The Sound and the Fury Explained: Benjy’s Timeline, Caddy and the Final Carriage Ride

Why Does Benjy Cry at the End of The Sound and the Fury?

What Happens to the Compson Family?

A Golfer Calls Out His Sister’s Name

Benjy Compson is standing at a fence when a golfer calls for his caddie. On the course, the word belongs to a game. On Benjy’s side of the wire, it sounds like Caddy, the sister who used to know what he wanted before anyone else had even noticed he was upset. William Faulkner gives us the sound before he gives us the family history. We have to learn why an ordinary Saturday afternoon in Mississippi can contain a childhood that ended decades ago. The best guide through The Sound and the Fury is often the person Benjy is trying to reach. Whenever the date seems impossible or two people appear to have the same name, look for Caddy. Where is she, how old is she, and who is telling us what she did?

How to Find Your Bearings in Benjy’s Saturday

It is 7 April 1928, Benjy’s thirty-third birthday. Luster, the teenage grandson of the Compsons’ Black servant Dilsey, is looking after him. Luster has also lost a quarter and wants to find it so he can go to a show. One of the most demanding opening chapters in American fiction therefore begins with two fairly simple desires. Benjy wants to stay where he can watch the golfers. Luster would like his money back. They have an afternoon to get through together, and neither can explain to the other why his particular concern deserves priority.

Benjy has an intellectual disability and does not communicate through conventional speech. His section nevertheless gives him the first sustained account of the family. He registers what people say, where they stand, how things smell and what happens when he cries. What he rarely supplies is the interval between two experiences. When his clothes catch on a nail at the fence, Caddy is suddenly there helping him free. The nail belongs to the walk with Luster and to an earlier journey with his sister. Faulkner moves across the years at the point where the two sensations meet.

The people caring for Benjy offer a more dependable clock than the typography. When Luster is beside him, the action is generally taking place on that birthday in 1928. When Versh appears, Benjy is usually a much younger child. T.P., Versh’s brother, helps locate another stretch of Benjy’s life, including Caddy’s wedding. Italics flag many shifts, but the return to ordinary type need not bring us back to Saturday. Listening for a change of companion works particularly well if you are hearing the novel read aloud.

Another apparent puzzle concerns Benjy’s own name. As a small boy he is called Maury, after his mother Caroline’s brother. His parents rename him Benjamin after his disability becomes apparent. The change can make an early scene sound as though it contains an extra Compson child. It also tells us something rather precise about Caroline. A family name is a distinction to be conferred or withdrawn according to what the bearer might reflect back on the family. Benjy still needs the same care the morning after he is renamed. It is hard to identify a single difficulty of his that the adults have solved.

The land across the fence has changed names and uses too. What looks like an ordinary golf course to the players was once the Compson pasture. The family sold land to help pay for the things it considered necessary to its standing, including Quentin’s Harvard education. Benjy experiences that transaction in its least abstract form. People once crossed a familiar piece of ground together. Now other people play on it, and a wire marks the place where he must stop. Long before we know much about the Compson finances, we know what a sale feels like to the person left looking through the fence.

What Caddy Sees from the Tree

One childhood memory gives the family a shape. On the night their grandmother, whom the children call Damuddy, dies, the adults keep the children away from what is happening inside. Caddy climbs a tree to look through the window. From below, her brothers can see the mud on her drawers. She has got dirty playing in the branch earlier that day. To her, the climb has an evident purpose. Someone ought to find out what the adults are doing, and she is prepared to go up and look.

This is a good scene to remember whenever somebody describes Caddy later. Her brothers can see something she cannot, and she can see something they cannot. They are looking up at the girl in the tree while she is looking into the house. The difference sounds obvious until one considers how much of the novel will consist of men examining Caddy for signs of something. Here, at least, we can recover the direction of her own interest. She is curious about a death in the family. The mud on her underwear is of considerably greater interest to the people down below.

Benjy loves her partly because she pays attention to the consequences of what she does. When she wears perfume and he becomes distressed, she washes it off. His familiar measure of her presence is the smell of trees. He cannot explain that the new scent has made someone dear to him suddenly difficult to recognise. She works it out by attending to him. It is easy to miss how much intelligence goes into her care because she is young, affectionate and apparently doing something that comes naturally. Other members of the family have years to learn what she knows. Few make the attempt.

As Caddy grows older, the cost of making everything familiar for Benjy rises. Perfume can be washed away. A developing sexual life, a marriage and a departure from home cannot be managed on the same terms. At her wedding, Benjy needs the girl who used to comfort him precisely because that girl is getting married. People around him experience his crying as a disruption to an important occasion. From inside his account, the wedding is the disruption. Both experiences belong to the same event, and the bride cannot make the contradiction disappear by being kinder.

