Why Do Indigenous People Gather Above Plymouth Rock on Thanksgiving?

Why a Speakers’ Stage Matters on Plymouth’s Cole’s Hill This Thanksgiving

What Did Wamsutta Frank James Want to Tell Plymouth in 1970?

In 1970, Plymouth Invited A Wampanoag Man To Speak And Then Asked Him To Change His Words.

Wamsutta Frank James had been invited to a dinner marking 350 years since the arrival of the Mayflower. The anniversary organisers wanted to see his speech in advance. James had written about what happened to his people’s land and what it meant for a Wampanoag man to be alive, in Plymouth, on an occasion the state had chosen to celebrate. When the organisers offered him a replacement speech, he declined. On Thanksgiving Day, Indigenous people gathered on Cole’s Hill, overlooking Plymouth Rock. It was the first National Day of Mourning.

Indigenous people and their allies have returned each Thanksgiving since. They come to honour ancestors, mourn the lives and homelands lost to colonisation, and hear Indigenous speakers describe struggles continuing in their own communities. The choice of hill matters. From Cole’s Hill, a listener can look down at the monument to the Pilgrims’ arrival while hearing what that arrival meant to the people who already lived there.

In 2026, United American Indians of New England has announced the gathering for noon on Thursday 26 November. Fifty-six years after James refused the substitute speech, even the question of who will help put up the speakers’ stage has brought the organisers and the town back to court.

What Did Wamsutta Frank James Want to Say?

James, an Aquinnah Wampanoag man, began his prepared remarks by acknowledging that his audience had reason to take pride in its ancestors. He asked them to imagine what the same anniversary looked like from his place at the dinner. Their forebears had established a colony. His had seen their homeland pass into other hands. An invitation to the same table could hardly make those two inheritances feel alike.

One of his clearest examples was a fence. Wampanoag people understood boundaries, James wrote. What changed under English settlement was the spread of fences and stone walls, and the power behind them. Land on which a family depended for food could become somebody else’s property. A transaction recorded in a colonial court might settle the question for the new owner while leaving another family with no way to reach a hunting ground.

James also challenged his audience to consider why so many Americans spoke about the Wampanoag in the past tense. He described people who had concealed their ancestry because acknowledging it carried social or economic costs. Outsiders could mistake the silence that prejudice produced for evidence that a people had disappeared. The man invited to deliver the anniversary address was himself evidence of how badly that assumption failed.

Towards the end of the speech, James turned to the future. Wampanoag people could learn English, compete for jobs and participate in American public life while retaining their culture and deciding for themselves what that meant. The anniversary organisers had offered him a speaking part in a story about their ancestors. He had written a speech with something to say about his children.

Why Gather Above Plymouth Rock?

At the waterfront, a stone portico shelters Plymouth Rock, the traditional symbol of the Pilgrims’ landing. Up on Cole’s Hill stands a statue of Ousamequin, the Wampanoag leader often known as Massasoit. Nearby, a plaque explains why people have gathered there on Thanksgiving since 1970. In a short walk, a visitor encounters three different choices about whom Plymouth should remember.

The statue gives Ousamequin a permanent place in the landscape. The annual gathering gives living Indigenous people a chance to speak there in their own words. That distinction would have been familiar to James. Massachusetts was willing to honour a Wampanoag contribution to the colony’s early years. Its anniversary planners found it harder to accommodate a Wampanoag man’s judgement about the consequences.

The plaque itself came out of a struggle. In 1997, police arrested 25 people during the Day of Mourning. The following year, the town and United American Indians of New England reached a settlement. It provided for a plaque near the statue commemorating the gathering, and another in Plymouth in memory of Metacom, Ousamequin’s son. It also set out arrangements for future Thanksgiving marches.

One clause captures how differently the two histories had been treated. In reviewing the proposed wording about Metacom, the agreement said the historical claims should face the same standard of proof Plymouth applied to its own traditional account of the rock. People negotiating over a few lines on a plaque had reached a much larger question. How much evidence does a town demand before it will put one community’s history on public display, and how much did it demand for the story already carved into its landscape?

