The Mayor of Casterbridge Explained: Henchard, Elizabeth-Jane and the Meaning of His Last Request

Why Does Michael Henchard Ask to Be Forgotten in The Mayor of Casterbridge?

The Family Secret in The Mayor of Casterbridge

Five Guineas Changes Hands at Weydon-Priors Fair

Michael Henchard walks into a fair with his wife and their little girl. By the following morning, he has five guineas in his pocket and no idea where his family has gone. Thomas Hardy opens The Mayor of Casterbridge with an outrage committed in company. There are witnesses, somebody willing to act as auctioneer and a man prepared to pay. What takes the rest of the novel to discover is which part of the evening each person believes was binding. Henchard can give up drink, build a business and rise high enough to sit in judgement on others. Susan and her daughter have to make lives out of what he did before he was sorry.

The Morning After the Auction

Henchard is a young hay-trusser travelling in search of work. At Weydon-Priors, Susan steers him towards a tent selling furmity, a dish of grain cooked in milk, rather than towards the more obvious attractions of the drinking booths. She has made one small, practical decision intended to get her family safely through the evening. What she cannot see is the bottle from which the woman serving Henchard discreetly adds rum to his bowl. Several helpings later, he is explaining to strangers how much better he might have done for himself without a wife.

The other customers initially treat him as entertainment. Henchard makes them an offer and then keeps pushing until what sounded like drunken bluster becomes a public auction. A sailor called Richard Newson puts up five guineas. Susan gives her husband opportunities to withdraw. When he persists, she takes their daughter, Elizabeth-Jane, and leaves with Newson. She also returns her wedding ring in a manner Henchard is unlikely to forget. Her departure is the one decision that evening over which he assumed she would exercise no authority of her own.

By daylight he would give a great deal to undo the transaction. But asking for help to find his family would involve telling people how he lost them. Even his efforts to recover Susan are constrained by the reputation of a man who, as yet, has scarcely any reputation to lose. He searches without success, then enters a church and promises to abstain from alcohol for twenty-one years, one year for each year he has lived.

There is something impressive about the oath. There is also something distinctly Henchard-like about drawing up a penalty whose length he can count and whose fulfilment he can supervise himself. He can wake each morning knowing exactly what keeping sober requires. Working out what Susan now wants would be a less orderly undertaking. Hardy allows the reader to admire his capacity for reform while noticing that the injured woman has had no say in the terms.

The Mayor Behind the Window

Roughly eighteen years later, Susan and a young woman called Elizabeth-Jane return to the fair. Newson is believed lost at sea. Susan has learnt that the auction did not give it the power over her marriage that she once attributed to it. She wants to find Henchard, partly because she must consider what security she can offer her daughter. The woman who sold the furmity is still earning what she can at the fair. From her they learn where Henchard went.

In Casterbridge, mother and daughter reach a hotel where a public dinner is taking place. From outside, Elizabeth-Jane can see an important man at the table. He is the mayor, a prosperous corn and hay merchant. It is Henchard. By bringing Susan up to a window before admitting her to his company, Hardy lets the young woman discover exactly what the inhabitants know about him. They know where he sits, what business he conducts and even that he drinks water while others take wine. The two women in the street know why.

The dinner provides an introduction to a second man. Henchard’s customers have had bad bread from damaged grain, and he has publicly acknowledged the limits of what he knows about making the wheat fit to use. A young Scotsman passing through Casterbridge sends in a possible remedy. Donald Farfrae has listened to an awkward commercial problem and recognised one to which he possesses a technical answer. He has no expectation that the exchange will determine where he lives or whom he marries. Henchard, delighted by his competence and manner, sets about persuading him to stay.

That same evening, Elizabeth-Jane helps with the work at the inn where she and Susan are lodging. Money is short, and she can see a way to reduce what their stay will cost. Henchard will later be embarrassed to discover that she once served in this capacity. The reader gets to see the act before hearing his opinion of it. A customer needs attending to, an innkeeper needs help, and a daughter wants to spare her mother an expense. It takes a newly important father to find anything shameful in the arrangement.

How Henchard Reconstructs a Family

Henchard meets Susan privately in the Ring, the remains of a Roman amphitheatre. He wishes to provide for her and Elizabeth-Jane. He also wants their future household to look like one Casterbridge can understand. The solution is a public courtship. Susan will appear to be a sailor’s widow whom the mayor has chosen to marry. Elizabeth-Jane, who understands herself to be Newson’s daughter, can enter his household without hearing what happened in the tent.

