Les Misérables Summary and Ending Explained: Jean Valjean, Javert and the Price of Mercy

What Happens in Les Misérables? Victor Hugo’s Novel and Ending Explained

How the Stories in Les Misérables Fit Together

A Man With Money Cannot Buy a Bed

Jean Valjean arrives in the French town of Digne with money he earned in prison. He is hungry, tired and willing to pay the price of a meal. At the first inn, the landlord makes enquiries. At the next, the news has preceded him. Even the prison will admit him only if he gets himself arrested. By the time somebody directs him to the bishop’s house, the remarkable thing about the invitation is how little it requires. He can come in and sit down. Victor Hugo’s Les Misérables begins its great argument about justice with a practical question. What exactly is a man supposed to do on the evening of the day his punishment ends?

Why the Bishop Gives Valjean the Candlesticks

Hugo introduces the Bishop of Digne before he brings Valjean to his door. We know that Bishop Myriel has exchanged a spacious episcopal residence for the cramped building occupied by the local hospital. The arrangement strikes him as obvious. The patients need beds and he has rooms. He does retain a few pleasures, among them the silver used at his table. A guest could reasonably conclude that the silver is one possession the bishop particularly values. That is precisely what makes it worth stealing.

Valjean’s yellow passport identifies him as a former convict. He went to prison for breaking a baker’s window and taking bread when his sister’s children were hungry. His original term was five years. Attempts to escape and the additional punishments they brought kept him imprisoned for nineteen. He has had time to think about whether the sentence bore any proportion to the offence. He has also had nineteen years of being handled as somebody against whom force is always justified. He comes out strong, suspicious and thoroughly accustomed to hostility.

The bishop seats him at his own table and gives him a bed. During the night Valjean takes the silver and leaves. When gendarmes bring him back, Myriel greets him as a guest who has forgotten part of a gift. He fetches the two silver candlesticks and gives him those as well. The bishop is the one person who can establish that a theft has taken place. By asserting his right to give away his property, he deprives the authorities of the injured party whose complaint would send Valjean back to prison.

The encounter does not produce an instantly reformed man. Later, a travelling boy named Petit-Gervais drops a coin. Valjean puts his foot on it and drives him away. Only after the boy has gone does he fully register what he has done. He calls and searches for a child who now has every reason to keep well clear of him. At the bishop’s house, Valjean could think of himself as the person who had suffered. With his foot on a child’s money, he has occupied the other position. The bishop’s gift begins to work on him when there is nobody left to impress and no easy way to put the matter right.

How Fantine Falls Through the Gaps in a Prosperous Town

Several years later, the town of Montreuil-sur-Mer has a successful manufacturer known as Monsieur Madeleine. An improvement in the production of imitation jewellery has brought down costs, created employment and made its inventor wealthy. Madeleine spends generously on the town and eventually accepts the office of mayor. People who know how much the place owes him have little incentive to enquire closely into where he came from.

One of the women who comes looking for work is Fantine. As a young woman in Paris, she fell in love with a well-to-do student named Tholomyès. For him their relationship belonged to a pleasant interval before respectable adulthood. For her it produced a daughter, Cosette, for whom she alone must provide. Searching for employment is difficult enough. Persuading a respectable employer to overlook an unmarried mother’s circumstances seems a longer shot still.

On the road, Fantine sees a woman playing with two little girls outside an inn. The children look happy and their mother appears affectionate. Fantine asks whether her own daughter might live with them while she finds work. It is worth taking seriously the evidence on which she decides. Madame Thénardier really does love the children Fantine sees her with. Fantine has no way of knowing how sharply the woman distinguishes between her own daughters and somebody else’s child.

The Thénardiers accept payment, dress Cosette poorly and put her to work. Their letters demand more money for supposed needs that Fantine cannot inspect from a distance. Meanwhile, women at the factory uncover her secret. The female supervisor dismisses her without consulting Madeleine. His business has given women paid employment, but he has delegated the authority to decide which women deserve to keep it. Fantine experiences the difference between her employer’s humane intentions and the institution he actually runs.

