The Story Behind Tolstoy’s War and Peace
Everybody at the Party Understands Napoleon
In a St Petersburg drawing room in 1805, it takes only a few minutes to establish who Napoleon is, what threat he poses and what a decent Russian ought to think about him. Then Pierre Bezukhov opens his mouth. Newly returned from abroad, he admires aspects of the French Revolution and rather wants to discuss them. His hostess would sooner he had broken a glass. Across the room, Prince Andrei Bolkonsky is so tired of evenings like this one that going to war seems an excellent prospect. Leo Tolstoy begins War and Peace with people who can explain the affairs of Europe over supper. He spends the rest of the novel finding out what each can see when events reach their own front door.
Pierre Inherits a Fortune and Andrei Goes to War
Pierre’s great social disadvantage is that he takes conversation seriously. His hostess, Anna Pavlovna, has assembled her guests with considerable skill. Certain people must meet, certain opinions must circulate and nobody ought to become so interested in an argument that the evening escapes her control. Pierre listens to what people are saying and answers accordingly. Prince Andrei, who knows exactly how the room operates, rather likes him for it.
Their friendship survives a considerable difference in temperament. Andrei has married a charming young woman, Lise, and discovered that domestic society makes him restless. He hopes military service will give his abilities a proper field. Pierre possesses neither his friend’s discipline nor his sense of direction. He is the illegitimate son of the immensely wealthy Count Bezukhov. While his father lives, Pierre’s position is uncertain enough for people to be careless about whether he notices their contempt.
In Moscow, the Rostovs offer another way into Russian society. Count Rostov welcomes guests with a warmth that makes the cost of entertaining them feel like somebody else’s concern. His son Nikolai wants to join the army. His young daughter Natasha rushes into adult company with the confidence of a child accustomed to being loved there. Their cousin Sonya, an orphan brought up in the household, loves Nikolai. She shares the children’s pleasures while already understanding that her place in the family depends on other people’s generosity.
At the dying Count Bezukhov’s house, a more calculating group gathers. Prince Vasili Kuragin has an interest in whether Pierre’s father has made arrangements to legitimise him and leave him the estate. The struggle over the papers looks peculiar from Pierre’s position. People who barely explain where he ought to stand are urgently concerned with documents that will determine his future. When the arrangements in his favour prevail, he becomes Count Bezukhov and one of the richest men in Russia.
The change provides Pierre with a poor education in judging affection. Invitations multiply and his awkwardness begins to look attractive to people who found it embarrassing before. Prince Vasili brings him into close contact with his beautiful daughter Hélène. Pierre can recognise that he does not know her very well. He finds it much harder to disappoint a roomful of people behaving as though he has already proposed. He marries her. A man whose first appearance showed him capable of defending Napoleon before a hostile audience proves quite unable to tell his prospective father-in-law that he would like another week to think.
What Andrei Sees Above Austerlitz
Andrei leaves his pregnant wife at Bald Hills, the estate ruled by his formidable father. His sister, Princess Marya, lives there under a regime of exact timetables, intellectual exercises and personal criticism. She loves her father and fears him. Lise will have her company during the pregnancy, although neither woman chose the household arrangement that allows Andrei to pursue his ambition.
Serving on General Kutuzov’s staff, Andrei hopes for the sort of opportunity that once made Napoleon famous. He understands the appeal of distinctions earned in action. His more dangerous belief is that a sufficiently able observer might identify the decisive moment, take charge of it and afterwards know what he accomplished. Tolstoy begins testing that belief in an encounter involving Captain Tushin, a modest artillery officer whose battery keeps firing in circumstances of extraordinary confusion.
Tushin’s contribution looks quite different at headquarters afterwards. Guns have been lost, explanations are required and the captain struggles to describe his conduct before his superiors. Andrei witnessed enough to speak on his behalf. It is an early instance of a problem that will become central to the book. The person best placed to contribute to an action may be exceptionally badly placed to produce the official account. For a little while, what the army knows about Tushin depends on whether someone with better social standing will interrupt.
At Austerlitz in 1805, Andrei sees Russian troops falling back. He picks up a standard and runs forward, hoping to rally them. Here at last is the moment he once imagined with such pleasure. Then he is struck and falls. From the ground, his field of vision fills with the enormous, quiet sky. The movement of the battle that had seemed so urgent minutes before occupies a remarkably small part of what he can now see.