There is kindness in providing for Susan, and considerable vanity in designing the story by which the neighbours will explain it. The second wedding cannot restore the years taken from the first marriage. It can produce a household in which Henchard no longer has to encounter an obvious consequence of his behaviour each time he opens his front door. Susan accepts the arrangement with less enthusiasm for its theatrical possibilities. She has brought Elizabeth-Jane somewhere she hopes the girl will be cared for. On that point, at least, they seem to agree.

Henchard is eager for his new manager’s confidence. He tells Farfrae both about the sale and about another woman to whom he has an obligation. While ill in Jersey, he became close to Lucetta, whose association with him has compromised her reputation. Believing himself effectively free, he intended to make amends by marrying her. Susan’s return makes that impossible. He now has two women whom he believes he ought to treat honourably and two incompatible ideas of what honour requires. For a man who likes to give his word decisively, previous promises keep proving a remarkable nuisance.

Farfrae receives the confidences with sympathy. He does not attach the same significance to hearing them that Henchard attaches to telling them. Henchard has employed a gifted manager and found himself ready to love him almost as a son. Farfrae thinks he has accepted a job from a generous man and become his friend. Both understandings can coexist while things go well. Trouble begins when Henchard expects an employee’s obedience and something close to a son’s exclusive loyalty in return for a confidence Farfrae never asked him to disclose.

How Farfrae Becomes a Rival Without Trying

Farfrae’s appeal becomes most apparent when a workman called Abel Whittle oversleeps. Henchard has warned him repeatedly and decides to make an example of him by sending him off to work without his breeches. To the employer, the threatened humiliation is an overdue remedy for a persistent fault. To Abel, whose neighbours will see him exposed, the prospect is unbearable. Farfrae intervenes and lets him dress. The work can still be done.

Henchard has helped Abel’s elderly mother in circumstances where no audience was present to applaud him. He knows this and feels the unfairness of being thought a worse friend to the family than the newcomer. But an act of charity does not purchase the right to humiliate its beneficiary’s son. What infuriates Henchard is partly the ease with which Farfrae obtains the men’s affection. Farfrae need only prevent an indignity that would never have occurred had Henchard been willing to back down in public.

A holiday celebration makes the difference between them visible across the town. Henchard plans generously but counts on fine weather. Farfrae arranges shelter for his entertainment. When rain comes, the people go where they can enjoy themselves without getting wet. Henchard experiences their perfectly intelligible preference as a personal judgement. He hears people admiring Farfrae, sees the younger man dancing with Elizabeth-Jane and allows his resentment to break out. The employment ends. Farfrae establishes his own business, and Henchard instructs Elizabeth-Jane to have no more to do with him.

The commercial irony is exact. While Farfrae worked for him, Henchard owned the business to which the younger man’s foresight brought an advantage. By insisting on being first in the affections of people he employs, he creates the competitor he feared. The rain has not singled him out for punishment. Both men got the same weather. Only one regarded the possibility of getting it as more important than the pleasure of imagining a splendid afternoon.

The Letter Susan Wanted Left Unopened

Susan dies having left a sealed letter for Henchard, with instructions that it be opened on Elizabeth-Jane’s wedding day. He has already decided to tell the young woman that he is her father. It is an awkward disclosure because she loves the sailor she grew up calling father, yet she receives it with a willingness to love Henchard too. For a brief interval he has the relationship he wanted and a daughter prepared to do the emotional work his confession demands.

Then he opens Susan’s letter early. The little girl carried away from Weydon-Priors died in childhood. Susan subsequently had a daughter with Newson and gave her the same name. The Elizabeth-Jane now living with Henchard is the sailor’s biological child. The disclosure works because Henchard and the reader have made the same unexamined inference. A woman left carrying a little girl of that name and returned with a young woman of the right name and approximate age. Nobody asked Susan about a loss she had excellent reasons to remember even when she had reasons to conceal it.

Henchard’s response exposes a limit in his idea of fatherly love. Elizabeth-Jane is the same person the morning after he reads the letter. She has shown him kindness on the strength of information he provided. Yet he cools towards her, finds fault with her speech and manners, and resents evidence that she once worked to pay her way. He cannot reproach her for having the wrong father without admitting what he has discovered. Instead, she has to endure a succession of smaller reproaches whose cause she has no means of identifying.