She sells her hair. When a letter claims that Cosette is dangerously ill, she lets a man extract her front teeth for money. Eventually she sells sex. Each concession is made for a particular sum and an immediate reason. From the outside, the resulting changes in her appearance can be taken as evidence of the sort of woman she has always been. From inside her life, we have watched a succession of people take something valuable from her and then leave her to face the next transaction with less to offer.

A prosperous idler torments her in the street and puts snow down her back. Fantine retaliates. Inspector Javert sees an assault on a respectable man and takes her into custody. Madeleine intervenes, hears enough to understand the provocation and orders her release. Fantine initially spits in his face. As far as she knows, this is the man who threw her out of work. His willingness to keep listening after she does it is the first genuinely useful exercise of his authority that she has encountered.

The Trial That Gives the Mayor a Choice

Javert has already found reason to wonder about Madeleine. When an elderly carter named Fauchelevent is trapped underneath a heavily laden cart, the mayor gets beneath it and raises it sufficiently for the man to be freed. Javert remembers a convict of extraordinary strength from his time serving in the prisons. An act the townspeople take as proof of Madeleine’s goodness draws the inspector’s attention to the possibility that he is Jean Valjean.

Then another man, Champmathieu, is identified as the missing convict. Javert, who reported his suspicions about the mayor, comes to confess what he now regards as a grave professional offence. He believes he has falsely denounced his superior and asks to be punished. There is a kind of integrity here. Javert will apply a hard rule to himself as readily as to somebody he dislikes. His fearsome limitation is how seldom it occurs to him that the rule, or the identification on which it depends, might be wrong.

Madeleine knows exactly who is wrong because he is Jean Valjean. If he stays home, witnesses will likely identify Champmathieu as the former convict, and the authorities will have little reason to look further. Valjean can continue employing workers, supporting the poor and caring for Fantine, who is gravely ill. For once self-preservation can present itself to his conscience with an impressive list of beneficiaries.

He goes to the court at Arras. His appearance alone could be taken for the intervention of an eccentric public official, so he addresses former prisoners who have appeared as witnesses. He identifies them through particular memories and bodily details acquired during their imprisonment together. The respectable mayor possesses knowledge that would be exceedingly difficult to explain unless he had once lived among these men as one of them. Champmathieu goes free. The life Madeleine built now has its owner’s testimony against it.

Javert comes for Valjean at Fantine’s bedside. Valjean asks for time to fetch Cosette. In front of the sick woman, Javert rejects the request and exposes the mayor’s identity. Fantine has sustained herself with the belief that her daughter will be brought to her. She dies amid the collapse of that hope. Valjean bends close and speaks to her, but Hugo withholds the words. We shall learn more about what he owes her from the way he spends the next part of his life than we could from overhearing a promise.

What Cosette Is Carrying Through the Woods

Returned to penal servitude, Valjean escapes after rescuing a sailor in danger aboard a ship and falling into the water. He is believed drowned. Where Edmond Dantès in The Count of Monte Cristo can use a concealed identity to approach the people who wronged him, Valjean has a more immediate obligation. He must find a little girl who has no particular reason to trust a stranger saying he has come to take her away.

On Christmas Eve, the Thénardiers send Cosette into the dark to fetch water. The bucket is heavy when full and she is frightened of the woods. On the way back, a large hand takes the handle. Before Cosette knows who Valjean is, or whether he has money, or what arrangement he might make with the innkeeper, she knows what it feels like when he carries something too heavy for her. Hugo builds their relationship in the right order for a child.

At the inn, Valjean sees the difference between the treatment of Cosette and the treatment of the Thénardiers’ daughters. He buys Cosette the magnificent doll she has admired in a shop. The gift restores a distinction the household has abolished. A child old enough to sweep, knit and carry water can still be young enough to want a doll. She watches the adults before daring to enjoy it. Valjean can buy the toy in a minute. Making it safe for her to play will take longer.

He pays Thénardier and takes her away. When the innkeeper follows in hopes of extracting more, Valjean can produce written authority from Fantine to collect her child. Mother and daughter will never meet again, but Fantine has retained a part in what happens to Cosette. The innkeeper’s power over the girl ends when he discovers that the stranger has both the determination and the means to resist his price.

