What Happens to Tom in Greece?
13 Times a Writer Hid the Truth in Plain Sight
A doctor records the time he left a friend’s house. A little boy fills his pockets with stones. A woman borrows a necklace for a party. Of the three, the necklace looks like the detail worth remembering. That leaves the doctor free to go home and the boy free to choose stones of just the right size. A good writer knows how much can happen while our attention is elsewhere.
Some of the greatest plot twists in literature are still closely guarded secrets. Others have become so familiar that a reader can know the answer years before picking up the book. Both belong here. The ranking weighs the surprise on a first reading, how much of the story changes when you learn the truth, and what there is to come back for once the secret is out. Novels, short stories and a Greek tragedy compete on the same terms. A writer who can turn the world upside down in four pages deserves a seat at the table.
13. The Gift of the Magi — O. Henry
Della has a dollar and eighty-seven cents to buy her husband a Christmas present. She has counted it three times. We meet her at the end of all the bargaining and penny-pinching that produced this miserable sum, which makes her next decision feel almost extravagant. She sells her beautiful long hair and spends the proceeds on a platinum chain for Jim’s gold watch. She can already imagine him taking it out in company.
Jim comes home carrying the expensive ornamental combs Della has admired in a shop window. He bought them by selling his watch. Each has spent the one thing that would have made the other’s gift immediately useful. There is a particularly good beat between the two disclosures. Della remembers that hair grows back, recovers her excitement and asks Jim to get his watch. For a moment she sees a perfectly sensible way to salvage Christmas. We have just enough time to see the second disappointment coming.
O. Henry earns the symmetry by letting husband and wife have different reactions to it. Della goes through terror, delight, tears and renewed enthusiasm. Jim eventually suggests they put the presents away and have dinner. The story finishes with its famous comparison to the wise men, but the most convincing declaration of love may be that practical suggestion. Somebody still needs to cook the chops.
12. The Necklace — Guy de Maupassant
Mathilde Loisel borrows what appears to be a diamond necklace from her wealthy friend Madame Forestier. For one evening at a ministerial ball, strangers look at Mathilde exactly as she has always wished to be seen. Then she goes home, takes off her wrap and discovers the necklace is gone. She and her husband buy a replacement in secret. Paying for it takes ten years.
The final encounter takes place after the debt has been cleared. Mathilde, hardened almost beyond recognition by work, can at last afford to be frank. She tells her old friend what happened with something approaching pride. Madame Forestier replies that the lost necklace was imitation jewellery, worth at most five hundred francs. The Loisels paid thirty-six thousand for its replacement.
It is easy to remember this as a little sermon about vanity. Try reading it from the husband’s side. He gives up money he had earmarked for himself so Mathilde can buy a dress, helps search the streets, signs the ruinous promises to lenders and works extra hours. His loyalty is admirable at every stage, and every act of loyalty helps sustain a disastrous misunderstanding. What makes the last conversation so painful is its ordinariness. The two women could have had a version of it the morning after the ball. An awkward visit might have cost Mathilde a friendship. Avoiding it cost both spouses a decade.
11. Strange Case of Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde — Robert Louis Stevenson
Imagine opening Stevenson’s book without knowing what the names Jekyll and Hyde mean. A respected doctor has made a will that favours an appalling young man. The beneficiary can get into his house. The doctor’s friends would very much like to know what this outsider has on him. Blackmail is an excellent explanation for the facts, particularly to a Victorian gentleman aware of how much a friend might pay to keep a youthful indiscretion quiet.
The respectable doctor and the man who benefits from his apparent disappearance share a body. Stevenson distributes the discovery among different witnesses. Utterson, the lawyer, can investigate documents and doors. Dr Lanyon can report the physical impossibility he has seen with his own eyes. Only Jekyll can explain what it felt like to take the drug and find himself free to behave as Hyde. The book saves that testimony until the reader has already seen what his freedom costs other people.
One detail gives the old revelation much of its continuing bite. Jekyll takes practical steps to make Hyde’s life comfortable, right down to furnishing lodgings for him. Consider the time and money that requires. The transformation may happen in seconds, but the arrangements have been made by a man with leisure, resources and a clear head. Knowing the secret puts those quiet afternoons of preparation back into the horror story.
