The Charges, the Evidence and What the Jury Must Decide
Sonia Exelby Case: Why Florida Law Says You Cannot Consent to Your Own Killing, and What the Jury Must Decide
Sonia Exelby, a 32-year-old music tutor from Southsea in Hampshire, flew to Florida in October 2025, and her body was found in a shallow grave in Marion County a week later. The man accused of killing her, Dwain Hall, 54, of Ocala, has pleaded not guilty to first-degree murder and kidnapping. Closing arguments were heard on Friday 20 November 2026, and the jury will now decide the case. Hall denies the charges and is presumed innocent unless and until the jury finds otherwise.
The case has drawn attention on both sides of the Atlantic because of an uncomfortable fact that neither side disputes: the court has been told that Exelby travelled to the US wanting to die. That raises a question many readers have asked. If someone wants to be killed, is the person who kills them still a murderer? Under Florida law, the answer is yes. A person's consent does not make a killing lawful. The real legal fight in Ocala is about something else: whether the state has proved who killed her, whether she was held against her will, and whether the killing was planned.
Who Was Sonia Exelby?
Exelby lived in Southsea, part of Portsmouth on England's south coast, and worked as a music tutor. Her family described her in a tribute as a "truly beautiful person, inside and out", the BBC reported.
The court heard that she had lived with serious mental illness for many years. Her fiancé and partner of 16 years, Stevie Hunt, told jurors she had been in therapy for more than a decade, the Guardian reported. According to the BBC, Hunt said he had once taken her passport away for several months to stop her leaving the country, and had reported her use of online forums to the police.
On 10 October 2025, according to the prosecution, she told her family she was going to a sisters' weekend. Instead she flew from London Heathrow to Gainesville, Florida. She was reported missing on 12 October. British authorities raised the alarm with US investigators through Interpol, the international police co-operation body, on 13 October, NBC News reported, the same day she was due to fly home. Her body was found on 17 October.
The Short Answer: Consent Is No Defence to Killing in Florida
Florida's murder law, section 782.04 of the Florida Statutes, defines murder as "the unlawful killing of a human being" in particular circumstances. First-degree murder covers a killing "perpetrated from a premeditated design to effect the death of the person killed", and also a killing committed during certain serious crimes, including kidnapping. Nothing in the statute creates an exception where the person killed agreed to it.
Florida law goes further. Section 782.08, a provision dating back to 1868, says: "Every person deliberately assisting another in the commission of self-murder shall be guilty of manslaughter." In other words, Florida treats even helping someone to end their own life as a serious crime. Florida has no medically assisted dying law either. The campaign group Death with Dignity lists the state as having no such legislation.
If assisting a suicide is manslaughter, it follows that a person who carries out the killing themselves cannot rely on the victim's wishes as a defence. The court-watching site Justice Is A Process put the point plainly in its trial preview: "No one can consent to being killed, but the burden of proving who did it, and that it was planned, is the State's alone."
For UK readers, the position in England and Wales is similar. Consent is not a defence to murder, and since 2021 section 71 of the Domestic Abuse Act has stated in law that it is "not a defence" to say someone consented to serious harm "for the purposes of obtaining sexual gratification". Encouraging or assisting suicide is a separate crime under the Suicide Act 1961.
So Why Does Consent Still Matter in This Trial?
Although consent cannot excuse a killing, it does matter to the second charge, kidnapping, and through it to the murder charge.
Under section 787.01 of the Florida Statutes, kidnapping means "forcibly, secretly, or by threat confining, abducting, or imprisoning another person against her or his will and without lawful authority", with intent to commit a felony, inflict bodily harm or terrorise the victim. The words "against her or his will" are central. If the jury is not sure that Exelby was held against her will, the kidnapping charge fails.