Napoleon himself comes across the wounded officer and remarks on him. Earlier, recognition by this particular observer might have seemed the highest distinction a young soldier could receive. Lying injured, Andrei can barely attach importance to the emperor’s presence. His former ambition depended on seeing himself from something like Napoleon’s position, as a figure in a great historical composition. His physical situation has changed the composition altogether. He wants to live.
Nikolai Rostov’s introduction to battle has a different embarrassment. On encountering the possibility that an enemy soldier might actually kill him, Nikolai thinks of how much his own family loves him. At home his death would be an event of unbearable importance. The stranger bearing down on him has no access to that household knowledge. Later, among friends keen to hear a good account of his adventures, Nikolai discovers how much easier it is to tell a recognisable cavalry story than to describe the thoughts that went through his head.
Andrei survives and returns to Bald Hills just as Lise is giving birth. She dies, leaving an infant son, also called Nikolai. Andrei sees reproach in the expression of the woman whose domestic claims he found so irksome. He had imagined returning from service as a changed man and resuming his life from a more honourable position. The person to whom he might have made a different sort of husband has run out of time to meet him.
The Things Pierre Cannot Put Right With Money
Pierre’s marriage to Hélène has given him excellent standing and very little intimacy. Rumours connect her with Dolokhov, a bold, calculating army officer who has enjoyed Pierre’s hospitality. At a dinner, a succession of provocations becomes more than Pierre can bear. He challenges Dolokhov to a duel. Pierre has almost no relevant experience and only an uncertain understanding of the offence for which he is prepared to kill a man.
He wounds Dolokhov. The result settles nothing about Hélène’s conduct. It does give Pierre an opportunity to discover that the man he shot has a mother who adores him. A duel was supposed to convert a confused social injury into a clear encounter between two men. It has enlarged the circle of people who may be hurt and left the original question exactly where it was. Pierre separates from Hélène and begins looking for a way to live that will give his decisions more substance.
He finds temporary direction in Freemasonry. Its moral teachings and ceremonies appeal to his desire for brotherhood and practical reform. On a tour of his estates, he orders improvements for the peasants and takes pleasure in the evidence presented to him that life is getting better. His managers understand more about presenting an estate to its visiting owner than Pierre understands about running one. Some measures look splendid on the day of inspection while leaving burdens in place or creating fresh ones. His intentions are sincere. Sincerity is a frail instrument for checking an account prepared by somebody whose interest is to please you.
When Pierre visits Andrei, their conversation tests what each has learned. Pierre speaks with the confidence of a man who has recently found a creed. Andrei distrusts ambitious schemes and has drawn his responsibilities closer to home. Yet an argument can accomplish something other than winning assent. Talking with Pierre gives Andrei a glimpse of a larger life at a time when he has tried to reduce his expectations to the smallest dimensions grief will permit.
At the Rostovs’, Nikolai acquires a less abstract understanding of money. Dolokhov, whom Sonya has refused to marry, draws him into a card game that leaves him owing forty-three thousand roubles. Nikolai must ask his father to pay. The old count loves him and will somehow find the money. That willingness is what makes the interview so painful. A father who habitually receives his son without calculation must now find an enormous sum because his son sat too long across a table from a man with a grudge.
That same evening, Nikolai hears Natasha sing. For a moment the debt loses its power to define the whole world. Natasha does nothing heroic and has no idea what has happened. Her singing restores to her brother the physical sensation of belonging to a life larger than his disgrace. In a lesser account the music might cancel the debt emotionally and let everybody move on. The money still has to be found. Both things are true of the evening, and Tolstoy lets us hear the singing before the bill is settled.
Why Natasha Cannot Wait a Year
Visiting the Rostovs’ country estate, Andrei overhears Natasha at an open window, so delighted by the night that she can scarcely bear to go to bed. She has no idea he is listening. That matters to a man exhausted by social performances. The girl at the window has managed to suggest a world worth rejoining without having the slightest interest in persuading him to join it.
Later, at a grand ball, Natasha faces the very ordinary misery of standing beautifully dressed while nobody asks her to dance. Andrei asks her. The happiness that crosses her face supplies more encouragement than any practised flirtation could have done. He begins visiting the family and comes to love her. His old father, unwilling to welcome the marriage, imposes a year’s delay. Andrei agrees and goes abroad. He tells Natasha she remains free to withdraw.
From Andrei’s side, the permission seems generous. He will honour his promise without binding a much younger woman irrevocably to hers. From Natasha’s side, an engagement has been announced to very few people, her lover has left the country and she must somehow pass twelve months sustaining a relationship whose daily life has scarcely begun. The arrangement gives her considerable freedom in principle and very little help with the business of being seventeen and missing somebody.