One of Benjy’s memories becomes particularly painful once we understand the history of the gate. He goes towards a schoolgirl, wanting to communicate, and frightens her. His account conveys the effort to say something and the failure of words to come. The girl has no access to that interior experience. The family subsequently has Benjy castrated. Faulkner presents the event and its aftermath in fragments, leaving us to put together a sequence other people have acted upon with terrible certainty. We have occupied Benjy’s perspective long enough to know how little of it was available to the people who made that decision for him.

Back in 1928 there is another young woman around the house, and somebody is calling her Quentin. Here the book makes one of its most important distinctions. Quentin Compson is Caddy’s older brother. Miss Quentin is Caddy’s daughter, named after him. The girl in Benjy’s birthday present and the young man whose bedroom we enter next belong to different generations. As with the recurring family names in One Hundred Years of Solitude, recognising the repetition is only the beginning. The harder question is what the younger person inherits along with the name.

Why Quentin Breaks His Watch

The second section takes us back nearly eighteen years to 2 June 1910. Quentin Compson is a Harvard student waking in Massachusetts. He can hear the watch his father gave him, an object that once belonged to his grandfather. He breaks its glass and pulls off its hands. The watch goes on ticking. It is a beautifully exact account of a failed experiment. Quentin has removed his means of reading the time and done nothing to diminish his awareness of its passage.

Outside his room, clocks and bells keep the day moving for everybody else. Quentin even enters a watchmaker’s shop, where he wants to know whether the displayed clocks are right and does not want to be told the hour. That peculiar request opens up his state of mind more effectively than a speech about despair. Part of him longs for somebody to certify that a dependable measure of time exists. Another part cannot bear to receive the information it would give him. The watchmaker has been asked to help with a problem no adjustment to a watch could reach.

What Quentin wants preserved is a particular idea of Caddy. She has had sex, become pregnant and married Herbert Head. In Quentin’s memories, her relationship with Dalton Ames concentrates much of his distress. He imagines that a brother ought to be able to defend his sister’s honour. Caddy herself does not understand her experience in those terms, which leaves an extraordinary vacancy at the centre of his supposed duty. Who has asked him to perform it? What conceivable outcome could restore to her something she does not agree he owns?

Quentin tells his father that he and Caddy have committed incest. The confession is false. Its emotional logic is that he could place himself inside what has happened and make the consequences theirs to bear together. He can imagine sharing punishment with Caddy more readily than he can imagine an adult life of hers in which he plays a smaller part. His father refuses to accept the confession. He also suggests that the sexual purity Quentin reveres has much of its importance in the minds of the men who prize it. This might release a different son from an impossible obligation. Quentin hears another reason to be ashamed. Even the scale of his suffering may belong chiefly to himself.

Quentin’s encounters in Massachusetts show how little room this private drama leaves for anybody he meets. He tries to help a little Italian girl get home. He buys her bread and takes responsibility for her without understanding where she lives or being able to make himself properly understood. Her brother comes to believe Quentin has taken her away, and the authorities become involved. For once the reader can watch a protective impulse from outside the Compson family. Quentin means the child well. He also decides what part he ought to play in her life before he knows enough to be much use.

Later, in the company of fellow student Gerald Bland, talk and memory run so close together that Quentin’s old confrontation with Dalton seems to occupy the present. An altercation leaves him physically battered. The difficulty of his prose is doing something specific here. If Faulkner supplied neat quotation marks and introduced each remembered speaker, we might imagine Quentin sorting one humiliation from the next. His inability to make that separation is precisely what the people sharing his afternoon cannot see. They encounter a young man behaving strangely towards Gerald. We have been hearing another man’s name.

Quentin puts his affairs in order, attends to small matters of dress and prepares for his death. He dies by suicide in Massachusetts. Faulkner leaves the death itself outside the narrated action of the day. The section stays with the unnerving continuance of routine, including the business of brushing his teeth. Harvard had represented the family’s investment in the future, purchased in part with the land Benjy loved. The reader now knows something none of the Compsons could have understood when they made that calculation. The young man sent away to carry the family forward has devoted the last day of his life to something he cannot change in its past.

How Jason Makes Money from Caddy’s Exile

The next date is 6 April 1928, Good Friday. We have moved forward nearly eighteen years and landed one day before Benjy’s opening section. Jason, the surviving brother who works in a farm-supply shop, is arguing with his niece. Miss Quentin has been missing school. He threatens her, and Dilsey intervenes. After the difficulty of Quentin’s thoughts, Jason is disconcertingly easy to follow. He identifies an offence, names a culprit and announces what ought to be done. Give him a few pages and it becomes clear why fluency is such a poor test of whether to trust a storyteller.