That matters because of how Florida defines first-degree murder. A killing during a kidnapping is first-degree murder even without proof of premeditation, under a rule US lawyers call "felony murder". So the state has two routes to a first-degree murder conviction: proving that Hall planned the killing in advance, or proving that he killed Exelby while kidnapping her.
The prosecution's case is that Exelby changed her mind after arriving in Florida, and that Hall would not let her leave. The defence does not have to prove anything. The burden is on the state to prove each element "beyond a reasonable doubt", the US equivalent of the English test that a jury must be "sure".
What Both Sides Agreed Before the Trial Began
Unusually, part of the background was agreed before the first witness spoke. According to the Daily Mail's The Trial podcast, Judge Timothy McCourt told prospective jurors that Exelby "had suffered a lifelong history of depression and mental illness and was actively seeking someone to assist her with the efforts to end her life".
Hall's lawyer, Junior Barrett, referred to that in a short opening statement, which Law&Crime's Cathy Russon transcribed in full. Barrett reminded jurors that the judge had read them "a set of facts that we all agreed on", and said: "We believe that when you listen to all the facts and evidence in this case you will arrive at a decision that Dwain Hall did not murder Sonia."
So the trial was never about whether Exelby once wanted to die. It is about what happened after she arrived, and whether the state can prove that Hall killed her unlawfully.
The Prosecution Case, as Reported From Court
Everything in this section is the prosecution's case or evidence given by witnesses, as reported by journalists in court. None of it has been tested by a verdict.
Assistant State Attorney Amy Berndt told jurors that Exelby met Hall, whose online username was "Alpha Sadist", on a fetish website about two years before her death, the BBC reported. Berndt alleged that he "manipulated her for years", that he "targeted her because of her mental illness", and that he had demanded $4,000 (about £3,000) to kill her. A first plan to meet in March 2025 failed, the court heard, and the meeting was rearranged for October.
Berndt said Exelby was "trying to find someone who would kill her" and that, when Hall "finally got her alone, thousands of miles away from home, completely incapable of making any rational decisions, he stabbed her to death and buried her body".
According to investigators and reporting by the Guardian and Fox 35 Orlando, Hall collected Exelby from Gainesville airport and drove her to an Airbnb in Reddick, north of Ocala, that she had booked. The court heard he had bought rope and a shovel shortly before she arrived. The BBC reported that location data from the Life360 app placed him at the burial site on 12 October, and that security footage showed him buying a large tarpaulin at a Lowe's DIY store earlier that day.
The most important evidence on the kidnapping charge is what Exelby wrote while she was with him. The Guardian, citing the arrest affidavit, reported a text message to a friend in which she said she felt scared and trapped: "I'm sorry, he keeps taking my phone, he doesn't trust me with it. He made it clear there was no way out." Court TV reported that the message went on: "No one will find me in time." Prosecutors rely on these messages to argue that she had changed her mind and could not leave.
Jurors were also shown a short video, deleted from Hall's phone and recovered by investigators, in which Hall can be heard questioning Exelby about what she had been "consenting to", the BBC and Court TV reported. Prosecutors say the video shows coercion, not consent. A clinical neuropsychologist told the court that her level of vulnerability was "exceptionally high", according to the BBC.
The physical evidence includes a shovel found in Hall's garage that investigators say carried Exelby's DNA, and a knife recovered from the home of a friend in Ohio. The BBC reported that Hall had posted the friend a package, telling him there "might be a big storm coming for me". A crime laboratory biologist told the court that blood on the knife matched Exelby's DNA profile, and that Hall was "excluded as the source". A medical examiner testified that she had been stabbed four times, WCJB reported.
Investigators first identified Hall, NBC News reported, through attempts to charge Exelby's bank card via a roadside assistance business that he owned.
3:11 PMTaylor Tailored
What Hall Has Said
Hall did not give evidence, and the defence called no witnesses, WCJB reported. In the US, the Fifth Amendment to the Constitution protects a defendant's right not to testify, and jurors are told they must not hold that decision against him.
