Why Dmitri, Ivan and Alyosha Understand Guilt Differently
Three Sons Have Come to Discuss Their Father
Dmitri Karamazov wants his father to account for his inheritance. His father would prefer an audience. They agree to meet at a monastery, where a respected elder might help settle the dispute, and almost everybody arrives with a private understanding of what the occasion is for. One son wants justice, another studies the proceedings with intellectual interest, and the youngest knows enough about his family to dread what they might say in front of a man he loves. Fyodor Dostoevsky’s The Brothers Karamazov begins with the difficulty of getting these people into the same room. By the time a courtroom tries to establish what happened between them, the family has produced enough witnesses to tell several convincing stories.
A Family Meeting at the Monastery
Fyodor Pavlovich Karamazov has three acknowledged sons by two marriages. Dmitri, often called Mitya, is the son of his first wife. Ivan and Alexei, usually called Alyosha, are the sons of his second. All three grew up largely in other people’s care. Their father appears to have discovered the pleasures of being a patriarch relatively late, once the children were old enough to argue with him and the responsibilities of bringing them up had passed.
The quarrel with Dmitri has an awkward practical foundation. Money and property came through Dmitri’s mother. Over the years Fyodor has advanced his son various sums, and the two men profoundly disagree about what remains due. Dmitri believes his father has cheated him. Fyodor maintains that the accounts run the other way. Anyone hoping to establish the truth by deciding which man seems more honest faces an immediate difficulty. Fyodor enjoys deceiving people, while Dmitri can be perfectly sincere about money he has made almost no effort to count.
At the monastery, Fyodor performs the part of an outrageous guest with such enthusiasm that it becomes difficult to tell when his embarrassment is genuine. If he makes himself ridiculous first, he can treat everyone else’s contempt as a response he deliberately provoked. The tactic also makes ordinary correction nearly impossible. Someone who asks him to behave has already become another straight man in his performance. Alyosha, who lives at the monastery as a novice, experiences the occasion from the uncomfortable position of belonging to both households.
Dmitri’s arrival brings out the grievance behind the disputed accounts. Father and son are pursuing the same woman, Agrafena Alexandrovna, known as Grushenka. Money could give either man an advantage. A father who withholds his son’s inheritance and a rival who keeps a competitor short of cash may be doing precisely the same thing. Dmitri cannot separate his financial complaint from his sexual jealousy, and Fyodor knows how to aggravate both with one remark.
The elder Zosima makes the strangest gesture of the meeting. He bows down before Dmitri. Nobody present receives an explanation adequate to the occasion. Dmitri himself is overwhelmed. At a moment when everyone is trying to establish which Karamazov deserves the most contempt, the one person whose moral authority they have come to borrow treats the most visibly disorderly member of the family as someone before whom it is possible to kneel.
The Money Dmitri Cannot Give Back
Dmitri tells Alyosha how he became involved with Katerina Ivanovna, the woman he has promised to marry. Her father, a military officer, faced public disgrace over missing funds. Dmitri had money and knew the young woman might be persuaded to visit him to obtain it. He imagined the pleasure of making a proud woman come to him on humiliating terms. When she actually came, he gave her the money and let her leave unharmed.
Dmitri’s account is unusually frank about how close generosity and cruelty can stand in one person. He can take pride in giving Katerina the money and still remember with shame what made the gift possible. For Katerina, the memory carries its own obligation. She has been rescued by a man who saw her when she could least afford to refuse him anything. Her later determination to remain faithful to him has some of the character of a second visit, this time on terms she has chosen.
A separate sum now binds them. Katerina entrusted Dmitri with three thousand roubles to send to a relative. Instead, he used some of the money on a lavish excursion with Grushenka to Mokroye. What he lets people believe about that night will eventually matter almost as much as what he spent. For now, he tells Alyosha enough to make his immediate problem clear. He wants to go to Grushenka as a free man. He cannot bear to leave Katerina while she can regard him as someone who stole from her.
This explains why obtaining three thousand roubles becomes an emergency out of all proportion to an ordinary debt. Dmitri imagines that if he can lay the money before Katerina, he can recover the right to choose his future. It never quite occurs to him that she may have a different opinion about what he owes her. Even his plan to restore her dignity depends on his deciding what the payment will mean to them both.