In Paris, Valjean and Cosette live quietly until Javert picks up their trail. Their flight brings them into the enclosed grounds of a convent. Here Valjean encounters Fauchelevent, the carter whose life he saved and whom he helped to find work as a gardener. A man whom the mayor once lifted out from under a cart now has the knowledge Valjean needs. Fauchelevent understands the convent’s rules, knows who can enter and is willing to claim Valjean as his brother.

Getting them accepted requires an extraordinary piece of practical theatre involving a coffin and a burial. What matters afterwards is the ordinary arrangement it secures. Valjean can work as a gardener. Cosette can be educated with the girls. For years they have a home in a place the police cannot casually inspect. It suits the hunted man so well that he eventually has to confront an uncomfortable question. Does it suit the growing girl equally well, and how could she discover what she wanted if he kept her there?

The Father Marius Never Really Knew

Elsewhere in Paris, Marius Pontmercy grows up in the comfortable home of his royalist grandfather, Monsieur Gillenormand. His father, Georges Pontmercy, fought for Napoleon. The grandfather’s hostility to that allegiance has helped keep father and son apart. Marius is brought up to understand the separation as evidence that his father took little interest in him. It is an explanation congenial to the man who controls the house and Marius’s expectations of an inheritance.

After his father’s death, Marius learns that Georges used to come secretly to church to catch sight of him. The information comes from a witness who saw the visits. An absence Marius had interpreted as indifference turns out to have required considerable effort and restraint. He begins reading about Napoleon and investigating his father’s military career. The politics change first as a consequence of love. A boy who had accepted his grandfather’s loyalties now wants to know what the world looked like to the man he misjudged.

Georges has left another obligation behind. He believed that a man named Thénardier saved his life on the battlefield at Waterloo and asked his son to help him if the occasion arose. Hugo has already shown the reader how the supposed rescue occurred. Thénardier was stripping the fallen and inadvertently helped a wounded man survive. Georges remembered the face of the person who pulled him free. His gratitude is genuine, although the intention he attributed to its recipient was an invention born of incomplete knowledge.

Marius breaks with his grandfather, experiences serious poverty and moves among young men interested in republican politics. His friend Courfeyrac belongs to a circle known as the Friends of the ABC, whose most commanding figure is Enjolras. Marius admires these men without simply adopting every opinion they hold. At this stage an attraction nearer to home occupies much of his attention. In the Luxembourg Gardens he repeatedly sees a young woman walking with an older man. The girl is Cosette.

The pair fall in love largely through looks before either has much knowledge of the other’s circumstances. Valjean notices Marius’s interest and changes their habits. The protection that once carried a terrified child out of the woods now places an obstacle in the path of a young woman making her first independent attachment. He loves Cosette deeply. He also depends on being the person around whom her whole life is organised. She has grown old enough for those two facts to pull in different directions.

How an Old Debt Silences a Witness

Living in a poor Paris tenement, Marius observes a neighbouring family who call themselves the Jondrettes. A charitable older man visits them with the young woman Marius recognises from the gardens. Listening through the partition, Marius realises the family intends to lure the benefactor back and rob him. He alerts the police. Javert gives him pistols and arranges for a shot to be the signal that the police should intervene.

Then Marius hears the father of the household identify himself as Thénardier. The victim is Valjean, although Marius does not know the full history that connects him to this family. Marius is suddenly responsible for signalling the arrest of the very man his father charged him to protect. We know the debt was founded on a misunderstanding. Marius has the dying request of a beloved parent on one side and a crime taking place a few feet away on the other. Superior information makes the choice easy for the reader and does absolutely nothing for the young man holding the pistol.

Marius finds another way to interrupt the attack, using a written warning that suggests the police are present. Javert and his officers enter, but Valjean slips away. Marius has helped save the older man’s life without gaining an introduction, an address or even a reliable name. Hugo’s Paris is full of people who owe one another something but lack the information necessary to understand the debt.

It is Éponine, the Thénardiers’ eldest daughter, who eventually finds Cosette’s address for Marius. Once one of the favoured children at the inn, Éponine now moves through Paris in poverty. She loves Marius and knows why he wants the address. Her assistance brings him to the garden in the Rue Plumet, where he and Cosette at last speak and meet in secret. Later, Éponine also stands up to her father and his associates when they come to target the house. She protects a happiness in which she has no place, though her generosity has limits that will matter when Cosette tries to send word to Marius.