In Moscow, Hélène draws Natasha into the company of her brother Anatole Kuragin. Anatole is handsome, attentive and already married, a fact Natasha does not know. He excels at making what he wants this evening feel like the only matter worth discussing. Natasha has spent months trying to treat a distant promise as more real than what is before her. In Anatole’s presence she makes the opposite mistake. The intensity of an immediate feeling seems proof that it must be trustworthy.
She breaks with Andrei and agrees to run away with Anatole. Sonya learns enough to intervene, and their hostess, Marya Dmitrievna, prevents the elopement. Pierre knows about Anatole’s existing marriage. He confronts him and gets him out of Moscow. Once Natasha learns the truth, the future for which she has destroyed her engagement disappears. In her distress she takes poison, then calls for help and survives.
Andrei cannot offer the forgiveness he once thought a decent man ought to extend to a woman who had gone wrong. Pierre visits Natasha and sees what public accounts of the scandal leave out: a very young person in considerable pain who has lost the right to expect kindness and badly needs some. Trying to comfort her, he says that if he were free and worthy he would ask for her hand. It surprises him almost as much as it does her. On the way home he sees the great comet above Moscow. Other people can find an omen of disaster in the sky. To Pierre, on this particular night, its brightness belongs to the discovery that he still has love to give.
The Invasion Reaches Bald Hills
In 1812 Napoleon invades Russia. The first campaigns allowed officers to go abroad, fight battles and bring imperfect accounts home. This time the direction of travel is reversed. Estates, servants, children and stores of grain lie along the route of an advancing army. A family can no longer sustain the distinction between the men who go to war and the people who wait for news.
At Bald Hills, the old Prince Bolkonsky struggles to accept the danger in time to act. After a stroke, he becomes dependent on Marya in ways neither would have wished. Their last exchanges allow an affection to emerge that years of rigorous lessons and humiliating remarks have made difficult to express. His death grieves her. It also releases her from an authority whose loss she has sometimes imagined with a relief she can hardly forgive in herself.
At the family’s Bogucharovo estate, the peasants resist the evacuation arrangements. Marya initially believes an offer to distribute grain will resolve matters. The peasants have their own fears, expectations and rumours about what a French advance might mean. They need the horses and carts as much as their landowner does. Her astonishment that a generous offer fails to secure consent makes an instructive companion to Pierre’s inspection of his estates. Both discover how little the owner of a place may know about the people who make it function.
Nikolai arrives and uses his authority as a cavalry officer to break the resistance. Marya experiences his intervention as a rescue, and each remembers the other afterwards. Their attraction has arisen under awkward financial conditions. She is an heiress. The Rostovs are deeply in debt, and Nikolai has long imagined himself bound to Sonya. He would despise a man who married for money. It does not follow that he can avoid loving a woman who possesses it.
Meanwhile, Andrei has chosen to serve with a regiment. His men know him, and he understands more of their condition than an officer looking at marks on a map. On the eve of Borodino, Pierre visits him hoping to understand the coming battle. Andrei’s outlook has hardened with the invasion of his country and the loss of his home. He has even less patience than before with the idea that officers moving units on paper can predict how frightened, exhausted men will behave when the firing starts.
What Pierre and Andrei Experience at Borodino
Pierre goes to the battlefield as a civilian. His clothes and conspicuous hat make him an oddity among men with jobs to do. At first he sees a magnificent spectacle. Light, smoke, distant movement and the contours of the ground combine into something almost impossible to reconcile with the knowledge that people are being killed. His view changes as he approaches a Russian artillery position and stays there long enough to recognise the men working around him.
The soldiers initially find him an encumbrance. Gradually a sort of welcome develops. Their jokes and their absorption in their work allow Pierre to believe he has been admitted into a fellowship. Then casualties mount. Familiar figures disappear. The same area of ground keeps its geographical identity while losing the particular people who made it intelligible to him ten minutes earlier. He came hoping to see a battle. What he can actually witness is what becomes of a handful of men at one battery.
Andrei spends much of the battle under fire with his regiment in reserve. It is a particularly cruel situation for someone who once dreamed of decisive action. Men can be killed while waiting for a useful order, and courage has to find an expression in continuing to stand where one has been put. A shell lands near him. In the instant before it explodes, the grass and the air seem intensely desirable. He is terribly wounded.