10. The House of Asterion — Jorge Luis Borges
Asterion lives in an immense house. He roams its courts and galleries, invents games and imagines a second Asterion visiting so he can show someone around. That last pleasure is recognisable to anyone who has watched a lonely child supply both sides of a conversation. It is also an ingenious way of introducing a labyrinth. Asterion has spent his whole life there. Why would he describe his home as a puzzle simply because strangers get lost in it?
At the close, the voice changes. Theseus speaks to Ariadne about how little resistance the Minotaur offered. In a few words the house acquires its familiar shape, the speaker acquires a bull’s head, and the visitor Asterion has awaited as a redeemer becomes the hero who kills him. Readers who recognise the name Asterion early get a different experience. They spend longer in the company of a creature whose fate they know and whose expectations they now understand.
Borges leaves just enough of the old heroic adventure outside the frame. Theseus has evidently experienced something surprising too. He went in prepared to fight the monster at the heart of the labyrinth. He comes out with a question about why the encounter was so easy. For once, the reader can answer a question the victorious hero cannot. We have been inside that house a little longer than he has.
9. Great Expectations — Charles Dickens
Pip has good grounds for believing Miss Havisham is paying to turn him into a gentleman. She is rich. She has brought him into her house and encouraged his fascination with Estella. The lawyer Jaggers acts for her, and the same Jaggers arrives with news of Pip’s anonymous benefactor. There is one rather large gap in the case. Nobody has actually told Pip the money is hers.
The truth walks up the stairs to his London lodgings on a foul night. Abel Magwitch, the escaped convict Pip helped as a frightened boy, has made a fortune in Australia and spent it on him. He has come back, at mortal risk, for the pleasure of seeing his gentleman. Pip can scarcely bear to look at him. There is terrible comedy in the difference between the reunion one man has rehearsed for years and the one the other is struggling to survive.
Dickens gives this revelation space to change the direction of a life. Pip has imagined his rise as a long courtship culminating in marriage to Estella. Magwitch has imagined much the same expenditure as the creation of a son. Pip must now decide how to treat the living man who paid his bills. The boy on the marshes offered a hungry prisoner food before he knew enough about society to feel embarrassed by him. Becoming worthy of that boy takes the adult Pip rather longer than becoming a gentleman.
8. Jane Eyre — Charlotte Brontë
The interruption at Jane’s wedding is devastating partly because it takes so little time. A few formal words about an existing marriage can undo an entire imagined future. Edward Rochester already has a wife, Bertha Mason, who lives under guard at Thornfield. The party goes back to the house, where Rochester produces the woman whose existence he has concealed from Jane.
Readers have heard laughter in the corridors, watched a fire break out in Rochester’s bedroom and seen the damage done to Jane’s wedding veil. Grace Poole is such a convenient explanation for the disturbances that it takes some effort to remember who controls the household, pays Grace and decides what Jane gets to know. Rochester has been able to manage the courtship because it takes place inside a world he owns. At the church door, a fact from outside that world finally catches up with him.
The scene’s emotional weight falls on what Jane does afterwards. She still loves him. She can imagine how easily she might forgive him, and she has very little money with which to build a different life. For her to leave under those circumstances makes the cost of independence painfully specific. There is another reader’s reckoning waiting upstairs, too. The frightening presence in Jane’s love story has a name, a brother and an earlier claim on the man telling everyone how unfortunate his life has been.
7. An Occurrence at Owl Creek Bridge — Ambrose Bierce
Peyton Farquhar stands on a railway bridge during the American Civil War, a rope around his neck. When the execution begins, the rope appears to break. He plunges into the water, fights his way to the surface and escapes through a landscape of astonishing clarity. At the end of his journey his wife is waiting. He reaches for her. In the story’s actual present, his body hangs beneath the bridge. The entire escape has occupied his last instant of consciousness.
Bierce makes an extraordinary wager on how readers understand time. Give us a succession of physical tasks and we start measuring the minutes ourselves. A man must free his hands, get air, evade gunfire and cover the miles home. We almost never stop to ask whether the clock outside his experience has advanced at all. Why would we? We have been counting strokes beside him.
