Who Sent an 18-Year-Old Model to Jeffrey Epstein’s Home While He Was Serving His Sentence?
Why Was A Modelling Agency Sending An Eighteen-Year-Old To Jeffrey Epstein’s Home While He Was Serving A Jail Sentence?
Roza went to Jeffrey Epstein’s Palm Beach home twice in 2009. She had arrived in the United States from Uzbekistan about a month before the first visit. She was 18, she had an American modelling agency, and she understood that she was going there to have her photograph taken. Years later, she could still recall what was odd about the shoots. There was no stylist. Epstein’s girlfriend took the pictures. As far as Roza knew, nobody ever used them.
The visits did lead to a job. Roza became Epstein’s assistant. She told the BBC that he began raping her within a week.
In The Model Trap: Exposing Jeffrey Epstein’s Network, BBC Eye investigates how a man convicted of a sex offence involving a minor continued to meet young women through people they had professional reasons to trust. Over a year, the team examined material from more than three million pages released by the US Department of Justice and spoke to more than 100 models from 14 countries. Among the records it traced were a payment to a modelling agency, correspondence about individual women and an expense statement for a flight home. Each answered a different part of the question Roza has been asking ever since. Who knew where she was going?
The Return Flight From Palm Beach
In 2009, Epstein was serving his Florida sentence under an arrangement that allowed him out of jail to work during the day. For Roza, newly arrived in America, the instruction to go to Palm Beach came from the US branch of MC2 Model Management. The person she holds responsible for putting her in danger is Jeff Fuller, then the agency’s US president.
Roza showed BBC reporters an expense statement that appears to identify Fuller as the person who booked her flight home after the second shoot. She believes he knew exactly where the agency had sent her. Fuller has previously said he did not know she was going to Epstein’s house or that Epstein was abusing her. He did not respond to the BBC’s questions for the investigation.
The statement matters because it places the agency within the practical arrangements for the trip. It also has a limit. A person booking a flight from Palm Beach can know a traveller’s departure airport without knowing the address she visited or what happened there. Roza supplies something the paperwork cannot. She remembers who directed her to the shoot and why she understood it to be part of her work.
That is an important distinction for anyone asking why she went. An 18-year-old model could reasonably take a booking from her own agency as an indication that someone more experienced had checked the client and the job. Roza says protecting her was part of what she trusted the agency to do.
What Connected Epstein to MC2 Model Management?
The BBC traced the relationship back four years before Roza’s shoots. US Justice Department files showed that Epstein gave MC2 $1 million in 2005. Two years later, the agency’s owners told a US publication that Epstein had no involvement in their company. The payment establishes a substantial financial connection. On its own, it tells us little about who controlled bookings.
A March 2012 email gives a clearer picture of Epstein’s influence over at least one decision. Writing about a different model, Fuller told Epstein that the agency would have dismissed her months earlier were it not for him. He also cautioned Epstein that she talked about things. The exchange does not identify what Fuller thought she might disclose. What it does reveal is that an agency president considered Epstein’s wishes relevant to whether a woman kept her representation.
The investigators identified ten MC2 models who met or corresponded with Epstein after his conviction. That figure measures contact. The evidence about what happened to each woman varies, and it would be wrong to assign Roza’s experience to all ten. What the finding establishes is that the professional connection survived a conviction and extended beyond the two Florida shoots.
What a Scout Could Promise
For a young model trying to work abroad, an introduction can have genuine value. Someone who knows an agency director can arrange a meeting that would otherwise be difficult to obtain. That ordinary feature of the business gave weight to the offers women described to the BBC. They could have good reason to believe a contact would advance their careers while knowing very little about the man they were being asked to meet.
The BBC examined the work of Ramsey Elkholy, a former modelling agent. It found that he tried to put 34 women in touch with Epstein. One was an 18-year-old Czech student whom, according to the documentary, he tried to persuade to travel to America for a photoshoot. Elkholy denied facilitating abuse and said he had no knowledge of it at the time.
