Are Black Friday Deals Actually Cheaper? How to Check a Deal in 60 Seconds

The "Was" Price Trick: Why Black Friday Discounts Look Bigger Than They Are

The 60-Second Check

Is That Black Friday Deal Really a Deal, or Just a Red Label?

Black Friday falls on Friday 27 November 2026, the day after US Thanksgiving, and the sales run through to Cyber Monday on 30 November. Most of the offers you will see are real prices. Far fewer are rare ones. The UK consumer group Which? tracked 175 Black Friday deals for a full year and found that 83 per cent were available at the same price or cheaper at some other point outside the four-week sales period. Not one was at its lowest price only on Black Friday itself.

So the honest answer to "are Black Friday deals actually cheaper?" is: sometimes, but usually not by as much as the label says, and rarely only on that day. The good news is that you can tell the difference quickly. Here is what the research shows, why the discounts look bigger than they are, and a 60-second check that works on both sides of the Atlantic.

What the Latest Which? Research Actually Found

It matters which year's figures you are reading. The most recent full Which? investigation was published on 25 November 2025 and looked at deals from the 2024 sales. Researchers followed 175 home, tech and health products across eight big UK retailers: Amazon, AO, Argos, Boots, Currys, John Lewis, Richer Sounds and Very. They tracked each price for six months before and six months after the event, from May 2024 to May 2025, and compared it with the price during the sales period, which they defined as 15 November to 12 December 2024.

The headline result was that 83 per cent of products were the same price or cheaper on at least one occasion outside the sales window, and 42 per cent were actually cheaper at least once. Compared with the price on Black Friday itself, every single product could be found at the same price or less in the six months either side. Waiting did not cost shoppers much either: 68 per cent of products were the same price or cheaper after the sales ended.

The pattern varied by retailer. Which? found that 94 per cent of the John Lewis products it checked were the same price or cheaper at other times of year, along with 93 per cent at Very, 88 per cent at Amazon, 85 per cent at AO, 84 per cent at Currys and 79 per cent at Argos. Currys did keep its promise that no sale item had been cheaper in the six months before Black Friday, which shows how a carefully worded pledge can be true without meaning the deal is the year's best.

No 2026 version had been published at the time of writing, so the 2025 report remains the latest evidence. Which?'s Ellie Simmonds sums up the advice in one line: "If there's only one piece of advice you take away this Black Friday, it's not to let yourself feel rushed."

Why "Was" Prices and RRPs Can Make Savings Look Bigger

Most fake-looking deals are not fake prices. They are real prices set against a flattering comparison. The two comparisons to watch are the "was" price and the recommended retail price (RRP).

A "was" price suggests the product cost more just before the sale. It does not always mean that. When Which? analysed 1,617 televisions sold with was-and-now pricing between February 2024 and February 2025, 56 per cent had been sold at one or more lower prices between the advertised "was" price and the sale price. One 65-inch LG OLED TV was on sale at Very for £1,499 against a "was" price of £2,499, which looks like a 40 per cent saving. But it had been sold at seven different prices since that higher figure, every one of them below £2,499.

An RRP is weaker still. It is the price the manufacturer suggests, and the shop never has to have charged it. Which? found Amazon advertising a Samsung heat pump tumble dryer for £629.99 on Black Friday against an RRP of £789.99, a claimed saving of £160. Amazon had not sold it at £789.99 at any point in the previous 12 months, and its highest price over that period was £719. In a Which? survey, 18 per cent of shoppers wrongly believed the retailer must have sold an item at its RRP before.

The inflation usually sits in the comparison price, not the sale price. So ignore the crossed-out number and compare the deal with the lowest price the product has recently sold for.

Countdown Timers and the Pressure to Buy Now

The other trick is time. Countdown clocks and "today only" banners are designed to stop you comparing prices, and UK regulators have started fining companies that use them falsely.

On 14 October 2026, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA), the UK's competition and consumer watchdog, fined the online furniture retailer Wayfair £4.8 million. It found that products sold as 24-hour "Flash Deals" or "Daily Deals", with countdown timers and messages such as "Here Today, Gone Tomorrow", often stayed at the same price or lower after the deadline passed. Wayfair agreed to settle. In the same announcement, Appliances Direct was fined £1.2 million, partly for pre-ticked add-ons and "limited-time" discount codes that kept coming back.

The fines use powers the CMA gained under the Digital Markets, Competition and Consumers Act 2024, which lets it penalise businesses directly instead of going to court first. Separately, in a July 2026 High Court case involving the mattress company Emma Sleep, a judge rejected a rigid formula the CMA had proposed for how long a "was" price must have applied, so the detailed rules are still being worked out.