At the dressing station, Andrei recognises Anatole Kuragin among the wounded. Anatole has suffered an amputation and is crying in pain. Andrei has imagined an encounter with this man often enough. He had meant to hold him to account for Natasha. Now there is nothing Anatole can say or do that interests him as much as the fact of another human being suffering within reach. The compassion that comes to Andrei here is inseparable from the circumstances of the meeting. He could maintain his hatred of a rival imagined whole and triumphant. It proves much harder to hate the man on the next table.
Who wins Borodino? The answer depends on what victory is supposed to accomplish. The Russians subsequently withdraw and the road to Moscow opens to the French. Yet Napoleon has failed to destroy the Russian army or obtain the political settlement he needs. Tolstoy gives particular weight to the fact that the Russians have endured the encounter and can continue the war. For Pierre, leaving the field amid the human consequences, the desire to give one side possession of the word victory already seems a poor reason to put anybody else through such a day.
The Rostovs Have to Decide What Their Carts Are For
Kutuzov authorises the abandonment of Moscow. Keeping the army intact requires a decision whose public appearance could scarcely be worse. Military glory attaches easily to the defence of a city and uneasily to the general under whom it is given up. In Tolstoy’s account, Kutuzov’s particular gift is an ability to endure that appearance when ordering men to fight would satisfy public feeling at a cost the army cannot afford.
The Rostovs prepare to leave their Moscow home. Household possessions have been selected and packed. Wounded soldiers need transport. Natasha is appalled that carts capable of carrying men to safety should leave full of family belongings. Her father sympathises. Her mother understands, with rather more financial realism, that a deeply indebted family cannot go on treating its property as infinitely replaceable. The possessions come off and the wounded travel.
Natasha has no idea that Prince Andrei is among those being carried away. That ignorance gives her intervention a particular value. She acts for strangers, and only later discovers that one of those strangers is the man she once hoped to marry. Learning that he is nearby, she goes to him. He receives her with love and forgiveness. Their meeting has none of the conditions that defeated their engagement: no father’s permission to obtain, no year to count down, no difficult explanation that can be postponed until a happier occasion.
She nurses him, and his sister Marya eventually joins them. The two women once had ample reason to mistrust each other. Caring for the same person gives them exact things to understand about one another: what a movement means, when he is tired, what can still bring comfort. As Andrei approaches death, both sense a change in his relation to the people beside him. His growing acceptance feels to them like a withdrawal from the very love that has reunited them. He dies with their care around him, leaving a son who will have to discover his father through other people’s memories.
What Captivity Gives Pierre
Pierre stays in Moscow as the French occupy it. He has devised a private mission to kill Napoleon, partly supported by calculations with letters and numbers that appear to assign him a historical destiny. He has seen thousands of men at Borodino fail to control events a few yards from where they stand. Even so, he finds the idea of changing Europe’s future single-handed surprisingly difficult to relinquish.
Occupied Moscow gives him other work. Amid fires and confusion, he rescues a child and intervenes when French soldiers assault a woman. He is arrested. A man who hoped to introduce himself to history by killing an emperor becomes a prisoner through helping people whose names will never reach an official account of the campaign.
Suspected of involvement in the fires, Pierre witnesses French soldiers execute prisoners. He has every reason to believe he is about to be shot himself. Afterwards, what disturbs him includes the behaviour of the men carrying out the killings. He can see signs that individual soldiers find the work dreadful. Their discomfort fails to save the prisoners. An act may require the co-operation of numerous people without any one of them experiencing himself as the person who chose it.
In captivity Pierre meets Platon Karataev, a peasant soldier who shares food, tells stories and attends to the immediate requirements of living among other men. Karataev offers him a potato when food matters more than all the property he owns. Pierre has sought moral instruction in lodges, books, philanthropy and private reckonings of Napoleon’s destiny. This lesson begins when a stranger notices he needs to eat.
When the French leave Moscow, the prisoners are driven west with the retreat. Karataev weakens and can no longer keep up. Pierre cannot bring himself to go back to him. He hears a shot and understands what has happened. His love for his companion does not produce a rescue; his later gratitude has to contain the memory of the moment he looked away. Karataev remains important to Pierre partly because there will never be a chance to repay the kindness on equal terms.
A Russian raiding party liberates the prisoners. Among those taking part is Petya, Natasha and Nikolai’s younger brother, desperately eager to prove himself useful among experienced soldiers. He has been listening to their conversation, offering what he has and delighting in being included. He rides into action and is killed. The encounter that gives Pierre his life back takes the youngest Rostov from his family. An account recording a successful rescue would get the military outcome right and leave the Rostovs’ entire experience of it out.