Susan’s instruction deserves attention here. Had Henchard waited until Elizabeth-Jane married, she might already have had an independent home when he learnt the truth. We cannot know everything Susan hoped to achieve by specifying the date. We can see the consequence of ignoring it. Henchard gets an answer to a private question immediately, and the young woman living under his roof pays for his disappointment. He has behaved as though the seal on a letter were an obstacle between himself and something he owns. The timing belonged to Susan too.

Elizabeth-Jane’s response to uncertainty is quieter. She studies, watches other people and tries to acquire the education she missed. When a well-off woman offers companionship and a different home at High-Place Hall, she accepts. The woman is Lucetta, newly established in Casterbridge after coming into money. Henchard’s impatience with his daughter has placed her in the house of the woman whose history he most needs to keep private.

Lucetta Chooses Farfrae

Lucetta’s inheritance gives her a degree of independence that she lacked in Jersey. She comes to Casterbridge with a future marriage to Henchard in view now that Susan is dead. In another novel, an altered fortune and a widower’s freedom might conveniently settle the difficulty. Here, having the means to choose makes Lucetta considerably less certain she wants the man whom necessity once required her to marry.

She meets Farfrae and falls for him. He encounters an attractive, independent woman in a handsome house and knows little about the anxious hopes with which she furnished it. Elizabeth-Jane, who has reason to care for him herself, watches their attachment develop from within the household. Hardy gives her a difficult position without making her vindictive. She can recognise what Lucetta wants, suffer from it and still refuse to take advantage of something she has observed in confidence. It is precisely the distinction that several more powerful people in the town fail to maintain.

For Henchard, Lucetta’s preference introduces an intolerable element of comparison. Farfrae already has customers and popularity he once enjoyed. Now his former manager can win the woman Henchard remembers as passionately dependent on his good opinion. He presses the claims of their past and the danger Lucetta would face if it became known. A marriage once proposed as a means of protecting her begins to look like something she might have to accept to protect herself from him.

Lucetta secretly marries Farfrae. She is entitled to choose him, although secrecy cannot give her the secure future she imagines. Her husband has made his choice without knowing an episode that their neighbours would judge much more severely in her than in Henchard. Telling Farfrae herself might place the truth inside a relationship capable of withstanding it. It might also cost her that relationship. Hardy makes her delay comprehensible by giving her something real to lose. The longer she waits, the more people acquire the power to speak first.

Henchard’s own reputation fails under far plainer circumstances. Sitting as a magistrate, he encounters the old furmity seller, brought before the bench. She recognises the man judging her and recounts the wife sale. He could dismiss her as an unreliable witness. Instead, he acknowledges that her account is true. This is one occasion when his abruptness serves him well. Faced with a particular woman telling a particular truth, he speaks more honourably than he did through all the careful arrangements intended to make his second marriage look proper.

His business is also failing. Seeking advance knowledge of the weather, he acts on a prediction, commits himself heavily in the grain market and loses. Farfrae prospers and eventually occupies the house and business premises Henchard once possessed. Yet at his bankruptcy Henchard tries to surrender even small personal items for the benefit of his creditors. There is genuine decency in the gesture. What he can do for men to whom he owes a measurable sum remains markedly easier for him than making amends to someone free to tell him what she needs.

When Casterbridge Turns Private Letters Into Street Theatre

Lucetta wants the letters she wrote to Henchard returned. They are dangerous because they preserve the intensity of her earlier attachment in her own words. Henchard entrusts them to Joshua Jopp, who has grievances of his own. Jopp opens the packet. The contents reach listeners with none of the obligations that complicated the matter for the original correspondents. What was once an urgent appeal from one person to another becomes an evening’s entertainment for strangers.

The result is a skimmity-ride, a noisy procession in which effigies of Henchard and Lucetta publicly enact the scandal. Hardy has prepared us for it since the fair. The people in the furmity tent could tell themselves that a husband’s outrageous offer was merely a bit of fun, right up to the moment Susan walked away. Here each spectator can regard a contribution to the spectacle as small. Somebody makes a figure, somebody carries it, somebody calls a neighbour to the window. Lucetta gets the cumulative effect of every small contribution at once.

She sees the effigies, collapses and dies following the shock. She is pregnant. The loss is devastating partly because the procession has obtained no knowledge that could justify the certainty with which it passes sentence. Its participants have learnt that Lucetta once loved Henchard. They do not know what he promised, what she endured in Jersey, what Farfrae would have forgiven or how frightened she was in the days before they brought the figures to her door. Having some genuine letters proves sufficient to give a crowd the pleasures of omniscience.