The jury did hear Hall's own account through a recorded police interview lasting several hours. According to the BBC, he first denied knowing Exelby, then made what he called a full retraction to "clear my conscience". He told officers he had been "mentoring" her online, "wanted to make her life better" and did not want her to kill herself. He said: "She did not want to be found. She did not want to be returned home."
Court TV reported that Hall admitted the two had sex but continued to deny killing her. During cross-examination, Barrett questioned the lead agent, Rebekah McKinzie, about her interviewing tactics, and she agreed that Hall had never said outright that he killed Exelby, according to The Trial podcast.
The defence has not, in any reporting we have seen, argued that Exelby's wishes made a killing lawful. Its stated position is simply that Hall did not murder her.
Why Hall Cannot Face the Death Penalty
First-degree murder is a capital offence in Florida, but prosecutors are not seeking execution. The Telegraph reported that British police refused to share "crucial evidence" unless US prosecutors agreed not to seek the death penalty. A spokesman for the Florida State Attorney's Office told the paper that "there was a total refusal on the part of the UK to share crucial evidence unless we agreed that we would not seek the death penalty", describing it as the "first time we have ever encountered" this.
That position follows a 2020 UK Supreme Court ruling in a terrorism case involving two men from the so-called Islamic State "Beatles" cell, which found the government had acted unlawfully by sharing evidence with the US without assurances against execution, LADbible reported, summarising the Telegraph's account.
Berndt also told the court that she had refused Hall's repeated requests for a plea deal after speaking to Exelby's family, who did not want one, according to LADbible and the Telegraph.
What the Jury Must Decide
The jury of 12, chosen from Marion County residents along with two alternates, must reach a unanimous verdict. Unlike in England and Wales, where a judge can accept a majority verdict of 10 to 2, US criminal juries must agree unanimously to convict for serious crimes, as the US Supreme Court confirmed in Ramos v Louisiana in 2020. If they cannot agree, the judge can declare a mistrial and the state can try the case again.
The jurors face four main questions:
Are they sure Hall killed Exelby?
If so, did he act from a premeditated design, meaning he decided to kill her beforehand?
Was she confined against her will, with the intent the kidnapping law requires?
If they are not sure of first-degree murder, does the evidence prove a lesser offence?
WCJB reported that the judge has gone through the lesser offences that jurors may consider if they do not find Hall guilty of first-degree murder. Under Florida law these can include second-degree murder, an unlawful killing by an act "imminently dangerous to another and evincing a depraved mind" but without premeditation, under section 782.04(2), and manslaughter under section 782.07. Kidnapping can carry the lesser alternative of false imprisonment.
What Each Outcome Would Mean
The sentences differ sharply. Because the death penalty is off the table, a conviction for first-degree murder carries a mandatory sentence of life imprisonment without parole under section 775.082 of the Florida Statutes. The judge would have no discretion.
Second-degree murder is a first-degree felony, punishable by up to life in prison. Manslaughter is a second-degree felony, normally punishable by up to 15 years. Kidnapping is a first-degree felony, punishable by up to life.
If Hall is acquitted on every count, he cannot be tried again for the same offences, under the US constitutional protection against "double jeopardy". After a conviction, the defence could appeal to Florida's appellate courts, but the state cannot appeal an acquittal.
VERDICT INSERT: What the Jury Decided
[VERDICT INSERT. Replace this paragraph within three hours of the verdict, using one of the prepared versions in the publishing package. Verify the verdict on each count, the time and any sentencing date with two sources before publishing.]
What Happens Next
As of Friday afternoon UK time on 20 November 2026, closing arguments had been heard in Ocala and the jury had not returned a verdict. Ocala is five hours behind the UK, so a verdict reached during the Florida court day would arrive in the UK evening.