Who Marries Whom, and Why Does the Story Continue?
News of Petya’s death devastates the Countess Rostova. Natasha, herself grieving for Andrei, gives her mother sustained, exhausting care. Nothing in the work requires Natasha to decide that her own loss matters less. Somebody she loves needs her in the room. For a young woman who has lately experienced time as a succession of things she can no longer bear to remember, that need supplies a reason to get through another hour.
Pierre’s wife Hélène has died, leaving him free to marry. When he sees Natasha again in Marya’s company, he barely recognises the subdued woman grief has made of her. Then a familiar expression returns. Their intimacy develops through conversation about what they have endured, including Andrei’s last days and Pierre’s captivity. At the ball years earlier, Natasha needed an invitation to enter a roomful of life already in progress. With Pierre she finds someone to whom part of her life that looks finished can still be told.
The epilogue carries the family story forward to 1820. Pierre and Natasha are married and have children. Nikolai has married Marya. His father’s death left the Rostov finances in dreadful condition, and he took responsibility for the debts. Marriage to a wealthy woman changes his circumstances, but Tolstoy also takes an interest in the unglamorous question of whether Nikolai can manage land well. He learns to judge work, recognise competence and take the conditions of agricultural life seriously. The young man who once asked his father to find forty-three thousand roubles has become somebody on whose judgement a household can depend.
Sonya, who released Nikolai from his promise in a letter written under family pressure and with complicated hopes of her own, remains in the extended household. Its happiness looks different from where she sits. She has loved its members since childhood and repeatedly made herself useful to them. The family finds it remarkably easy to enjoy the results of her renunciation. Readers have spent enough time with the girl who prevented Natasha’s elopement to recognise a cost the contented married couples seldom count.
Natasha has largely withdrawn from the social world that once delighted in her singing and dancing. Home, children and Pierre absorb her. Tolstoy treats her domestic absorption with considerable approval, although the earlier scenes allow a reader to feel more ambivalence. We heard what her singing could do for a despairing brother. We saw her make a decision about the wounded that several older people had been unable to reach. Remembering those capacities lends the picture of her marriage more tension than a simple declaration of happiness can resolve.
Why War and Peace Ends With a Boy’s Dream and an Argument
Peace has given the families children, work and a common table. It has also given Pierre time to recover an appetite for politics. He believes men of conscience should associate to resist abuses in government. Nikolai insists that he is bound by his oath and would obey an order even if it placed him against Pierre. The disagreement arises inside a loving family between two men whose wartime conduct has given each good reason to trust his convictions.
Andrei’s son, young Nikolai Bolkonsky, hears them. He admires Pierre and longs for a father he cannot properly remember. That night he dreams of glory, an army and his father’s approval. The novel opened with Andrei hoping war might give him an opportunity to become the hero of a great story. His son inherits the longing without any direct memory of Austerlitz or the dressing station at Borodino. Peace has allowed the adults to raise a boy safely. It has also allowed a new imagination of war to grow up in their house.
The family story ends there, but the book continues into a second epilogue about freedom, necessity and the writing of history. Tolstoy challenges the habit of explaining the movement of whole peoples by naming the wishes of exceptional rulers. An emperor issues many commands. Some correspond to what eventually happens and others become impossible, arrive late or vanish from the story. Select the successful orders afterwards, arrange them neatly and the commander begins to look as though he possessed knowledge nobody had at the time.
The novel has already given us a way to test that argument. Why does a wounded Russian officer travel out of Moscow with the Rostovs? To answer, we need the outcome at Borodino, Kutuzov’s decision to abandon the city, the availability of transport, the family’s preparations and the actions of the people who loaded the carts. Yet anyone who omitted a young woman’s horror at the thought of leaving wounded strangers behind would miss the reason there was room for Andrei. Fifteen years of emperors, battles and political argument have made the scale of history visible. Natasha, standing beside a loaded cart, has shown us the size at which somebody can actually do something about it.
Sources
War and Peace — Leo Tolstoy, translated by Louise and Aylmer Maude. Complete English text, including the 1805 and 1812 campaigns, the family narrative and both parts of the epilogue. www.gutenberg.org
War and Peace: Full Book Summary — SparkNotes. Supporting reference for the family relationships, separation, captivity and reunions. SparkNotes
War and Peace — Sotheran’s First-Edition Catalogue. Bibliographical details of the six-volume Russian first edition issued in 1868–69. aba.org.uk