Katerina makes a similar mistake with Grushenka. She receives her with conspicuous warmth and believes they have reached a generous understanding about Dmitri. She kisses Grushenka’s hand. Grushenka plays along until it is her turn to offer the answering gesture, then refuses. The scene is painful because the courtesy has been so exquisitely arranged that one woman can humiliate the other simply by declining to complete it. Alyosha, who has been enlisted as a family messenger, discovers how readily a witness can become part of the intended audience for an injury.
Fyodor meanwhile keeps three thousand roubles in an envelope for Grushenka if she comes to him. It is the very sum Dmitri needs. Smerdyakov, a servant in Fyodor’s household, knows about the envelope and the private signals by which his master expects to recognise a visitor. Common gossip identifies Fyodor as Smerdyakov’s father, although he has never acknowledged him as he has the other three sons. The acknowledged sons can come and go, quarrel with their father and explain themselves at length. The servant stays in the house and learns how its doors are opened.
What Ivan Cannot Accept
While Dmitri tries to find money, Ivan asks Alyosha to hear an argument. Ivan is the brother whom educated people invite to discuss religion and public affairs. In a tavern, talking to someone he loves, he sets aside much of that public manner. He has been collecting accounts of cruelty to children. His objection concerns what it would mean to accept a world in which these things have happened, even if somebody could demonstrate that the whole of creation would ultimately end in harmony.
A child’s suffering, as Ivan understands it, belongs to that child. A future community enjoying universal happiness has no clear authority to count the suffering as an acceptable contribution to its happiness. Even forgiveness raises a difficulty. A mother might forgive someone for what she herself has endured, but who has given her the right to forgive what was done to her child? Ivan’s reasoning keeps returning to the person whose consent everyone else finds it convenient to supply.
He follows the argument with an invented story usually called The Grand Inquisitor. Christ returns to earth in Seville during the Inquisition. An elderly churchman has him arrested and visits him in confinement. The Inquisitor argues that Christ asked ordinary people to bear more freedom than they can endure. Give people bread, certainty and an authority that relieves them of choosing, he suggests, and they will surrender the freedom Christ valued so highly. The churchman believes he has corrected a mistake in the original Christian undertaking.
Christ listens and kisses him. The old man releases his prisoner and tells him to go. When Ivan has finished speaking, Alyosha kisses his brother. It is a lovely piece of sibling mischief as well as an expression of love. Alyosha has taken his answer straight out of Ivan’s own composition. Ivan can imagine a gesture his philosophy cannot fully explain, and his little brother can borrow it without claiming to have solved the suffering of children.
The conversation also sharpens a danger familiar from Dostoevsky’s Crime and Punishment. An idea sounds different when someone takes it as permission to act. Ivan is capable of making fine distinctions about faith, freedom and moral obligation. Smerdyakov has been listening to him in a house where a cruel old man has money, two sons wish him gone and one of those sons has announced his hatred loudly enough for half the town to hear.
Alyosha Leaves the People Who Know How to Pray
The elder Zosima dies. People who admired him expect the treatment of his body to offer some outward confirmation of his exceptional holiness. Instead, the body begins to smell, and the speed with which the news travels exposes the rivalry beneath the monastery’s devotional life. Admirers experience humiliation. Detractors take pleasure in what they present as a correction to excessive reverence. A natural physical change becomes material for settling disputes among the living.
Alyosha is badly shaken. He has never required a general rule that good people’s bodies behave differently after death. What he wanted was for this particular man, who had shown so many others consideration, to receive a little honour in return. The distinction brings him surprisingly close to Ivan. Both brothers object to an arrangement of the world that seems willing to let a person they care about bear an undeserved indignity. Their difference emerges in what they do with the objection.
A companion named Rakitin takes Alyosha to visit Grushenka, anticipating the pleasure of seeing the young novice compromised. Grushenka is ready to tease him until she learns that Zosima has died. Her manner changes. She tells a folk story about a wicked woman whose one remembered kindness was giving away an onion. Offered a chance of rescue by means of that onion, the woman loses it when she tries to prevent anyone else coming up with her.