On a second reading the exaggerated precision of his senses begins to feel ominous. The world has come into focus past the point at which an exhausted swimmer could perceive it. There is something politically uncomfortable about the escape as well. Farquhar is a slaveholder devoted to the Confederate cause. Bierce still manages to enlist our most elementary narrative reflex on his behalf. Put a man underwater and most of us will hold our breath until he reaches the surface.
6. Rebecca — Daphne du Maurier
The second Mrs de Winter is living the particular misery of competing with a dead woman who seems to have been good at everything. Rebecca could sail, entertain and run Manderley. Her handwriting has more personality than the new bride can summon in conversation. Worst of all, Maxim appears incapable of speaking about his late wife. His silence looks like the one tribute the newcomer can never hope to match.
Then a boat is found with Rebecca’s body inside. Maxim tells his second wife that he hated Rebecca, shot her and sank the boat himself. Du Maurier gives us a moment to absorb what it means to be alone with a husband capable of murder. The narrator is busy absorbing what it means that he never loved Rebecca. After all those pages spent sharing her jealousy, there is a fair chance the reader feels a flicker of the same relief.
That split second is the reason the novel ranks so high. Our sympathies have taken shape through small domestic humiliations, the wrong clothes and ill-judged remarks. They hardly seem consequential until we catch ourselves hoping a killer gets away with it. Rebecca, meanwhile, remains dependent on other people to tell her story. The confession answers the question that has tormented the narrator throughout her marriage. Whether the man who fired the shot deserves such complete authority over the dead woman’s character is another matter.
5. Fingersmith — Sarah Waters
Sue Trinder knows how the confidence trick is supposed to work. She will enter a country house as maid to Maud Lilly and help a swindler known as Gentleman marry the heiress. Once married, he can have Maud confined to an asylum and lay hands on her fortune. Sue’s great difficulty is that she comes to love the woman she has agreed to betray. By the time the doctors appear, we have had ample opportunity to worry about whether Sue can go through with it.
The doctors take Sue. Maud has helped arrange for the maid to be identified as the disturbed young wife. Worse still, Sue’s perfectly accurate protests sound precisely like the behaviour the doctors have been briefed to expect. We have spent so much time trusting Sue’s intimate account of the household that it takes a moment to grasp how little that account is worth to anybody standing in the room.
Waters then gives Maud the floor and runs the clock back. Familiar gestures between the women turn out to have required agonising decisions on both sides. Later revelations about their births and Mrs Sucksby’s involvement open the swindle wider still, but that first exchange of identities is the unforgettable one. Try imagining what evidence you could produce if the people who brought you to a locked institution had already explained that you would claim to be somebody else. Sue has the entire readership on her side and cannot call a single one of us as a witness.
4. The Lottery — Shirley Jackson
On a June morning, the people of a village gather in the square for an annual drawing. The children get there first. The men talk about farming and taxes. Tessie Hutchinson arrives a little late, jokes about her household chores and squeezes through to join her family. Jackson allows her exactly the entrance you would give a minor comic character in a story about village life. In so few pages, that small kindness does an enormous amount of damage.
The Hutchinson household draws the marked slip. A second drawing identifies Tessie herself. The villagers pick up stones and close in. In retrospect, the children’s industrious collecting in the opening scene was the most candid piece of information anybody gave us. They knew precisely what they would need. It was the adult conversation about arrangements and the shabby black box that made the occasion seem complicated.
Jackson is especially sharp about which traditions survive. Parts of the ceremony have fallen out of use. There is talk of replacing the box. People elsewhere have even abandoned the lottery. Yet somebody thinks to put pebbles into the hands of Tessie’s little son. There is no shortage of practical imagination when it comes to making sure the killing can proceed. The word “lottery” usually invites a private fantasy about what it might be like to win. By the end Jackson has given us an equally private question. What did we think the stones were for?