The practical lesson is simple. A timer tells you what the shop wants you to feel, not whether the price is good.

What the Rules Say in the UK and the US

In the UK, guidance from the CMA and the Chartered Trading Standards Institute points the same way: a "was" price should be a genuine, recent selling price, ideally the last price charged before the offer, and the discount should not run for longer than the higher price was actually charged.

In the US, the Federal Trade Commission's Guides Against Deceptive Pricing set a similar standard. A former price is a fair comparison if it is "the actual, bona fide price at which the article was offered to the public on a regular basis for a reasonably substantial period of time". The guides also warn against "limited" offers that are not really limited. They are guidance rather than a strict formula, so American shoppers have to do most of the checking themselves.

4:58 PMTaylor Tailored

Are US Black Friday Deals Any Different?

US research measures discounts differently, so the figures are not directly comparable with Which?'s. Adobe, which tracks US online retail sales, forecast in September 2026 that discounts this season would peak at up to 30 per cent off listed prices during Cyber Week. It expects discounts of up to 14 per cent in early November, up to 21 per cent just before Thanksgiving, and 10 to 15 per cent through December. Black Friday is forecast to offer the deepest cuts on TVs, toys, clothing, appliances and furniture, while electronics and computers are expected to bottom out on Cyber Monday.

Those percentages are measured against the retailer's own listed price, the same kind of figure that "was" and RRP claims rely on. Price-history studies tell a more cautious story. The personal finance site WalletHub reported in November 2025 that 36 per cent of the items it checked offered no saving on Black Friday compared with their prices between 27 October and 17 November, although items that were genuinely reduced averaged about 24 per cent off. A smaller analysis of 763 US products by the data company Happy Endpoint found that only 22.5 per cent hit their 12-month low during the Black Friday window.

US shoppers can find real discounts, but the discount label alone proves very little.

How to Check a Black Friday Deal in 60 Seconds

This works for any product with a model number, in Britain or America.

  1. Copy the exact model number (10 seconds). If it does not match the model reviewers tested, be cautious.

  2. Search that model number on a price-comparison site (15 seconds). In the UK, PriceRunner and PriceSpy show what other shops are charging. In the US, Google Shopping does the same job. If four shops sell it for the same price and only one calls it a deal, it is the normal price.

  3. Open the price history (15 seconds). CamelCamelCamel and Keepa track Amazon prices in both countries, and PriceSpy shows price histories in the UK. Look for the lowest price over the past three to six months.

  4. Ignore the "was" price and the RRP (10 seconds). Compare the deal with that recent low. If it matches or beats it, you have a genuinely good price. If it does not, you can probably wait.

  5. Ask the full-price question (10 seconds). Which? suggests asking whether you would buy the item at full price on a normal Friday. If 30 per cent off is the only reason it appeals, you are spending 70 per cent on something you do not need.

If a deal passes all five steps, buy it calmly. If it fails, set a price alert and move on: the same price, or a better one, will probably come round again.

How to Pay and What to Do If It Goes Wrong

How you pay matters almost as much as the price. In the UK, paying by credit card for an item costing between £100 and £30,000 gives you extra protection under Section 75 of the Consumer Credit Act 1974 if the goods never arrive or the seller goes bust. Our guide to who pays you back after a Black Friday scam compares card, debit and bank-transfer protection in more detail.

Most UK online purchases also come with a 14-day right to cancel under the Consumer Contracts Regulations, and many shops extend returns over Christmas. The rules on returning a Black Friday purchase after Christmas explain what you are entitled to and what is just shop policy. In the US there is no general federal right to return an item, so the retailer's own policy usually decides, although credit card disputes can help when goods never arrive.

Watch the final price as well as the headline one. The CMA has also warned retailers about prices that leave out delivery fees until the checkout, which can quietly erase a small saving.

So, Should You Shop on Black Friday?

Yes, if you have a list, a budget and a price you already know is good. Black Friday is a reliable time to buy some things, particularly toys, TVs and appliances that genuinely drop to their lowest price of the year. It is a poor time to buy on impulse, because the strongest evidence shows that most deals return, and a few were never really deals at all. Spend a minute on the price history before you pay, and the red label stops mattering.

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

Manchester United Humiliated 4–0 by Liverpool: Is Relegation Now a Real Threat?

Next
Next

Pochettino Confirms Bruno Fernandes Will Stay Manchester United Captain