Grushenka thinks in modest units of goodness. Perhaps she has managed the equivalent of an onion by taking pity on someone for a moment. Alyosha, who has been surrounded by people calculating what the decomposition of a body establishes about a lifetime’s goodness, can recognise what she has actually done. She noticed that he was grieving and stopped what she was doing. He, in turn, treats the change as real. Their encounter succeeds partly because neither insists that the other must first become respectable.
Back at the monastery, listening to the Gospel account of the wedding at Cana, Alyosha dreams of Zosima at the feast. He goes outside and embraces the earth. His grief has passed through an encounter with the very woman his companions considered a danger to him. When he leaves the monastery to live among other people, he carries an experience of receiving kindness from someone who had considerably less confidence in her own goodness than many of his fellow mourners.
A Night at the Garden Window
Dmitri spends his remaining freedom trying to raise money. He appeals to a businessman, pursues a supposed opportunity that costs him precious time and turns to a wealthy lady whose enthusiasm for his prospects yields advice where he needs cash. These episodes can be extremely funny, partly because Dmitri believes the violence of his need ought to make it self-evident that somebody must lend to him. A potential lender sees a man with obscure security, an erratic history and a rapidly contracting deadline.
At Fyodor’s house, Smerdyakov has made sure Ivan understands how vulnerable their father would be if his usual attendants were incapacitated. Grigory, the old servant who helped raise the boys, is unwell. Smerdyakov suggests that he himself might suffer one of his epileptic seizures. He also makes Ivan aware that Dmitri knows the secret signals. Ivan finds the conversation repellent, senses that something is being asked of him and leaves town without compelling Smerdyakov to say plainly what he means.
Ivan’s departure creates an uncertainty that will torment him. Going away is perfectly consistent with wanting to escape a hateful family quarrel. It is also what a man might do if he privately wished something terrible would happen and preferred to be absent when it did. Ivan can remember what he said. His difficulty will be establishing, to his own satisfaction, how much he understood when he said it.
When Grushenka disappears from her lodgings, Dmitri assumes she has gone to Fyodor. He seizes a brass pestle and goes to his father’s garden. Looking through the window, he sees Fyodor waiting. He uses the signal associated with Grushenka, and his father responds eagerly. Dmitri has the weapon, the opportunity and the sight of the man whose money and invitation have helped drive him to distraction. At this decisive point the account leaves a gap. The reader will have to live for a while with much the same uncertainty as the people who investigate.
Grigory encounters Dmitri as he is escaping over the garden fence. Dmitri strikes him with the pestle, then comes back down to see what he has done. Grigory is bleeding heavily. The attempt to examine him leaves Dmitri covered in blood. He runs away believing he may have killed the man who helped bring him up. Coming back was an act of concern. The blood it puts on his clothes will look much like evidence of a further act of violence.
Dmitri learns that Grushenka has gone to Mokroye to meet a former lover, a Polish officer who abandoned her years ago. He suddenly has cash available. He reclaims his pistols, buys provisions and follows her. The change in his intention is easy to miss amid the preparations. He had gone to the garden afraid of losing Grushenka to his father. He goes to Mokroye expecting to see her choose another man and imagining that he can stage one last magnificent evening before ending his life.
Grushenka’s reunion has given her an opportunity she lacked while she waited for the officer. She can compare the person who once meant everything to her with the man actually sitting across the table. The meeting goes badly, and his dealings over money and cards make the distance between memory and present company painfully clear. She turns towards Dmitri. For a brief interval he has reason to imagine a common future, just when the police arrive to question him about the death of his father.
Why the Evidence Points to Dmitri
Fyodor has been murdered and the envelope prepared for Grushenka has been found empty. The investigators have a suspect who threatened the victim, needed the precise amount of money that disappeared, went armed to the scene, injured a witness and started spending freely almost immediately afterwards. Grigory has survived. To Dmitri this is wonderful news, since he believed himself responsible for his old servant’s death. To the investigators it means there is a living witness who can place their suspect in the garden.
Dmitri acknowledges his violence towards Grigory and denies killing Fyodor. Explaining the money requires him to disclose something he finds almost more degrading than the accusation. On his earlier excursion with Grushenka, he says, he spent only half of Katerina’s three thousand roubles. He sewed the remainder into a little packet and carried it on his person. That is the cash he has now begun spending. His long-standing reputation for having squandered three thousand in one spree rests partly on his own boasting and partly on the ease with which an expensive party becomes more expensive in the telling.
