which to learn about his captain. After weeks of debate over who should wear the armband, the most encouraging sight for United supporters might be a simple one at Anfield on Sunday. A team-mate does the work to get the ball to Fernandes, and their captain receives it facing goal.
Sources
The Guardian — Weekend football countdown, 20 November — Pochettino’s captaincy remarks and Arbeloa’s response to the Bassey link. live
Sky Sports — Bruno Fernandes rejects second Manchester United contract offer — Contract dates, the extension option, the assist record and the sequence of events under Carrick. Sky Sports
talkSPORT — Man United told to move on from Bruno Fernandes — Andy Brassell’s argument about rebuilding the squad, published before the captaincy announcement. talksport.com
The Guardian — Will Unwin answers questions on Manchester United — Supporter concerns about the hierarchy, Martínez’s contract position and the opening fixtures. The Guardian
Manchester United — Training update ahead of Anfield clash — Maguire and Dorgu’s participation, Martínez’s availability and Dorgu’s contributions against Villa. Manchester United
Reuters — No sleep for Pochettino as new era at Man United begins — Pochettino’s arrival from the United States and United’s league position before his first match. Reuters
Next Reads
Man Utd Sack Michael Carrick With Mauricio Pochettino Lined Up. Can He Fix This Team? — How Fernandes, Dorgu and United’s forwards fit the squad Pochettino inherited.
How Many Points Do Manchester United Need to Stay Up? What 30 Premier League Seasons Tell Us — What eight points from ten matches leaves United needing and where the familiar 40-point target comes from.
Why Does Manchester United Keep Changing Managers? The Decisions Above the Dugout — Why supporters have directed some of their hardest questions at the people choosing the head coach.