Which Revolution Is the Barricade Fighting?

The street fighting in Les Misérables takes place on 5 and 6 June 1832. France is under King Louis-Philippe. The funeral procession of General Lamarque, an opposition figure who has died during a cholera epidemic, brings crowds onto the streets of Paris. Republicans seize the occasion for an uprising. Readers picturing the storming of the Bastille in 1789 have supplied the wrong revolution, the wrong king and a very different outcome.

Enjolras and his companions build their barricade in the expectation that their stand might form part of a wider movement. Its prospects depend on what people elsewhere in Paris decide to do. From behind it, the defenders can see their immediate neighbours and hear firing. They cannot simply look out and discover whether a city is rising. As wider support fails to materialise, the barricade changes from a position they hope to hold into a place from which many of them will never return.

Marius comes to it in despair. Valjean intends to leave with Cosette, and an appeal to his grandfather has ended disastrously. The old man responds to the proposed marriage with advice that treats Cosette as a girl Marius might keep as a mistress. It is a cruel misunderstanding on both sides. Gillenormand is delighted to see his grandson and imagines he is speaking with worldly affection. Marius hears an insult to the woman he loves and departs before either can repair the injury.

At the barricade, Éponine receives a bullet intended for Marius. As she dies, she gives him a letter from Cosette that she had withheld. The letter supplies the new address and proves that Cosette tried to reach him. Éponine has both helped separate them and used her last opportunity to restore the connection. Reducing her to a selfless admirer would cost the scene much of its feeling. She knew what it would mean to give him that letter, which is why it took her so long.

Marius writes a farewell and sends it with Gavroche, the Paris street boy who is also Éponine’s younger brother. The errand offers a chance of getting the child away from the fighting. It also takes news of Marius directly to Valjean. Cosette’s blotting paper, readable in a mirror, has already shown her guardian more about the attachment than she intended him to know. Now the older man learns where his rival is and how little the young man expects to survive the night. He goes to the barricade himself.

Why Valjean Asks for Javert

Javert has entered the barricade as a police spy. Gavroche identifies him, and the insurgents take him prisoner. Valjean thus encounters the man who has pursued him for years under circumstances in which respectable witnesses will regard killing him as a service. He asks to take charge of the prisoner’s execution. The defenders grant the request. For once the outward appearance of implacable justice is entirely at Valjean’s disposal.

He takes Javert out of sight, cuts his bonds, gives him his address and lets him go. He fires a shot so those waiting will believe the duty has been performed. Marius hears the shot. He has grounds to remember afterwards that Valjean took a bound policeman away and that a pistol went off. He has no opportunity to observe the one act that would let him understand either man’s subsequent conduct.

Until this encounter, Javert could account for Valjean’s evasions readily enough. Of course a convict wanted to remain free. Even a generous deed performed under an assumed name could be interpreted as part of a successful disguise. His own release poses a much harder problem. Valjean has surrendered a safe opportunity to get rid of him and provided information that makes another arrest possible. The inspector’s continued existence is now evidence against his most settled judgement about the man who spared him.

The attack comes. Gavroche goes beyond the defences to collect ammunition for the people still fighting and is shot dead. Enjolras makes his last stand with Grantaire, the sceptical companion whose devotion to him has proved more durable than his belief in the cause. Marius is badly wounded. Valjean finds him and takes him below the street into the sewers. The man who once feared Marius would take Cosette from him now carries the unconscious young man whose survival would make that separation possible.

What Javert Learns at the Sewer Exit

Carrying another adult through darkness and foul water is painfully slow. Marius cannot tell Valjean which route to take or help distribute his own weight. At one point Valjean sinks into treacherous ground and struggles to keep his burden above it. Hugo makes the physical labour last because, once Marius is safely in bed, there will be almost no visible trace of what another man did to put him there.