The word tried matters here. Earlier reporting on Elkholy uncovered a striking example of how far a proposed introduction could be from an actual meeting. In emails from 2012, he claimed to have recruited a Russian supermodel and discussed her visiting Epstein. A tentative appointment appeared in a schedule. Her lawyer said she had never met either man. Asked about the discrepancy, Elkholy acknowledged making up his claims.
Read together, the email and the diary entry might look like two pieces of corroboration. In fact, the second could simply preserve the assertion made in the first. The model’s own account changes the meaning of both records. It also explains why speaking to women across 14 countries mattered to this investigation. An archive compiled around Epstein generally preserves what people told him. The woman whose name they used may have an entirely different story.
How an Offer of Work Could Narrow a Woman’s Choices
A second survivor, whom the BBC calls Simona, described meeting Epstein when she was 20 and already represented by a New York agency. In her case he offered something specific. He could introduce her to Faith Kates, who ran Next Management, a major modelling agency. Simona says she met Kates and that Epstein subsequently persuaded her to leave modelling and become his assistant. She says he repeatedly raped her over the two years she spent around him.
Kates’s lawyers told the BBC that Epstein had seriously misled her and that, with what she knows now, she would never have associated with him. Next Management did not respond to the BBC’s request for comment. The files also contained requests from Epstein for Kates to meet five other models. How many of those meetings happened remains unclear.
Simona’s account helps explain why the offer of an assistant’s job recurs in the investigation. A photoshoot has an end point. A meeting with an agency director does too. Working directly for Epstein gave him a reason to expect a woman to return. In Simona’s case, she says accepting that position also meant giving up the profession she had come to New York to pursue.
Another former model interviewed for the project described how closely immigration, housing and money could be bound together for a woman working overseas. A decision about a job might also be a decision about where she could live and whether she could afford to stay in the country. That gives some substance to a question often asked of survivors years later. To understand what leaving would have involved, it helps to know what the person offering work had come to control.
What the BBC’s Findings Leave Open
The investigation identifies decisions that can be examined individually. Who accepted money from Epstein? Who was still discussing a model’s employment with him in 2012? Who proposed an introduction, who attended and what was the woman told beforehand? Those questions are more likely to establish responsibility than treating every name in the files as evidence of the same conduct.
They also explain the interest in the case among people seeking changes to the law. New York state senator Zellnor Myrie has proposed legislation intended to give investigators greater scope to pursue people who may have enabled sex trafficking. That is a proposal about investigative powers. Establishing criminal responsibility for any individual would require evidence of that person’s own conduct and the knowledge required under the applicable law.
The Model Trap is available on BBC iPlayer, with a companion investigation on BBC Sounds. For viewers, the telling detail may still be the unused photographs. Roza can account for her side of those two trips. She can say why she went, who took the pictures and what job followed. She even kept paperwork for the journey home. The question she puts to the adults who arranged the booking is one a model ought to be able to ask before she leaves for work. Who checked where she was being sent?
Sources
BBC News reports Roza’s account, Fuller’s previous response, the Palm Beach expense statement and MC2’s financial connection to Epstein. Read the BBC investigation
BBC World Service presents survivors’ testimony and the investigation into modelling contacts after Epstein’s conviction. Listen to The Model Trap on BBC Sounds
The Washington Post interviewed Ramsey Elkholy and checked his account of a proposed introduction with the model’s representative. Read the investigation into Elkholy’s correspondence
Next Reads
Epstein Files: Why the Names Matter Less Than How They Appear examines the difference between a name in a document, a proposed meeting and evidence that two people met.
The Epstein Files Are Public—What They Reveal About Prince Andrew and Bill Gates considers what correspondence can establish when the people named in it dispute Epstein’s account.
Epstein Files Detonate: Lutnick, Gates, Andrew, Clinton—The Powerful Names in the Documents puts the modelling investigation in the wider context of the US document release.