How Can a Glacier Disappear While the Ice Is Still There? NASA’s Images From Indonesia

What the Blue Flecks in NASA’s Images Reveal About Indonesia’s Last Glaciers

What the Blue Flecks in NASA’s Images Reveal About Indonesia’s Last Glaciers

A Few Blue Marks On An Indonesian Mountain Reveal What Outlasts A Glacier.

Look for the blue in NASA’s two images of Puncak Jaya. In the first, taken in 1988, you can follow it along the high ridges. In the second, taken in October 2026, you have to pick out individual flecks among the brown rock. Those flecks are ice. Yet the Indonesian scientists who have tracked the mountain’s decline say its days of supporting active glaciers are effectively over.

A glacier can disappear while some of its ice survives because a glacier moves. Given enough thickness and slope, the ice slowly deforms under its own weight and flows downhill. Near Puncak Jaya, thinning has left fragments too small to sustain that flow. A sheltered crevice can hold a piece of the old glacier long after the surrounding slope has lost the ice that once fed it.

How to Read NASA’s Two Images

Start with a ridge and follow the same line in both pictures. Landsat 5 recorded the first view on 3 November 1988. Landsat 9 captured the second on 19 October 2026. The images use false colour so that surfaces that might look alike to the eye are easier to tell apart. Ice appears pale blue, cloud white, exposed rock brown and vegetation green. It is easy to mistake the brightest parts of the picture for the ice you came to see.

The gaps are as revealing as the surviving blue. Rock now separates patches that once belonged to a much larger expanse. A satellite looking down can show where those gaps have opened. Two pictures taken 38 years apart cannot tell you when the ice stopped moving. To understand what happened between them, scientists also have measurements from people who worked on the mountain itself.

One figure often associated with these images belongs to a different date. In 1988 the ice covered about 4.31 square kilometres. By September 2025, aerial and satellite observations put the remaining area at about 0.09 square kilometres, or nine hectares. That amounts to a loss of roughly 98 per cent of the original footprint. The October 2026 image shows the later condition of the ridges. An aerial survey planned for December is intended to produce a fresh estimate.

How Can Solid Ice Flow?

Imagine marking a spot well up a glacier and returning to survey it over several years. The ice beneath the mark can carry it downhill even while the glacier’s lower edge retreats uphill. Ice is still arriving from above, but melting at the lower end is removing it faster than the glacier can deliver more. Someone watching the mark and someone watching the front could report movement in opposite directions, and both would be right.

That distinction matters on Puncak Jaya. Retreat alone tells us little about whether the surviving ice still moves. Thickness helps answer that question. On a given slope, a deep mass of ice experiences more stress from its own weight than a shallow patch does. Under sustained stress, solid ice slowly changes shape. As it thins, its capacity to carry ice downslope falls sharply.

Consider what researchers found on the East Northwall Firn, one of the mountain’s ice fields. At their main monitoring site, the ice was 32 metres thick in 2010. In 2023 it was four metres thick. By November 2024, the ice at that spot had gone. A camera pointed towards a neighbouring hollow could still have captured genuine glacial ice on the very same day.

Why Does Snowfall No Longer Rebuild the Glacier?

Puncak Jaya rises to 4,884 metres on the Indonesian side of New Guinea, about four degrees south of the equator. That height explains how ice could endure here in the first place. Where snow survives one year and receives another layer the next, the buried grains compact. Over time, air spaces close and dense glacier ice forms. A snowfall that melts away on bare rock leaves nothing for the next layer to bury.

On this mountain, a shift in the altitude at which air reaches freezing can change what falls from a cloud. When the freezing level rises above the summit, precipitation can arrive as rain. The mountain then misses out twice. It gains less snow, and older ice loses the bright covering that would have reflected sunlight. Darker exposed surfaces absorb more of that energy.

Researchers caught the effect of a particularly strong El Niño in their measurements. From 2010 to late 2015, the monitored ice thinned by about a metre a year. During the strong 2015–16 event, the thinning rate rose roughly fivefold. A stake anchored to bedrock gave the scientists a fixed reference as the surface dropped. It recorded how much ice one exceptionally warm period could take from a mountain already close to the limit for permanent ice.

What Did Scientists Save Before the Ice Went?

In 2010 a team drilled two cores to bedrock on the western drilling peak and recovered another on the eastern peak. The longest cylinder measured just over 32 metres. Inside it were samples of precipitation that had fallen on this part of the tropical Pacific decades earlier.

Water molecules contain different forms of oxygen. Their proportions in snow reflect the conditions through which moisture travelled before it fell. By measuring variations down the cores and establishing the age of the layers, researchers reconstructed a record of regional climate variability reaching back to 1964. In a region dominated by warm ocean, a high mountain had provided a rare place where precipitation could accumulate in sequence and be sampled years later.

The cores preserve part of that history in cold storage. Repeating the drilling today at the monitoring site would be impossible. The bedrock that once marked the bottom of the record is now the surface.

When Will the Last Ice Disappear?

Satellite-based research has put the possible disappearance of the main ice areas around 2030. Indonesia’s meteorological and climatological agency considers an earlier loss possible, particularly with El Niño conditions hastening melt. The fate of an individual pocket depends in part on where it sits. Two pieces of ice at the same altitude can receive quite different amounts of direct sunlight.

Even a future photograph of a white summit would need careful reading. It might show snow that fell the previous night. To find out whether the mountain was building ice again, researchers would have to return after that snow had time to melt, then see whether successive years added to what survived.

For now, the change is easiest to see by returning to the two NASA frames. Find a ridge you can trace in blue in 1988 and follow it again in 2026. Across much of that distance, you are tracing bare rock.

Sources

Next Reads

Next
Next

Why Do Galaxies Look Like Arcs? Euclid’s 15,000 Lens Candidates Explained