At the exit Valjean finds a locked grate. Thénardier appears with the means of opening it. Seeing a man carrying an apparently lifeless body, he assumes he has found a criminal who will pay for an escape route. He takes what money he can and secretly tears a piece from Marius’s coat. It might later be useful as evidence against the man carrying him. At Waterloo, an attempt to rob a body looked like a rescue. Thénardier has now witnessed a rescue and mistaken it for the disposal of a body. On both occasions he has correctly observed where one man’s hands were and completely misunderstood what they were doing there.

Javert is waiting outside. Valjean asks to take the wounded Marius home before being arrested. A note Marius has carried on his person supplies the address of his grandfather. Javert accompanies them, and the young man reaches a household with the means and overwhelming desire to nurse him. Valjean then asks for a short stop at his own home. Once there, he looks out and discovers that Javert has gone.

Why does Javert let him go? He has just helped complete an act whose goodness he understands from personal experience. At the barricade Valjean preserved his life. At the sewer exit he found the same man preserving somebody else’s. To take him into custody, Javert had to wait for an injured person to receive the benefit of Valjean’s freedom. He can no longer pretend that enforcing the sentence and serving the good are necessarily the same act.

An older man whose professional identity is built around obedience has made an independent moral decision. Instead of experiencing that freedom as relief, Javert finds it unendurable. He writes observations about abuses in police and prison practice, still able to see particular things his profession might do better. Then he takes his own life in the Seine. Valjean had years after the bishop’s intervention in which to learn how to live with a different account of himself. Javert reaches a comparable crisis and cannot imagine a life on its far side.

Why Marius Misjudges the Man Who Saved Him

Marius slowly recovers, reconciles with his grandfather and marries Cosette in February 1833. Valjean makes his fortune available to her. The money comes from the legitimate manufacturing business he built as Madeleine. To Cosette, the man who raised her naturally belongs in the life that follows. She has little conception of the effort required to preserve that appearance of ordinary family continuity.

Valjean tells Marius privately that he is a former convict and that Cosette is outside his family by birth. He cannot accept a permanent place in the household under what he considers false pretences. Yet his confession leaves out the piece of history most likely to secure him a welcome. He does not tell Marius who carried him through the sewers. He would like to be received honestly, but he gives the young man a selection of truths from which an unjust conclusion is remarkably easy to draw.

Marius remembers the shot at the barricade. He has questions about the fortune and knows that its source, Monsieur Madeleine, disappeared. For all his affection for Cosette, he has inherited some conventional ideas about the moral significance of a conviction. Valjean’s visits become more constrained and less welcoming until they cease. Cosette has scarcely enough information to object effectively. A man who once carried her through the woods loses his place in her adult life without anybody having to tell her plainly that he must go.

Thénardier breaks the deadlock by coming to sell information. He hopes to profit by exposing Valjean as a murderer. Instead, the evidence he produces helps establish that Valjean and Madeleine were the same man and that Javert died by suicide. The fortune has an honest source. The shot Marius heard did not kill the inspector. Finally, Thénardier produces the scrap of cloth taken from the supposed corpse in the sewer. Marius has the damaged coat. He can recognise the body because it was his own.

This discovery brings the novel’s long sequence of mistaken identifications to a precise conclusion. A courtroom once prepared to send an innocent man to prison because witnesses recognised his face. Marius can now correct his own judgement because a piece of material fits a particular tear and he knows where the coat was worn. Thénardier has finally acquired evidence strong enough to prove something. Its meaning is the exact reverse of the one he hoped to sell.

Marius takes Cosette to Valjean. They find him dying, with the bishop’s candlesticks beside him. He has time to receive their affection and to tell Cosette about Fantine. The mother whose wages, hair and teeth paid for the child’s supposed upkeep can at last be restored to her daughter by name. Valjean dies with both young people there, and the candlesticks that once furnished the evidence of a theft give their light to a family reunion.

Those candlesticks have travelled further than the bishop ever did. He could not have foreseen a little girl carrying water, a policeman at a sewer gate or a wounded republican returning to his grandfather. He knew only what would happen to the hungry man in front of him if he claimed the silver as his own. He gave it away. The rest of Les Misérables is what that decision gave Jean Valjean time to do.

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

The Trial by Franz Kafka: Plot Summary, the Court and the Ending Explained

Next
Next

Middlemarch Summary and Ending Explained: Dorothea, Lydgate and the Cost of Choosing a Life