Jason traces his grievances back to Caddy’s marriage. Herbert Head was supposed to give him a bank job. When the marriage broke down over Caddy’s pregnancy by another man, that opportunity disappeared. Jason treats the missing job as though he had held it for years and Caddy had personally dismissed him. Every subsequent disappointment can therefore be charged against an old debt. The arrangement has obvious advantages for a brother who wants to call himself a practical man. He never has to discover whether he would actually have made a success of banking.

Caddy’s daughter has grown up in the Compson household while Caddy herself has been kept away. Caroline considers her daughter a disgrace. Jason can exploit that judgement because mother and daughter still need something from each other. Caddy wants news of her child, a chance to see her and some assurance that she has money. Miss Quentin needs the support Caddy sends. Jason controls the passage between them. The more rigidly his mother insists that the house must have nothing to do with Caddy, the more valuable her private dealings with him become.

One remembered incident makes the cruelty of that position plain. Caddy pays Jason for a chance to see her little girl. He takes her money and lets her see the child only in passing, from a moving carriage. He can claim to have delivered exactly what she purchased. Any ordinary understanding of what a mother means when she asks to see her child would have required something different. Caddy has to bargain with a man who will interpret every word to his advantage, and there is nobody to whom she can appeal without risking what little access remains.

The regular payments work through a more elaborate deception. Caroline believes she is dramatically refusing Caddy’s help by burning her cheques. Jason substitutes pieces of paper that permit his mother to perform the refusal while he keeps the real proceeds. Caddy believes she is supporting her daughter. Caroline believes the family is too proud to accept the money. Jason collects the financial benefit of maintaining both beliefs. Follow the money through those three pairs of hands and his favourite claim, that he alone supports an ungrateful household, becomes difficult to hear with a straight face.

On Good Friday, Caddy sends a money order that requires Miss Quentin’s signature. For a moment a practical obstacle enters the scheme. Something must pass through the hands of the person for whom it was intended. Jason uses pressure and keeps control of what his niece knows about the amount. This is where the legacy of the older Quentin takes its ugliest turn. Her uncle Quentin believed Caddy’s sexual life had injured an entire family. Her uncle Jason has found a way to turn the same belief into a regular income. The girl named Quentin pays for both ideas without having had any say in either.

What Jason Misses While Watching His Niece

Jason spends much of Friday trying to keep track of Miss Quentin and a man associated with the travelling show, identifiable by his red tie. His movements take him away from work and into a humiliating pursuit. At the same time he follows the cotton market, where he prides himself on seeing through people who believe they know better than he does. The two activities compete for his attention. Prices can move while he is out hunting his niece. His employer expects him at the shop. Each fresh consequence of his own decisions supplies him with another example of the burdens other people impose.

Miss Quentin is particularly hard to see clearly because Jason is almost the only person who gives us a sustained account of her everyday life. He notices her make-up, her clothes, her absences and the company she keeps. He has comparatively little curiosity about what it has been like for her to grow up in a house where her mother’s name can scarcely be mentioned. Readers who readily reject his insults can still find themselves accepting his choice of evidence. We know a great deal about where this girl is supposed to be during school hours. We know remarkably little about what she would like to do with the rest of her life.

The travelling show also matters to Luster. The quarter he will spend Saturday looking for would get him into it. Jason has tickets and, in front of Luster, burns them. He would rather destroy something another person wants than let that person enjoy it for free. Remember Caroline burning what she thinks are Caddy’s cheques and the episode acquires a particularly unpleasant family resemblance. Both mother and son like to demonstrate what they can afford to throw away. Luster has supplied the opening chapter with half its forward motion because he cannot afford the coin that would have made the tickets unnecessary.

By the time we catch up with Saturday, we can hear that day differently. Luster’s impatience with Benjy seemed at first like a simple failure of kindness. Now we know something about the evening before. He is a teenager who wants a small pleasure, has been taunted by a grown man and must spend the next day responsible for somebody else. Faulkner never needs to send us through the whole birthday a second time. The destroyed tickets do the work. A supporting character briefly comes into focus as someone who has a Friday of his own.

Easter Morning with Dilsey

On 8 April, Easter Sunday, Faulkner changes the terms of the telling. People often call this Dilsey’s section. The description is useful so long as one distinction stays clear. Benjy, Quentin and Jason each give a first-person account. Dilsey does not narrate the fourth section. A third-person narrator follows her through much of the morning and can also go elsewhere. After three brothers who have laid powerful claims to our attention, we finally see the physical effort it takes to get their household through breakfast.

Dilsey lights the fire, prepares food and answers demands that arrive from different parts of the house. Caroline’s dependence on her has never produced much willingness to recognise her authority. Dilsey can understand exactly what a situation requires and still have to spend precious minutes negotiating with someone less competent who has the power to dismiss her judgement. The family speaks of itself as a once-great house in decline. From the kitchen, the more immediate question is how long a Black woman who has already worked most of her life is expected to keep the place running.