Why keep half while desperately trying to borrow the whole? Dmitri had constructed a private distinction. As long as he still carried fifteen hundred roubles, he could go to Katerina, return something and admit that he was a scoundrel. Once he spent the rest, he would have to call himself a thief. The reserve also left him money with which he might run away with Grushenka. He had found a way of preserving two incompatible futures in one packet and could bring himself to surrender neither until the night at Mokroye.
It is a persuasive account of how this particular man thinks. As evidence it has a conspicuous weakness. Nobody reliable saw him sew up the money or wear it. People did see him spending, and they heard him describe the cost of the earlier party. His defence requires strangers to appreciate a distinction about honour that even sympathetic listeners might find self-serving. Every hour he previously spent concealing his conduct from Katerina has made the true explanation harder to prove.
During the investigation Dmitri dreams of a peasant woman carrying a crying baby amid scenes of cold and devastation. He wants to know why the child is crying and what anyone is going to do about it. Ivan had invited Alyosha to consider whether the suffering of a child can ever be justified. Dmitri, exhausted after his arrest, experiences the question as an impulse to help. When he later speaks about accepting suffering, that desire is genuine. It still gives a court no sound basis for deciding who killed his father.
What Ivan Learns From Smerdyakov
Over the following weeks Alyosha also attends to a sick schoolboy, Ilyusha. The boy’s father, Captain Snegiryov, was publicly humiliated by Dmitri, who dragged him by his beard in front of his son. Ilyusha tried to defend his father and has endured taunts from other children. The incident has received little attention in Dmitri’s grand account of his misfortunes. In the captain’s household it has become an event around which ordinary life has reorganised itself.
Alyosha helps bring the boys together around their sick friend. One of them, Kolya Krasotkin, arrives with a dog that Ilyusha feared he had killed after playing a cruel trick on it. The dog’s appearance gives the child relief that no abstract assurance about his goodness could have supplied. Kolya deserves credit for finding and training the animal. He has also prolonged the uncertainty to secure an impressive reveal. Even this genuinely kind visit contains a little of the desire to manage an audience that has caused so much trouble among the adults.
Meanwhile Ivan repeatedly visits Smerdyakov. At first the servant makes him confront the implications of going away when danger was foreseeable. As the conversations continue, Ivan begins to hear a claim beyond reproach. Smerdyakov thinks the two men had an understanding. Ivan’s departure, in his reading, conveyed permission. Ivan remembers disgust, hints and silences. Smerdyakov has assembled them into instructions.
In their final interview, Smerdyakov admits that he killed Fyodor. He describes feigning the initial seizure that placed him beyond suspicion. Dmitri came to the window and left without killing his father. Once Dmitri had struck Grigory and fled, Smerdyakov could exploit both the confusion outside and Fyodor’s eagerness to see Grushenka. He persuaded his master that she was there, and when Fyodor leaned out to look, Smerdyakov struck him with an iron paperweight. He took the money, leaving the opened envelope where its discovery would suggest an obvious motive.
The account explains something the public case cannot. The servant has detailed knowledge of how Fyodor was induced to expose himself, the household arrangements that made the approach possible and the disposition of the stolen money. He hands Ivan three thousand roubles. The cash is powerful corroboration for Ivan, who knows where he received it. Once it changes hands, however, it becomes money that Ivan possesses. A courtroom cannot witness the exchange simply because he describes it.
Smerdyakov insists that Ivan bears the principal responsibility. That part of his confession deserves much more resistance than his account of the physical act. Ivan’s ideas interested him. Ivan went away despite understanding at least some of the danger. Neither fact removes the series of deliberate choices Smerdyakov has just described making himself. Indeed, his pride in the ingenuity of his arrangements sits uneasily beside his insistence that somebody else was their true author.
Ivan decides to speak. By now he is feverish and seriously unwell. Back in his lodgings, he experiences a visitor whom he recognises and argues with as the devil. The visitor has the irritating familiarity of a man who knows Ivan’s ideas well enough to repeat them in a cheaper form. Ivan’s mind can supply both sides of a conversation and still leave him desperate for an external witness. Alyosha arrives with the news that Smerdyakov has taken his own life. The only other participant in the confession can no longer be questioned.