If Hall is convicted of first-degree murder, the life sentence is automatic, so the formal sentence could follow quickly. If the jury convicts only of lesser offences, the judge would have a range of sentences to choose from, and a separate sentencing hearing would be expected. Exelby's relatives, eight of whom flew from England for the trial according to the Daily Mail, would be entitled to address the court.
Whatever the result, the case has raised questions in Britain about how vulnerable people are targeted online, and about how far UK police will help US prosecutors when a defendant could face execution. Those debates will continue after the verdict. For the jury, the questions are narrower: who killed Sonia Exelby, whether she was free to leave, and what the evidence proves.
This article discusses suicide and violence. If you are struggling, help is available. In the UK and Ireland, you can call Samaritans free on 116 123. In the US, call or text the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline on 988.
Sources
BBC News: Dwain Hall 'murdered woman for own sadistic pleasure', court told (17 November 2026). Prosecution opening, the $4,000 allegation, the March 2025 plan, Stevie Hunt's evidence, the defence line.
BBC News: Man made video before woman's death, court hears (19 November 2026). The recovered video, the knife and package to Ohio, DNA evidence, Life360 data, the neuropsychologist, Hall's police interview.
The Guardian: Prosecutors allege British woman 'trying to find someone who would kill her' lured to US and murdered (19 November 2026). Not guilty plea, the text message, the shovel, Barrett's opening, Hunt's evidence.
WCJB TV20: Prosecution, defense rest case in trial of Ocala man accused of murdering UK woman (19 November 2026). Hall not testifying, closing arguments on 20 November, lesser offences, the medical examiner.
WCJB TV20: Jury seated for Ocala man accused of murdering UK woman (16 November 2026). Twelve jurors and two alternates, the Airbnb in Reddick.
Court TV: 'No one will find me in time': Jury hears victim's voice (18 November 2026). The message to a friend, the video, Hall's denial in interview.
NBC News: Florida man arrested in death of British woman (November 2025). Interpol alert, how Hall was identified.
Daily Mail: Harrowing letter of British piano tutor (November 2026). Relatives in court, jury make-up, no death penalty.
Fox 35 Orlando: Florida man arrested after UK woman allegedly pays him to torture, kill her (November 2025). Airport pickup, purchases, investigation timeline.
The Telegraph: Sonia Exelby murder suspect 'tried 100 times to cut deal for lighter sentence' (15 November 2026) and LADbible: Why man accused of murdering Sonia Exelby can't face death penalty (16 November 2026). Death penalty assurances, plea requests.
The Trial podcast (Daily Mail): The Jury, My Time's Up and Dwain Hall Chooses Silence. The judge's agreed facts, cross-examination of the lead agent.
Cathy Russon on X: defence opening statement transcript (17 November 2026). Barrett's opening in full.
Justice Is A Process: State of Florida v Dwain Hall. Judge, charges and the consent point.
Florida Statutes 782.04 (Murder), 782.07 (Manslaughter), 782.08 (Assisting self-murder), 787.01 (Kidnapping) and 775.082 (Penalties).
Domestic Abuse Act 2021, section 71. Consent to serious harm is not a defence in England and Wales.
US Supreme Court: Ramos v Louisiana (2020). Unanimous verdicts for serious crimes.
Death with Dignity: State status map. Florida listed as having no assisted dying legislation.
Next Reads
What Happens When a Jury Can't Agree in England and Wales? Majority Verdicts and Retrials Explained. How the British system differs from Florida's unanimous jury.
Sandra Birchmore: Why Matthew Farwell Was Found Guilty. Another US murder trial built on digital and forensic evidence.
True Crime: Courtney Clenney—The Miami High-Rise, The Knife, And The Question A Jury Has To Answer. Another Florida case that comes down to one question for the jury.
Can a Victim Ask for a Longer Sentence? What a Victim Personal Statement Can Change. What families can and cannot influence after a verdict.
Nick Reiner Will Not Face Death Penalty As Murder Case Continues. Why prosecutors sometimes take execution off the table.