One of the effigies has a strange second use. In despair, Henchard goes to the water contemplating his own death and sees what appears to be his body there already. It is the likeness used in the procession. The sight interrupts him. Casterbridge built the thing to make a caricature of him, yet in the privacy of that encounter it gives him a view of his intended act from outside. A representation that helped kill Lucetta accidentally helps keep Henchard alive. Hardy grants the spectacle an afterlife nobody who organised it could have intended.

What Henchard Tells the Man at His Door

Elizabeth-Jane cares for Henchard as his position deteriorates. Their best period together comes after he has lost the wealth with which he once imagined he could make a daughter happy. He learns the routines of having her near and discovers how much her company matters. She has acquired a father’s place for him through the ordinary practice of coming back. This time he loves her in full knowledge that she is Newson’s child.

Then Newson himself arrives. He survived, and he wants to find his daughter. Henchard has only to see what the visitor wants to recognise the danger to the life he has rebuilt. Instead of letting Elizabeth-Jane decide how she might accommodate two fathers, he tells Newson that she has died. The sailor goes away grieving. No drunkenness, public provocation or bad commercial advice can account for this lie. Henchard knows precisely whom he is taking from whom.

The cruelty has grown out of a genuine change for the better. Earlier, Henchard punished Elizabeth-Jane for being Newson’s child. Now he loves her enough to dread losing her. His remaining failure is the belief that love gives him a right to manage what she knows. He treats her affection as though there were a fixed quantity of it, all his until the sailor returns and all Newson’s afterwards. A man who has spent years trading in things that change hands still struggles to imagine something two people could receive without either being robbed.

When Newson returns again, concealment becomes impossible. Elizabeth-Jane learns that her father is alive and that Henchard sent him away believing her dead. Her anger is deserved. It also arrives at the point when Henchard has least to fall back on. Farfrae and Elizabeth-Jane are to marry. The man who was once his manager and the sailor whose place he briefly occupied will both belong naturally at a celebration to which his own right of admission is uncertain. Henchard leaves town.

Why Does Henchard Ask to Be Forgotten?

Henchard returns for the wedding with a modest present, a caged goldfinch. He has little money left. Unlike the finery with which he once hoped to establish a mayor’s daughter, the bird is something he has chosen by standing outside shops and considering what he can actually afford. Elizabeth-Jane, still hurt by what he did to Newson, receives him coldly. He slips away. The covered cage is overlooked, and the bird starves.

What eventually reaches Elizabeth-Jane is the scale of the effort hidden inside that small purchase. She knew Henchard had deceived her. She had not understood what it cost him to walk into the wedding or what hope he had invested in being allowed to give her something. The dead bird changes the question from whether she was entitled to resent him to whether resentment expressed everything she felt. By the time she and Farfrae find him, he has died in a cottage attended by Abel Whittle.

Abel is the last man one might have expected Henchard to have beside him. He remembers the employer who threatened to send him through the streets half dressed. He also remembers what Henchard did for his mother. Where the skimmity riders took a few private letters as authority to judge a whole person, Abel can hold two contradictory pieces of knowledge and still bring food to a sick man. His care is among the least theatrical acts in a book crowded with declarations. It is also the final evidence we receive from someone who knew Henchard well enough to have a grievance against him.

Henchard’s written instructions ask that Elizabeth-Jane be spared the news of his death, that the usual funeral observances be omitted and that nobody remember him. It is tempting to take this as a final verdict on the life we have read. Listen to the form of it, though. The man who once prescribed twenty-one years of abstinence as the exact answer to his guilt is still specifying what others ought to do, right down to whether flowers may be planted. There is tenderness in his wish to spare Elizabeth-Jane further grief. There is also one last attempt to determine her feelings before she can speak for herself.

Elizabeth-Jane survives him and gives his life a meaning his instructions cannot settle. She knows the lie he told her father and the price of the little bird. At Weydon-Priors a tent full of people heard Henchard insist that he could give his family away. At the end, alone with a piece of paper, he imagines he can give away his place in another person’s memory. The woman who goes looking for him has understood something he never quite could: she can remember what he did, wish she had been kinder at the wedding and love him still.

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

Persuasion by Jane Austen: Anne Elliot, Captain Wentworth and the Letter Explained

Next
Next

Silas Marner Explained: The Stolen Gold, Eppie’s Choice and the Ending