What Does the Jury Hear?
At the trial, the evidence reaches the jury in a different order from the one in which it reached the reader. We have spent hours with Dmitri before his arrest and have heard Smerdyakov speak in private. The jurors must evaluate public conduct, physical evidence and the testimony of witnesses whose relationships give them strong reasons to protect or accuse. People in the gallery have come prepared to enjoy eloquence. Two accomplished advocates are more than ready to supply it.
Ivan produces the money and identifies Smerdyakov as the killer. He also accuses himself of responsibility and becomes visibly distressed. His account contains information the court urgently needs, yet the form of his testimony makes it easier to dismiss. His illness is real. So is the confession he received. Treating either fact as sufficient to dispose of the other is precisely the kind of shortcut the evidence cannot bear.
Katerina then produces a drunken letter in which Dmitri described killing his father to obtain the three thousand roubles. Its force comes from its date. Written before the murder, it looks like a plan preserved by chance, with details that subsequent events appear to have confirmed. Katerina has previously tried to protect Dmitri. Seeing Ivan disintegrate changes what she is prepared to disclose. A document can remain physically identical while the person who holds it changes the purpose it will serve.
The prosecution turns Dmitri’s turbulent history into a coherent portrait of a man capable of parricide. The defence challenges the quality of the proof and offers rival explanations for facts that have begun to seem decisive through repetition. The lawyers can make the same action point in opposite directions. Going back to Grigory might show kindness, or a calculation about whether a witness will survive. Neither counsel has access to the private moment when Dmitri decided to climb back down from the fence.
The jury convicts him. Dmitri is sentenced to twenty years of penal servitude in Siberia. He has struck Grigory, humiliated the captain, misused Katerina’s money and threatened his father. He has quite enough to answer for without taking responsibility for Smerdyakov’s act. The verdict acquires much of its emotional plausibility from an illicit exchange. Evidence of several real wrongs has been allowed to stand in for proof of the particular wrong on the indictment.
Why Does the Novel End With the Schoolboys?
After the verdict, an escape is contemplated. Ivan has helped devise a plan that could allow Dmitri and Grushenka to reach America. Dmitri speaks of returning eventually to Russia. He has discovered that imagining a great act of endurance and consenting to endure twenty years of a punishment imposed on false grounds are different undertakings. Alyosha gives him room to recognise the difference. The book leaves the escape as a proposal. It never shows Dmitri living freely abroad.
Katerina visits Dmitri while he is in hospital. Their encounter allows an acknowledgement of the love and injury between them without restoring their engagement or neatly reconciling everyone involved. Grushenka has her own grounds for resentment. Ivan remains ill. A family that once expected a meeting with a holy elder to settle its affairs has reached the end of a criminal trial with almost every important relationship still requiring attention.
The final gathering is for Ilyusha, who has died. His father’s grief has an intimacy that makes the great public performances of the trial feel remote. A pair of little boots can carry more of the particular child he has lost than any eloquent account of the suffering of children. The boys who once quarrelled with Ilyusha now have memories of visiting him, caring about his dog and belonging to a group in which he had a place.
At a stone associated with their friend, Alyosha asks them to remember what they have done together. He allows for the possibility that some of them will grow up to behave badly or laugh at their present feelings. A good memory might still remain available to someone who has changed. This is a modest claim for what their friendship can accomplish. It cannot give Ilyusha back to his father or supply the justification for suffering that Ivan found impossible to accept.
It can preserve a fact about the boy that the family quarrel would otherwise swallow. To readers following Dmitri’s case, Ilyusha first appears as the son of a man a Karamazov injured. By the last page, Dmitri is absent and the boys are calling out to one another. They know things about their friend that no Karamazov could have told them. Alyosha’s last service is to bring them together long enough to understand that, from now on, they will be the people who remember him.
Sources
The Brothers Karamazov — Project Gutenberg. Complete novel in Constance Garnett’s English translation, including Smerdyakov’s account, the trial and the epilogue. Project Gutenberg
The Brothers Karamazov — Full Book Summary. Independent cross-check of the principal relationships and narrative sequence. www.sparknotes.com
The Brothers Karamazov — Christian Classics Ethereal Library. Searchable edition for comparing the private confession with the evidence presented in court. ccel.org