3. Atonement — Ian McEwan
As a girl, Briony Tallis sees pieces of an adult story and makes them fit the wrong explanation. Her accusation helps send Robbie Turner to prison for an assault he did not commit. The war follows. Robbie retreats towards Dunkirk, Cecilia becomes a nurse, and eventually we find the lovers together in a London flat. The meeting with Briony is awkward. Robbie has every reason to be furious. That lack of easy forgiveness makes the scene feel particularly trustworthy.
Decades later, the elderly Briony discloses that she wrote the account we have been reading. Robbie died in France. Cecilia died in the bombing of Balham Underground station. They never shared that London reunion, and Briony never stood before the two of them to hear what they thought of her. She has written the meeting that history denied them and that she lacked the courage to seek with Cecilia while she could.
What lingers is Robbie’s anger in the invented scene. A less accomplished novelist might have given herself a pardon and exposed the wish fulfilment at once. Briony knows that a difficult encounter will persuade us. The skill she spent a lifetime acquiring has made her better at exactly the thing that proved so destructive in childhood. Yet the invented pages also give Robbie and Cecilia room to be funny, impatient and alive together. When Briony takes that room away, its loss feels like a second bereavement. McEwan makes the reader feel what is seductive about granting the lovers a little more life, even as we discover who has been deciding how much they get.
2. Oedipus the King — Sophocles
A plague is ravaging Thebes. Its king undertakes to find the murderer of his predecessor, Laius, and bring the city relief. Oedipus has already saved Thebes once by answering the Sphinx’s riddle. Asking questions is the thing he does better than anybody else. Few investigations have begun with a more convincing reason to put precisely the wrong man in charge.
Years earlier, Oedipus killed a stranger at a crossroads. The stranger was Laius, his father. The widowed queen whom Oedipus subsequently married, Jocasta, is his mother. Sophocles arranges the discovery so that a messenger meaning to reassure Oedipus does more harm than an enemy could have managed. News that Polybus has died naturally seems to release Oedipus from the prophecy that he would kill his father. To ease his remaining fear about marrying his mother, the messenger explains that the couple who raised him were his adoptive parents. Now the king needs to know whose child he was.
For an audience familiar with the myth, the suspense sits in the widening distance between Jocasta and her husband. She has understood enough and begs him to stop. He hears in her plea the possibility that his birth was too humble for her taste. Even this late, his excellent intelligence can produce an explanation that allows him to ask one more question. Aristotle singled out the messenger’s intervention in his discussion of reversal. More than two millennia later, you can still feel the impulse to reach across the stage and tell a well-meaning man to hold his tongue.
1. The Murder of Roger Ackroyd — Agatha Christie
Dr James Sheppard has several qualifications for the job of telling a Hercule Poirot mystery. He is observant, enjoys access to his neighbours’ confidences and has a sister whose appetite for gossip keeps information flowing through the house. Above all, he understands how to write about an eccentric detective with the mixture of admiration and amusement readers expect from a sensible companion. Christie puts the murderer in the one job most of us forget to include on the list of suspects.
Sheppard killed Roger Ackroyd. He was blackmailing Mrs Ferrars, and the letter she left for Ackroyd threatened to expose him. When he describes his final visit to the victim, Sheppard gives the time at which the letter arrived and the time at which he left. The murder fits inside the interval. Your eye can move from one sentence to the next in considerably less time than it takes to wonder what the doctor did with those minutes.
There is a pleasure here peculiar to the printed page. Once Poirot has named the killer, you can put a finger between the last few leaves, turn back and examine the passage for yourself. The words are still in the same order. The doctor has not acquired a different voice. What changes is your estimate of how much co-operation you owe a man simply because he has offered to tell you a story.
Sophocles gives us an investigator hunting himself. Christie separates those roles just enough to put a third person in danger of embarrassment. Poirot investigates, Sheppard edits, and the reader supplies the innocence that the doctor can hardly claim outright. On a second visit to King’s Abbot, the giveaway is there in the narration of an ordinary evening. There are ten minutes missing. Christie can account for every one of them. Can you?
Next Reads From Taylor Tailored
Pride and Prejudice Ending Explained — Darcy’s Letter and Lydia’s Scandal
Mad Mabel Ending Explained — Who Is Daphne and Who Is Peter?