Macron Says It’s Time to Discuss Ukraine Joining NATO. Who Would Have to Agree?

Does Russia Have a Veto Over Ukraine Joining NATO?

Why All 32 NATO Allies Would Have to Agree to Admit Ukraine

One Ally Could Hold Up Ukraine’s NATO Invitation.

Emmanuel Macron put Ukraine’s NATO membership back into the peace debate in Berlin on 19 November 2026. The French president argued that Russia’s demands made this the moment to discuss it. Turning that proposal into an invitation would take the agreement of all 32 NATO members. Each ally would then have to approve Ukraine’s accession under its own national procedures. Ukraine itself would take the final legal step.

The setting helps explain the significance of Macron’s words. He was speaking alongside Volodymyr Zelenskyy after a meeting of countries supporting Ukraine. Those governments can make commitments about the help they will give Kyiv. A NATO invitation requires a decision by a different body, the North Atlantic Council. The people on the platform in Berlin could influence that decision. They could not take it on behalf of the alliance.

Who Could Block Ukraine’s Invitation?

Article 10 of the North Atlantic Treaty gives the existing members the power to invite another European state to join. The candidate must be able to uphold the treaty’s principles and contribute to the security of the North Atlantic area. The decision belongs to the allies collectively, and they reach it by consensus.

In practice, that means there is no majority vote for Macron to win. If 31 governments are ready to invite Ukraine and the remaining government maintains an objection, there is no invitation. France, Britain and the United States each have the same formal standing on that question as Iceland or Luxembourg.

Russia has no seat on the North Atlantic Council and no treaty right to approve or reject a new member. Its influence operates through the calculations of governments that do sit on the council. An ally worried about a direct conflict with Russia can withhold agreement. In that case, the ally exercises its own authority, even if Moscow welcomes the outcome.

The distinction also matters for Britain’s place in Ukraine peace talks. Who gets a chair at a particular negotiating table can change from one meeting to the next. Britain’s consent to NATO enlargement is required by treaty, whether or not a British representative attends a particular round of peace negotiations.

Why a President’s Yes Is Only the First Approval

Suppose all 32 allies agreed tomorrow to invite Ukraine to begin accession talks. Kyiv would have to confirm that it was willing and able to accept the political, military and legal obligations of membership. The allies would then sign an accession protocol, the document that allows Ukraine to join the treaty. That document would go back to every member country for approval.

Consider what that means in Washington. An American president could support an invitation and direct US diplomats to work towards it. At the ratification stage, the US Senate would still have to give its advice and consent, with two-thirds of senators present voting in favour. A diplomatic promise made to Kyiv could therefore face a separate decision in Congress months later. Each of the other allies follows its own constitutional procedure.

Only after all the allies had approved the protocol could NATO issue the formal invitation to accede to the treaty. Ukraine would complete its own procedures and deposit its instrument of accession with the US government, which holds the treaty documents. That deposit is the moment Ukraine would become a member. Washington’s role in receiving the document is an administrative duty. By then, the American decision on whether to admit Ukraine would already have been made.

Sweden Shows How Much Can Happen After an Invitation

Finland and Sweden applied together on 18 May 2022. NATO invited both to begin accession talks at the same summit in Madrid. Their talks concluded on the same day, and the allies signed their accession protocols on 5 July. Up to that point, the two applications had followed almost identical calendars.

Finland became a member on 4 April 2023. Sweden had to wait until 7 March 2024. Türkiye and Hungary delayed approval of Sweden’s protocol, with Hungary’s parliament giving its consent in late February 2024. For almost eleven months, Finland had the rights and obligations of membership while Sweden, its fellow applicant, was still waiting.

That history offers a precise way to read any future announcement about Ukraine. Even a joint statement from every NATO leader inviting Kyiv to begin talks would leave a consequential question unanswered. When would the last national approval arrive? For Ukraine, the answer would determine how long it remained outside the treaty’s collective-defence commitment.

Has NATO Already Promised Ukraine Membership?

At Bucharest in 2008, NATO leaders agreed that Ukraine and Georgia would become members in the future. At Washington in July 2024, the allies described Ukraine’s progress towards membership as an “irreversible path”. In the same paragraph they set out when they could issue an invitation: “when Allies agree and conditions are met”.

Those words leave two judgements with the alliance. One concerns Ukraine’s preparations, including democratic and security-sector reforms and the ability of its armed forces to operate alongside allied forces. The other concerns the willingness of existing members to take on a defence commitment to Ukraine. Progress on the first question cannot settle the second. Both declarations also left the date open.

Macron’s intervention addressed that second judgement. His argument in Berlin was that Ukraine needed continued backing to enter peace negotiations in a strong position, and that Russia’s demands gave allies a reason to discuss membership now. He was asking governments to consider what they were prepared to offer Kyiv. He announced neither an accession agreement nor a timetable.

Could Ukraine Join While the War Continues?

Article 10 contains no express rule requiring a European country to be at peace before it can receive an invitation. The harder question for Ukraine is what allies would be undertaking under Article 5 while Russia is already attacking it.

Article 5 commits the allies to treat a qualifying armed attack on one as an attack on all. Each ally must assist the country attacked and decides what action it considers necessary. That action can include armed force. The treaty therefore creates a duty to help while leaving individual governments some discretion over the military response.

Zelenskyy gave that distinction a practical context in Berlin when he called for more air defence. A government can decide today to supply equipment to Ukraine and decide separately what it will offer next time. Admitting Ukraine would mean accepting a continuing treaty obligation. Before agreeing, allied governments would have to consider how that obligation would apply if Russian attacks continued after accession. Macron’s remarks did not settle how they would answer.

For anyone following the diplomacy, the next document worth watching for is a North Atlantic Council decision inviting Ukraine to begin accession talks. It would show that every ally had accepted a step the declarations at Bucharest and Washington left for another day.

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

UK Brexit Reset Deal Explained: What Changes for Food, Work and Study, and When?

Next
Next

Why Did Japan’s Prime Minister Meet Putin While a Japanese Journalist Remains Detained?