What Does the Thanksgiving Story Leave Out?

Plymouth already had a name when the English arrived. Patuxet was a Wampanoag community devastated by an epidemic shortly before the Mayflower crossed the Atlantic. Tisquantum, widely remembered as Squanto, returned there in 1619 to discover that his family and much of his community had died. For an English settler in 1620, the site offered somewhere to build. For Tisquantum, it was the place he had been trying to get home to.

Ousamequin made an alliance with the settlers in 1621. Each side agreed to help defend the other, a commitment that helps explain the presence of a large Wampanoag party at the English harvest gathering later that year. Edward Winslow, a colonist who described the occasion, recorded that Ousamequin came with about ninety men. The Wampanoag hunted five deer and presented them to members of the colony. The gathering lasted three days.

Those details of the harvest gathering at Plymouth are worth keeping. They show Ousamequin acting as a leader with allies to assess, people to feed and gifts to distribute. The difficulty comes when the story ends on the third day and leaves the impression that the two peoples had settled how they would live together.

Within the lifetime of Ousamequin’s children, English livestock and settlements had cut into places where Wampanoag families hunted, fished and gathered plants. His son Metacom became a leader in the conflict that began in 1675 and is remembered as King Philip’s War, using the English name for him. Metacom was killed in 1676. Native survivors of the war faced enslavement and displacement.

Father and son are commemorated within walking distance of each other in Plymouth. In the familiar Thanksgiving story, the father brings venison and the curtain falls. The memorial to his son gives a visitor a reason to keep walking.

What Happens on the National Day of Mourning?

The gathering begins with Indigenous speakers on Cole’s Hill and includes a march through Plymouth’s historic district. United American Indians of New England welcomes non-Indigenous supporters. The speaking programme belongs to invited Indigenous participants, who choose what to say about their ancestors, their communities and current events. Someone attending for the first time can contribute simply by listening.

Some participants fast from sundown on Wednesday through the Thanksgiving afternoon. The organisers ask visitors to respect that observance by waiting until after the outdoor speeches and march to eat, unless they need food for medical reasons. For the 2026 gathering, they have announced boxed lunches after the march, mask requirements and a livestream for people who cannot attend in person. They expect the outdoor programme to finish at about 3pm local time.

It would be easy to see the fast and conclude that giving thanks is itself the objection. Wampanoag traditions of gratitude long predate the United States. The ripening of strawberries and the green corn harvest have each given people an occasion to give thanks. Indigenous families also make their own choices about the November holiday. The National Day of Mourning addresses a particular public claim that carries special weight in Plymouth every autumn. A meal shared in 1621 has come to stand for a whole relationship, including centuries the diners could never have foreseen.

Why Is the Speakers’ Stage in Dispute in 2026?

The 1998 settlement dealt with practical questions as well as monuments. It described how organisers would notify the town of a march and how Plymouth would assist with a stage and power for the speeches. Those provisions read differently once you know how the gathering began. A speaker can have the freedom to choose her words and still need somewhere to stand where the people who have come to hear her can do so.

On 16 November 2026, United American Indians of New England sought emergency court intervention over arrangements for this year’s event. A point of dispute is whether the town can require insurance and protection against liability as a condition of helping with the stage. The organisers say the conditions breach the settlement. Town officials say they support the observance and want protection against liability of the kind they seek for other public events. The town has also pointed to another site with a stage and power.

A practical alternative on a town plan carries a different meaning to people returning to the site of the first gathering. The invitation that James received in 1970 gave him a date, an audience and a place at dinner. What it failed to give him was room to say why the anniversary mattered to him. On Cole’s Hill, the people issuing the invitation are Indigenous. This Thanksgiving, as every year since, everyone else is welcome to come and hear what they have to say.

Sources

Next Reads

Previous
Previous

Why Did American Revolutionaries Commission a Peace Medal for the Wabanaki in 1777?

Next
Next

The Fields We Came Back To: Why Did Humans Start Farming?