Miss Quentin’s room is empty. She has gone out by the window, and the money Jason kept locked away is missing. He immediately understands the disappearance as a theft against himself. The reader knows that his hoard includes money diverted from Caddy’s payments. It would go too far to describe the sum as a precisely calculated repayment to the daughter. Miss Quentin has neither seen his accounts nor explained her intentions to us. What she has done is leave with the means to stay away for at least a while. Her mother once had to pay Jason for seconds of contact with her. This daughter has found an exit he cannot charge her to use.

Jason wants the sheriff to recover the girl and the cash. The sheriff’s reluctance exposes a difficulty that never arises when Jason is speaking to himself. An outsider might want to know why he had so much cash hidden at home and how he came by it. His insistence on being treated as the injured party is far more persuasive when nobody asks a second question. He sets off in pursuit himself. His search around the travelling show brings him into another confrontation and fails to recover either his niece or the money.

Faulkner gives Miss Quentin no farewell speech and no reassuring destination. Jason has lost the means to direct her movements. The reader loses sight of her at much the same moment. That is an unsettling limitation on any easy celebration of her escape. We have spent enough time with Jason to want the girl beyond his reach. We have spent too little time with her to know what she will find there. For once, her uncle and the reader have to live without further information about her whereabouts.

Dilsey takes Benjy to Easter worship with members of her own family. At church, the visiting Reverend Shegog initially seems an unpromising speaker. Then the sound of his voice changes the congregation’s attention, and the Passion and Resurrection become experiences in which the worshippers participate together. Throughout the novel a sound has been able to transport one person across time while leaving everyone nearby puzzled by the response. Here a voice carries a roomful of people with it. Dilsey weeps among people who recognise what they are hearing.

The Easter service gives Dilsey an understanding of time spacious enough to hold grief and continuance together. It also gives her a morning that belongs to a community beyond her employers. Both things matter. To make her simply the good woman who endures what the Compsons inflict would be to leave her permanently standing in their kitchen. At church she brings Benjy into company, listens to a preacher and participates in a history for which the fortunes of one white Mississippi family supply a very small measure indeed.

Why the Carriage Turns at the Monument

Later that Sunday, Luster takes Benjy out in the carriage. In Jefferson’s square stands a Confederate monument. The accustomed route carries Benjy round it in a particular direction. Luster turns the horse, Queenie, to the left instead. Benjy begins to roar. Jason intervenes violently, striking Luster and forcing the carriage back onto its familiar course. Once the buildings and objects along the street begin passing in the sequence Benjy expects, he grows quiet. In his hand is a broken flower.

The immediate cause of his distress is wonderfully simple after a novel in which explanations have so often been withheld. Benjy knows this journey through the order in which things appear. Luster changes the order. Restoring the route allows Benjy to recognise his surroundings again. There is no evidence that he understands what happened to Jason’s money or that he is expressing a judgement on his niece’s escape. By now the reader ought to be capable of doing what Caddy did instinctively as a girl. Attend to the particular thing that has upset him.

Yet the means of bringing him comfort matter just as much as the comfort itself. Jason can put a horse on the familiar side of a monument. He cannot bring Caddy home, retrieve the family pasture, recover the money or compel Miss Quentin to submit. The one success he enjoys that Sunday comes where a younger Black boy is holding the reins and an intellectually disabled man is crying out in public. The violence falls on somebody with less power than Jason. The relief belongs to Benjy. Faulkner makes us witness both in the same few seconds.

The monument locates this family habit in a public square. Generation after generation can learn which way to pass a memorial before anybody asks what the memorial celebrates. Benjy needs a dependable route for reasons particular to him. Jefferson has arranged its streets around an inherited account of the Southern past. For one short ride those two sorts of familiarity coincide. The novel earns its disturbing calm by letting us feel the genuine relief of a man who can recognise his surroundings while still seeing the blow that has just fallen on the boy driving him.

At the fence on Saturday, Caddy came back for an instant because a word crossed the grass. On Sunday, the things Benjy knows slide past in their proper order, and she is still gone. The person who once washed off her perfume to ease his distress would have understood why he cried at the turn. Nothing in the corrected route can supply the difference between being quiet again and having your sister there to understand you.

Sources

Next Reads

  • One Hundred Years of Solitude Explained — Another family passes names down the generations until remembering who did what becomes essential to understanding its history.

  • Beloved Explained — Toni Morrison also lets the past enter the present through voices, sensations and memories that different members of a household experience differently.

  • Jane Eyre Explained — For a counterpoint to Caddy, follow a heroine who gets to tell her own story and choose which parts of a secretive household the reader sees.

Previous
Previous

The Talented Mr Ripley Explained: Tom, Dickie Greenleaf and the Novel’s Ending

Next
Next

Wide Sargasso Sea Explained: Antoinette, the Name Bertha and the Final Dream